Raystown Lake Fishing: The Complete Guide for 2025

Jan 24, 2025 | 8 minute read
Reading Time: 8 minutes

Tucked within the rolling Allegheny Mountains of central Pennsylvania, Raystown Lake is an angler’s sanctuary. Spanning over 8,300 acres of pristine waters, it offers some of the most rewarding fishing experiences in the Keystone State. Fishing in Raystown Lake promises something to people from all walks of life. 

An aerial view looking towards Raystown Lake in Pennsylvania on a clear day as it winds around lush green hills

The scenery surrounding Raystown Lake is as captivating as the fishing itself. Framed by lush forests and rugged mountains, this destination offers the perfect escape from routine. It’s easy to find the perfect casting spot, whether you’re after solitude or lively action.

In this guide, we’ll run you through everything you need to make that first cast. We’ll talk about top catches, techniques, spots, and more so that you’re ready to hit the waters. Let’s dive in!

Top Fish to Catch in Raystown Lake

So, what fish can you find in Raystown? The lake is packed with opportunities for anglers of all skill levels. Trophy-sized Stripers roam the deep waters, while Largemouth and Smallmouth Bass deliver consistent action closer to shore. Add Walleye and Crappie to the mix, and you’ve got a fishing menu that keeps everyone hooked. Let’s talk about the local crème de la crème in more detail:

Striped Bass

A middle-aged man in a baseball cap and blue raincoat holding a Striped Bass by its mouth vertically on a lake
Photo courtesy of Mike Salamon Guide Service

Wherever you find Striped Bass, they’re in hot demand. And that’s especially true when they’re landlocked. That’s why Striped Bass are the crown jewels of Raystown Lake. These predators thrive in the lake’s deep waters, with most catches ranging from 20 to 30 pounds

Spring and fall are the best seasons to target Striped Bass in Raystown Lake. During spring, the warming waters trigger a feeding frenzy, while fall sees them bulk up for winter. These fish prefer deeper parts of the lake, especially near the dam and submerged structures. 

Get ready to try trolling when pursuing thse speedsters. Deep-diving lures and umbrella rigs are particularly successful, mimicking the movements of bait fish. Live bait, such as shad or herring, also works wonders, especially when fished near steep ledges or underwater humps. Anglers who focus their efforts in the lake’s deeper sections will be rewarded with some of the most memorable catches Raystown has to offer.

Largemouth Bass

A man in a baseball cap and sunglasses smiles as he stands aboard a boat and holds a sizeable Largemouth Bass on a clear day
Photo courtesy of Awgul Fishing

While Stripers dominate the depths, Largemouth Bass rule the shallows, particularly around rocks, fallen trees, and vegetation. Largies average 12–16 inches, peaking from late spring through summer. The post-spawn period in spring offers some of the best fishing action in the lake, as the coves and inlets are abundant with bait fish.

The best techniques for targeting Largemouth Bass involve casting soft plastics, spinnerbaits, and crankbaits. The key here is accurate casting and a steady retrieve, which are crucial to enticing bites in the areas where Largies hang out.

The Seven Points Recreation Area and Hawn’s Bridge are prime locations for Largemouth Bass fishing. Both spots provide easy access to some of Raystown Lake’s most productive waters, especially during the warmer months. 

Smallmouth Bass

A man in a baseball cap standing on a boat on murky waters holding a Smallmouth Bass on a clear day
Photo courtesy of Reeltimebassfishing

Smallmouth Bass bring more spirit to Raystown Lake’s cooler, clearer waters. These Bass gravitate toward rocky outcroppings, drop-offs, and areas where the depth changes dramatically. Averaging 10–15 inches, with trophy catches often exceeding 18 inches, Smallies are a rewarding challenge for everyone. They’re particularly active during spring and fall, when the water temperatures hit their sweet spot.

Targeting Smallmouth Bass requires precision and the right tactics. Jigs, soft plastics, and crankbaits are go-to options, but success depends on working these lures close to rocky structures. They’re opportunistic hunters, striking hard when your bait moves naturally along their territory. 

Given their tenacious strikes, gear selection is key. A medium to medium-heavy rod paired with 8–12 lb test line provides the sensitivity and strength needed to handle their aggressive nature. Smallmouth Bass may not match the size of their Largemouth cousins, but they make up for it with an intense fight!

