First, my wife and I are experienced at Deep Sea Fishing, having been to a dozen of more locations between us in the last ten years, some more than once. There were three of us on this trip and the Boat, Gear, and Crew were great. The only reason the Overall Experience rating was four and not five stars is because we only caught one small Jack fish that fit in the little bait cooler. But we know you get shut out once and awhile, that’s just fishing. So maybe a four on experience is a little unfair to the crew, but part of the “overall experience” is catching fish. I do Highly recommend Island Dog.