What was once a remote fishing village on an isolated tropical island is now a vibrant town filled with people from all walks of life. Fishing in Fort Myers Beach is ingrained in the very fiber of the island, and it’s easy to see why. Crystal clear waters, abundant wildlife, and beautiful sandy beaches all make it paradise on Earth.
Nestled on Estero Island, one of the most beautiful barrier islands in all of Florida, Fort Myers Beach has no choice but to attract tourists. Its stunning scenery is like something out of a movie, and the locals know how to appreciate it. You’ll come across dolphins, manatees, rays, turtles, and native birds, as well as the numerous fish species that inhabit these waters.
This island’s rich history has been in the making since the Calusa people called it their home. And as the Calusa left and new people took up residence, one thing stayed just as important as it always was. Fishing. Fort Myers Beach grew from a small village into a famous resort town, but it’s never forgotten its roots.
Best Fish to Catch in Fort Myers Beach
There’s no end to the list of fish species that you can catch in the waters of Fort Myers Beach. This town has been blessed with an amazing location, great weather year-round, and rich waters. This makes it a fishing haven, so read on for more information on the prized fish you can expect to find here.
Redfish
A true Florida favorite, Redfish has enjoyed a special status in Fort Myers Beach, ever since the native Calusa people used to fish these waters. The locals have always loved the taste of Redfish, and it’s been an important part of their diet for generations. Today, this beautiful fish is considered a delicacy, and hooking it a real feat.
While Redfish is abundant in the back bays and mangroves out of Fort Myers Beach, it will not come quietly. Prepare for a real challenge and get ready to work for your dinner – it’s a feisty one. The fight is worth it though, as not a lot of fish can challenge it when it comes to meat quality.
Snook
Snook has been a favorite of Fort Myers Beach residents for decades. One of the most prized game fish in Florida, it holds a special place in the hearts of the locals. They’ve been targeting it for generations, ever since they were reeling it in with nothing more than a handline and a spoon.
And it’s still as exciting! Going after Snook in these waters will take you back in time so you can bask in the rich history of this stunning town. This is a feisty fish, and you can be sure that it’ll put up a good fight if you find it at the end of your line. Getting a big one out of the water will surely reward you with some bragging rights and admiration from the locals.
Tarpon
Ask anyone in Florida what the top game fish is, and they’ll all say it’s the “Silver King.” Tarpon has enjoyed legend status for centuries, and it never lost its appeal. This majestic beast is one of the most famous fish in the world, and people from all over flock to this area to break their personal records.
Boca Grande, the Tarpon Capital of the World, is just a boat ride away. If you’re looking to get in on the action, but want to avoid the crowds – look no further. When it comes to Tarpon fishing, Fort Myers Beach can easily give Boca Grande a run for its money. Head out and you’ll have an exciting battle on your hands, watching in awe as this beautiful creature leaps out of the water to get off the hook. It’s legendary for a reason!
King Mackerel
And yet another King! Kingfish is a beloved nearshore target that local anglers enjoy going after. They’re known to roam the warmer waters off the coast of Estero and Sanibel Islands. Finding them isn’t easy, but once you do, it’s a feeding (and fishing) frenzy! Hook some live bait at the end of your line and watch them ferociously fight you for it.
These mouthwatering fish will have you licking your fingers and wanting more. And it’s healthy, too. The residents of Fort Myers Beach have been eating it for a long time, so catch your own meal and see what all the fuss is about. Trust us, you’ll be coming back for years to come – if not for the food qualities, then for the fun of the challenge.
Snapper and Grouper
Snapper just had to be on our list. Mutton, Mangrove, and Yellowtail are abundant in the bays and mangroves around the island, while you’ll find the coveted Red Snapper by heading over to the reefs of the Gulf. Luckily, Fort Myers Beach has amazing access to both, so you won’t have an issue whatever you decide.
Grouper is another trophy you can get your hands on, and the reefs and wrecks of the Gulf hold some big ones. Hopping on a boat and heading out can yield amazing results. You’ll find Gag, Red, and Goliath Grouper all in the cards.
And More!
The list of fish you can run into on a fishing adventure in Fort Myers Beach is too long to fit in one blog post. However, they sure deserve a mention. Sheepshead, Pompano, Flounder, Speckled Trout, Black Drum, and more inhabit the shallows. The deep blue holds big Tuna, Mahi Mahi, Marlin, Sailfish, and a variety of Shark species.
What anglers said about fishing in Fort Myers Beach
How to Go Fishing in Fort Myers Beach
With so much water around, and great access as well, Fort Myers Beach is a versatile fishery that’s got something for everyone. You can enjoy it in a variety of ways, so keep on reading and find what best works for you!
