Key West Reef & Offshore Fishing 

We had a great trip & wonderful, fun experience out on the water with Joel & DJ! Joel kept mixing it up for us, DJ worked hard to keep rigging and baiting the lines. Both have wonderful personalities and are both very much appreciated! We caught a decent variety and I was so happy to get a very nice sized and my first barracuda! We did 8 hours and could have continued to go all day and night w these guys if the fish were cooperating better! We will plan another booking but for winter! These two are amazing guys and if you are trying to narrow it down, choose Joel! Thank you both for everything and more memories, we will meet up again! From Us4

We had a great trip with Conch Too, Joel put in the work to make sure everyone had a good time and caught fish. Even though we knew that the Sailfish/Wahoo bite was slow he still put in all the effort to try and get us on one. After giving it his best effort, he decided to go back in towards the reef and go for Snapper/Mackerel. We managed to put a good mess of fish in the boat and had a great time. Joel was also great with my 6 yr old the entire trip, letting him ask all the questions and be involved every step of the way. I would definitely recommend him to anyone and wouldn't hesitate to go fishing with him again!

I booked a 6 hr morning charter with Joel for my family of 4. Prior to the trip Joel communicated with me to make sure any questions were answered. The day of the trip we were able to park right at the boat and we were off the dock right on time. Joel took the time to ask us what we wanted to target and provided some great advice. The boat was comfortable, very clean, and all the tackle was in excellent condition. We had a productive day and caught a variety of fish. We really enjoyed fishing with Joel, not only is he an excellent fisherman, but was friendly and engaging. My wife hauling in a good size barracuda was fantastic and we ended up with a bunch of nice size mutton, mackerel, and a small shark (which the boys thought was cool). Joel and Tony cleaned all the fish and let us know of a great local spot that prepared it. If you are looking for a great day on the water with a quality captain I would highly recommend Joel on The Conch Too. Looking forward to our next trip.

From the moment we arrived at the dock, the entire experience was outstanding. The crew was knowledgeable, courteous, and thorough in explaining every aspect of the trip. Joel demonstrated great professionalism and put us on the fish right from the start. The captain remained attentive throughout the day, ensuring everything ran smoothly and safely. This trip was far more than just a day of fishing — it was an educational and memorable experience. We located the bait, caught the bait, and successfully caught our fish, all with the guidance of an excellent crew. Thank you, Conch Too Charters, for an exceptional outing. I will certainly return and highly recommend your services to anyone visiting Key West for a quality fishing experience.

We went out with Joel and his mate Tony. What an amazing trip , we asked to put us on what ever is biting and they took us to their favorite grouper spots. If there wasn’t any action they didn’t hesitate to pull anchor and relocate. I really appreciate that vs. captains that seem to care more about fuel conservation. Well they put us on the fish and boy did we have a day. About an hour left in the trip we get to our last spot to try and outta no where a 10 foot tiger shark swims right up to the boat in the chum slick. Capt. looked at me and asked you wanna try and catch it ? ( like there was any other answer besides yes) He had that shark hooked up 15 minutes later. My self and my girlfriend fought that beautiful monster for close to 40 minutes. He set us up for success with his knowledge his gear and his willingness to satisfy his customers. If you’re reading this don’t bother booking with anywhere else , you’ll be happy you went with Conch Too!!

Stop looking and book this one! We would highly recommend the is fishing trip to anyone looking. we caught lots of nice fish. Great trip for anyone who likes to fish. Captain and crew were awesome. They took time to speak with us over the phone several times before the trip to address any questions or concerns. They made suggestions to help us with any concerns we had. We will be booking again in the future!

Great for first timer or veterans. The weather was less than ideal, but Captain Joel worked to get us in the location we needed to be. we caught snapper (4 large enough to keep), grouper, a bonnethead shark, and even hooked into a cobia on the last cast. He recommended two spots nearby for fresh catch dinner which was a bonus. Looking forward to next time we’re down here for another fishing trip.

This was our first deep sea fishing trip and Joel made a point to ask what we’re wanting to catch. We say big because we’re from Colorado and not much big there. He did not disappoint. We caught 2 sail fish right off the bat and tuna’s after that. Very patient and knowledgeable about fishing. He will be our first stop when back in Key West. Every catch was just as exciting for Joel as us which shows how passionate he is about fishing. You will not regret it I promise you!!

Captain & crew were great!! Knew right to go to get ua on the fish. Will definitely fish with them again!!

Wahoo, yellow tail, 3 tail, and dolphin, for a total of 21 fish caught by 4 fishermen. A very good day of fishing.