Hero banner

Ithaca Fishing Charters

The best out of 19 charter fishing deals in Ithaca - enter dates to check availability

Ithaca Fishing Charters

Compare 19 captains, read reviews, and book in minutes

Trip date
banner
Loading...

Top Fishing Charters in Ithaca

Ithaca: 19 fishing charters available

Showing 1 - 10
 Show on map
Angler's Choice
Listing image
21 ft
Up to 4 people
Red Beard's Fishing – Cayuga Lake
4.9
/5
(69 reviews)
Ithaca
Red Beard's Finger Lakes Charters invites you to experience the stunning waters of Cayuga Lake. Having logged many hours on this lake, Captain Stan can tell you all about the local fishery.

"Booked a half day for my son, 12 year old grandson, and myself." —⁠ Kenneth,
trips from
US $450
Listing image
20 ft
Up to 4 people
Sich's Guide Service – Cayuga Lake
5.0
/5
(26 reviews)
Ithaca
Sich's Guide Service runs fishing charters on Cayuga Lake in a 2021 starcraft fish master 196. One of the most stable and spacious platform in aluminum boats and the latest in technology gives us the edge while fishing in comfort.

"There was some last-minute problems with the original boat so Captain Dawson met me bright and early." —⁠ John,
trips from
US $550
Listing image
17 ft
Up to 2 people
FLX Fish vertical jigging charters
5.0
/5
(3 reviews)
Ithaca
Experience the Finger Lakes differently with Captain Mike and FLX Fish. We specialize in vertical jigging for Lake Trout and Rainbow Trout on Cayuga and Owasco Lakes.

"We have chartered in Florida, Maryland, New Jersey, South Carolina and New York yet these folks are hands down the best!" —⁠ Jacqueline, Pennsylvania
trips from
US $400
Angler's Choice
Listing image
16 ft
Up to 2 people
Red Beard's Cayuga Lake Ice Out
5.0
/5
(2 reviews)
Ithaca
Hoping to cast a line in Ithaca? Then Red Beard's Finger Lakes Charters has a trip with your name on it! With Captain Stanley at the helm, you'll have a knowledgeable and experienced guide.

"Stan was a terrific guide and great conversation on Cayuga. We got a pretty good haul of fish too." —⁠ Ben,
trips from
US $300
Listing image
23 ft
Up to 4 people
Jigging Charters With FLX Fish
4.8
/5
(6 reviews)
Ithaca
We offer jigging and casting charters for Lake Trout, Rainbows, Browns and Landlocked Salmon We also offer Perch fishing charters in the spring and fall when the Perch are thick! Room for 4 people but much more enjoyable with 2-3 people We have a brand ne

"The appointment was for Saturday, Jul 18 but when they forecasted Thunderstorms, heavy rain and strong winds, Capt Dawson got ahold of us." —⁠ Diana,
trips from
US $400
Listing image
20 ft
Up to 2 people
Whiskey Runner Charters
5.0
/5
(10 reviews)
Ithaca
Captain Dan, owner of Whiskey Runner Charters has over 35 years of experience. He will provide you with an exciting and successful fishing trip! We offer the best in sport fishing on Cayuga Lake.

"We booked a 4-hour trip with Dan & Cat. We brought our kids, and they were enthusiastic and great at teaching them the basics." —⁠ Isabelle,
trips from
US $500
Listing image
21 ft
Up to 6 people
All About Trout
5.0
/5
(13 reviews)
Romulus (36 min drive from Ithaca)
If you want to experience world class trout fishing in the Finger Lakes region, look no further than All About Trout. With Captain Ryan at the helm, you'll be in knowledgeable and experienced hands.