Walleye

A man wearing a lamp on his head and holding a Walleye in pitch darkness
Photo courtesy of Mike Salamon Guide Service

Walleye are another favorite in Raystown Lake, especially for anglers who love the thrill of night fishing. These fish stick to cooler, deeper waters by day but come alive after dark, hunting bait fish in the shallows. Come in late spring and summer to take advantage of the warm weather and red-hot action! 

Most fish range from 14 to 18 inches, though Walleye over 30 inches aren’t unheard of. Trolling is your best bet for landing them, and deep-diving crankbaits like Rapalas are sure to get their attention. If you’re coming during the day, bottom bouncers or live bait rigs with minnows work wonders in deeper zones. 

The secret to landing one is steady trolling as the sun sets. That’s when Walleye are on the hunt. And, boy, are the strikes are worth the wait! For those who enjoy patience and precision, Walleye fishing at Raystown is always worth the effort.

Lake Trout

A photo featuring an angler on a charter boat posing with a decent Lake Trout catch on a cloudy but warm spring day
Photo courtesy of Horrocks Outfitting

For those who enjoy the thrill of precision deep-water fishing, Lake Trout deliver every time. Lakers thrive in the coolest, most secluded areas of Raystown Lake, and can tip the scales at 20 pounds! Despite this, the average catch is usually within the range of 12–18 inches. Lake Trout are most active in winter, when the water is coldest, but fall also offers a chance to reel in a few.

Success in Lake Trout fishing here hinges on reaching the right depth. These fish typically stay up to 80 feet below the surface, making downriggers essential. Trolling with deep-diving lures or live bait, such as minnows, entice the most strikes. Hit the lake’s deepest zones, particularly near the dam where Lake Trout often school, for the best action.

How to Go Fishing on Raystown Lake

Now that you know which fish call Raystown Lake home, it’s time to dive into how to catch them. From trolling the deep waters for Stripers to casting near submerged structures for Largies, success here means using the right technique. 

Naturally, the best way to explore the lake is by heading out with a local guide. They’ll make sure you learn about the lake and test your angling skills. But that doesn’t mean you shouldn’t know what to expect…

Trolling

A trolling rod sticks out from the side of a boat on a lake on a sunny day, with land visible ion the distance

Trolling is a must-know technique at Raystown Lake, especially for Striped Bass, Walleye, and Lake Trout. By dragging lures or live bait behind a boat, you can efficiently cover large areas of water. Deep-diving lures, Rapalas, and umbrella rigs are ideal for reaching deeper waters, where Striped Bass and Walleye often roam.

Maintain a steady speed between 2–3 miles per hour to keep your lures at the perfect depth. Creek mouths, drop-offs, and areas with rapid depth changes are hotspots for trolling—and don’t forget a fish finder to help you locate your targets! Local anglers swear by early mornings and late evenings for the best action. 

Casting and Jigging

Casting and jigging are top techniques for Largemouth and Smallmouth Bass fishing in Raystown Lake. Casting with soft plastics, spinnerbaits, or crankbaits works wonders near submerged structures like rocks, fallen trees, or weed beds. For Smallies, jigging with finesse jigs and soft plastics in deeper, rocky areas is a game-changer.

Largemouth Bass thrive in shallow waters during the warmer months, while Smallmouth Bass prefer rocky points and drop-offs. A medium to medium-heavy spinning rod with 8–12 lb test line is perfect for these techniques. Local tips include using a fast retrieve for Largemouth and a slower, deliberate approach for Smallmouth to match their feeding habits.

Ice Fishing

A view across a frozen lake towards a person ice fishing in spring, with barren foliage visible on the shoreline behind them

Ice fishing at Raystown Lake offers a unique winter fishing experience for Panfish, Yellow Perch, and the occasional Walleye. Shallow bays and coves with thick, stable ice are the safest and most productive spots.

Small jigs tipped with waxworms or minnows work great for Panfish and Perch, while larger jigs or live bait are better for Walleye. A lightweight ice fishing rod with 4–8 lb test line is perfect for detecting subtle bites, but drilling multiple holes and moving frequently will help you stay on active fish.