Charter Fishing
Easily the most productive way to enjoy the water, charter fishing in Fort Myers Beach is a way of life. Ever since Estero Island was first populated, people have been going out and exploring the Gulf on boats. Today, there’s a rich charter fishing industry, and you won’t have to look very far to find the perfect one.
If you’re looking to cover more ground and see the surrounding islands, as well as visit the deeper offshore waters, this is the way to go. You can find an experienced local captain who knows all the best spots. They’ll show you all the riches of this laid-back town, and you’ll be reeling fish in left and right!
Kayak Fishing
Another way to go about your Fort Myers Beach fishing adventure is by renting a kayak and exploring the shallows. With numerous back bays, mangroves, and flats, this is the perfect way to feel closer to nature and explore it non-disruptively. You’ll paddle out in awe of the beauty, and you’ll have a special experience to remember.
It’s easy to paddle out from the island, which is why you’ll find kayak rentals dotted along the beach. Just take a walk down the boardwalk and you’re sure to find a rental place you like. The other side of the island will give you easy access to the waters of Matanzas Pass and San Carlos Bay, so you’ll have a variety of options to choose from.
Shore Fishing
Fort Myers Beach really embodies the essence of fishing, with the whole town just made for it. Your job is made easy here, as there are great spots to relax and sink a line pretty much everywhere. With such an abundance of fish and the perfect spots to spend your day by the water, it’s no wonder that it’s evolved into a fishing utopia.
Surf fishing is especially popular, as the beach stretches all along the Gulf coast of Estero Island. Move away from the swimming and sunbathing folk, and you’ll see endless fishing opportunities. Also, pier fishing is a favorite pastime of the locals, and it’s been the town’s central spot for decades.
Where to Go Fishing in Fort Myers Beach
Anywhere! No, really – go anywhere on the island and you’re sure to come across a great spot to dip your toes and cast a line. But if you’re looking for specific recommendations, keep on reading and see what we’ve come up with.
- Fort Myers Fishing Pier: The famous pier on the west end of Estero Island has a long tradition of being the best fishing spot in town. And The Lynn Hall Memorial Park is right next to it, with fun for the whole family. You’ll catch fish like Spanish Mackerel, Flounder, Pompano, Spotted Seatrout, Redfish, Sheepshead, Mangrove Snapper, and Snook.
- Bowditch Point Park: This 17-acre park is located at the north tip of the island. It offers nature walks, a great beach, and stunning views. Surf fishing at Matanzas Pass is amazing, with targets like Redfish, Snook, Snapper, Trout, Sheepshead, and more.
- Estero Island Beaches: The 7-mile beach on the Gulf of Mexico offers amazing entertainment and fishing opportunities. And if you manage to find a spot not crowded by tourists, you’ll have your hands full with Snapper, Mackerel, Kingfish, Cobia, Snook, and Redfish all biting.
- Matanzas Pass Preserve: With nearly 60 acres of unspoiled nature, this preserve will have your jaw on the floor. You can enjoy amazing natural views and plentiful wildlife as you target some of the prized fish in the mangroves. Redfish, Snook, Trout, Snapper – they’re all in the cards.
- Lovers Key State Park: Known for spectacular beach weddings, this well-preserved natural gem is an amazing fishing destination too. Best explored by kayak, you can enjoy the mangrove forests and beaches. You can target Snook, Snapper, Redfish, Trout, Sheepshead, Flounder, and more.
Fort Myers Beach Fishing Seasons
Deciding on when to go fishing in Fort Myers Beach depends solely on your wishes and ambitions – the species you want to go after will determine the best time. The weather is great year-round and there’s always something you can target. The summer months see a lot of tourists, so if you want to avoid the crowds, visit in the fall.
Fort Myers Beach Fishing Tournaments
If you’re looking for some more adrenaline, join one of the tournaments in town. The Grouper Grapple Offshore Fishing Tournament in August is a great way to have fun and get a prize. It’s for a good cause too – they use the event to get funds for helping out military veterans. For some family fun, join the 4th of July Kid’s Fishing Tournament and help your kids catch the biggest fish!
Fort Myers Beach Fishing Regulations
Despite the great weather and excellent year-round action, some species fall under strict regulations, so they may not be available when you visit. Always consult the FWC website before heading out. If you’re fishing with a local captain, they’ll be all clued up on the latest rules so you can consult them and fish in peace. They’ll also cover your Florida fishing license for you. However, if you’re heading out alone, you’ll need to get your own.
Why Fort Myers Beach? It Exudes Fishing!
There’s not much left to say. Fort Myers Beach is one of the rare Florida gems with untouched nature, rich history, and amazing beaches (it’s in the name, after all!). Fishing out here will feel like going back in time, and the wonderful locals will help you feel right at home. You’ll find your place in the sun and never look back.
Have you ever visited Fort Myers Beach? How was your trip? Did you try out the fishing scene? Tell us all about it in the comments below or ask any questions. We love hearing from you!