"We had a great time with Ryan today! Both boys (10 & 13) caught large trout — a rainbow and a lake trout." —⁠ Christine,
trips from
US $450
Listing image
18 ft
Up to 3 people
Healy Outdoors – Cayuga Trout Charter
Ithaca
Hoping to cast a line in Ithaca? Healy Outdoors is here to make it happen! Depending on the time of year, you might hook into Atlantic Salmon, Brown Trout, Lake Trout, Rainbow Trout (Steelhead), and anything else that bites.
trips from
US $400
Listing image
30 ft
Up to 6 people
Pulling Meat Fishing Charters
5.0
/5
(22 reviews)
Union Springs (46 min drive from Ithaca)
I do not clean fish!  Pulling Meat Fishing Charters is your ticket to the stunning waters of Cayuga Lake. Your guide for the day is Captain Mike, so you’ll benefit from years of angling experience.

"We had an amazing day out on the Lake with Captain Mike! Everything about this trip was great!" —⁠ Tiffany,
trips from
US $600
Angler's Choice
Listing image
24 ft
Up to 4 people
Locked With Lorensen - Cayuga & Otisco Lake
5.0
/5
(27 reviews)
Romulus (33 min drive from Ithaca)
Locked with Lorensen is owned and operated by a local family man, Captain Ryan Lorensen, from the Oswego County area. He offers trips for any NYS freshwater species that you would like to target.

"Second time out with Ryan after catching a boat load if monster lake trout at Cayuga." —⁠ Jason,
trips from
US $400
View all fishing charters
See all 19 fishing charters in Ithaca

Top deep sea fishing trips in Ithaca

  • Loading...
  • Loading...
  • Loading...
  • Loading...

Top-rated family fishing trips in Ithaca

  • Loading...
  • Loading...
  • Loading...
  • Loading...

Half-day fishing trips in Ithaca

  • Loading...
  • Loading...
  • Loading...
  • Loading...
Loading
Loading

Real catches shared by our community in Ithaca

  • Loading...
  • Loading...
  • Loading...
  • Loading...

Top Types of Fishing in Ithaca

  • Loading...
  • Loading...
  • Loading...
  • Loading...

Top Fishing Techniques in Ithaca

  • Loading...
  • Loading...
  • Loading...
  • Loading...

Frequently Asked Questions about Fishing Charters in Ithaca

Loading
Loading
Loading
Loading
Loading
Powered by AI

Fishing in Ithaca

Discover the angling paradise of Ithaca, nestled in the heart of New York's breathtaking Finger Lakes region. Ithaca fishing charters offer unparalleled access to the pristine waters of Cayuga Lake, one of the region's true gems known for its healthy baitfish population and trophy catches.

Cayuga Lake, the centerpiece of Ithaca's fishing scene, delivers exceptional year-round fishing opportunities. Anglers can target a variety of prized species including Lake Trout, Brown Trout, Rainbow Trout, and the coveted Landlocked Atlantic Salmon. The lake's trout typically range from 2-8 pounds, while Lake Trout often average an impressive 6-10 pounds.

Professional guides in Ithaca employ various effective techniques to maximize your success on the water. Trolling with multi-rod spreads using lead-core lines, planer boards, dipsy divers, and downriggers proves consistently productive. For a more active experience, vertical jigging with light tackle spinning outfits offers an exciting way to target Lake Trout.

Morning charters are particularly productive, setting out at sunrise when fish are most active. An average outing yields dozens of bites, often resulting in the satisfying 'problem' of sore arms from reeling in so many fish. With experienced captains who've logged countless hours on these waters, you'll benefit from local knowledge that puts you directly on the fish.

Whether you're a seasoned angler seeking trophy catches or a family looking for a memorable day on the water, Ithaca fishing charters deliver exceptional experiences in a stunning natural setting. The combination of abundant fish, knowledgeable guides, and the breathtaking backdrop of the Finger Lakes region makes Ithaca an ideal destination for your next fishing adventure.

Ithaca

4.9
/5
Based on 31,684 reviews by FishingBooker anglers

What anglers said about fishing in Ithaca

  • Loading...
  • Loading...
  • Loading...
  • Loading...

How did anglers rate fishing charters in Ithaca?

  • Loading...
  • Loading...
  • Loading...
  • Loading...

Nearby Fishing Destinations

  • Loading...
  • Loading...
  • Loading...
  • Loading...