Where to Go Fishing on Raystown Lake 

A view of a rocky beach next to the calm waters of Raystown Lake, PA, on a clear day, with greenery visible on the opposite shore

Finding the perfect spot at Raystown Lake can make all the difference in your fishing experience. With its hidden coves and rocky shorelines, the lake is packed with settings for shore anglers and those fishing from a boat. Let’s take a look at some of them:

  • Seven Points Recreation Area. This area provides easy access to both shallow and deep waters, perfect for shore and boat anglers alike. It’s a go-to spot for both Largemouth and Striped Bass, especially during the warmer months when fish are more active.
  • Hawn’s Bridge. A prime location for Bass enthusiasts, this bridge has submerged structures and drop-offs that attract Largemouth and Smallmouth Bass. This spot produces results year-round, with early mornings being particularly productive.
  • James Creek. Situated in the lake’s central section, it’s great for Striped Bass, Walleye, and Smallmouth Bass. 
  • Shy Beaver Creek. Known for its standing timber and deep coves, this area is a hotspot for Musky and other predatory species. The creek’s quiet, less crowded waters appeal to anglers looking for a more serene fishing experience.
  • Snyder’s Run. This location offers convenient access for targeting Striped Bass, Walleye, and various Bass species. With a boat launch and shoreline fishing options, it’s a versatile choice for anglers.
  • Shawnee Run. Located in a secluded area, this is a productive spot for Smallmouth Bass and Channel Catfish. Its rocky outcrops and coves provide ideal conditions for these species.
  • Raystown Dam. The waters near the dam offer excellent Walleye fishing, particularly in the cooler months. This area also attracts anglers targeting Lake Trout, thanks to its depth and consistent temperature.

Raystown Lake Fishing Seasons

A view of three fishing rods set up for night fishing off a boat in Pennsylvania with lights brightening up the water so the anglers can find fish
Photo courtesy of Predator Getter Outdoors

What time of year is best for Striper fishing in Raystown Lake? Spring, especially from April to June, is probably peak season. Walleye and Largemouth Bass are highly active at this time of year, taking advantage of the warming waters. Fall is another top season, as Striped Bass and Walleye move closer to the surface to feed in cooler conditions. Early mornings and evenings are especially productive during these transitional periods.

However, Raystown Lake’s year-round accessibility ensures there’s always a chance of catching something special. Summer brings active Largemouth Bass to the shallows and Channel Catfish feed in deeper waters. Meanwhile, winter fishing caters to those seeking solitude and a challenge. Ice fishing for species like Walleye and Smallmouth Bass adds a unique twist to the colder months.  

Raystown Lake Fishing Regulations

An infographic showing the state flag of Pennsylvania along with text that says "Raystown Lake fishing regulations what you need to know" against a dark blue background

Fishing in Raystown Lake is governed by Pennsylvania state regulations. Anglers aged 16 and older must have a valid PA fishing license, available online or at authorized retailers. Species like Striped Bass, Walleye, and Lake Trout are also subject to specific bag and size limits, so it’s essential to check the latest guidelines before heading out. 

Certain areas of the lake may also have seasonal closures or restrictions to safeguard habitats, particularly during spawning periods. Spearfishing is restricted in some areas, so if you’re planning on getting up close and personal to your target, you’ll need to be extra cautious.

Raystown Lake: A Pennsylvania Fishing Tradition

A surface-level view of Raystown Lake on a clear day with calm waters dominating the image and greenery visible on the lake's shores

Fishing at Raystown Lake is all about big catches, better stories, and unbeatable views. However, you’ll have to hit the waters and see it for yourself. Stripers, Bass, or Trout—what’s next on your line? Grab your gear and find out. The lake is waiting!

Have you ever been on a Raystown Lake fishing trip? What’s your go-to target? Any fish stories you’re willing to share? Let’s chat in the comments!

Author profile picture

Lisa traded the lecture hall for the vast expanse of the world's waters, transforming her love of teaching into an insatiable passion for angling and storytelling. She would sail through oceans, lakes, and rivers, reeling in the world’s fish stories one catch at a time.

Comments (0)
Leave a reply
NameRequired
Your comment Required