Best Reef Fishing Charters in Key West

Top Reef Fishing Charters in Key West

Reef Fishing in Key West

You don’t need to go far to try reef fishing in Key West. To the west, untouched patch reefs extend from a stone’s throw from the mainland out as far as the fabled Dry Tortugas. To the south and east, the outer reef (the only living barrier reef in continental United States) is a melting pot of baitfish and predators. Bottom fish and pelagics alike visit these waters throughout the year. Suffice to say, there’s never a dull moment on these waters.

When and how to fish the Key West reefs

Key West reef fishing charters operate all year round, although it’s in spring and fall when the fishing really heats up. Most of the time, they use light tackle spinning gear, which is easy for beginners to use at the same time as putting up a challenge for more experienced anglers. Pair this up with some heavy chumming, and you’ll have a fishing frenzy on your hands.

If one species sums up the reef fishing Key West is so proud of, it’s the Yellowtail Snapper. This cheerful chappy is probably the most common target on these charters and its bright coloring is a sure hit with the kids. Great on the table, these fish weight up to about 5 lbs. While they usually live around the reef, they swim up to the surface when you chum the water, allowing you to target them with small jigs, live and dead bait, and flies.

But it doesn’t stop there. Joining the Yellowtail is its much bigger cousin, the Mutton Snapper, which weighs up to 20 lbs. These are usually targeted by fishing dead bait on the bottom. Lane and Mangrove Snapper might also find their way onto the boat, as well as Grouper.

That’s all good for people who want to fill the ice box. But what about the adrenaline junkies? Well, the beauty of reef fishing in Key West is that the rich marine life in the corals attracts plenty of larger fish looking for an easy meal. Expect to come across King Mackerel (Kingfish), Barracuda, Sharks, Amberjack, Bonito, Cobia, and even the occasional Sailfish and Mahi Mahi. Yes, we told you there was plenty going on round here.

Key West

Based on 19,486 reviews by FishingBooker anglers

View all fishing charters in Key West

Reviews of Fishing in Reef Fishing in Key West

"Fun 1/2 Day Fishing on the Reef Runner II"

William Popoli fished with Capt Conch Charters- Reef Runner II on July 29, 2020

Had a fabulous time in Key West on the Reef Runner II. This would be the third time we have gone fishing with them while visiting Key West. Great boat & tackle. Super first mate took very good care of us. We will return next year!!

"4 hour trip with Gill & Sysco"

Kevin Lamb fished with Capt Conch Charters- Reef Runner II on June 6, 2018

Had a good time catching Mahi Mahi on the Reef Runner 2!

"Great Fun on Cool Water I"

Lloyd W. McGrady fished with Fish Key West - The Coolwater on April 10, 2016

We had a great trip in marginal weather. Great equipment, Capt Cory did an excellent job fishing and dodging storms...and we caught great fish! Released a nice Caribbean Reef shark. See pix of some others.

Top Targeted Reef Fishing Species in Key West

Snapper (Mutton)

Snapper (Mutton)

King Mackerel (Kingfish)

King Mackerel (Kingfish)

Barracuda (Great)

Barracuda (Great)