Brad Vanhoose
Brad Vanhoose
Repeat angler
us
Michigan, Сједињене Државе
Member since 2020
2 trips
3.3
Verified

Too rough to fish

Half Day Trip (AM)2 adults

I emailed the captain the day before the trip and asked him again prior to going out if the wind and waves were going to be an issue for fishing. He said no problem. We went out, wife got sick, came in early. Being an avid fisherman and boat captain myself, I knew that as soon as we cleared the harbor and got out into deeper water the trip was not going to end well. The boat seemed well equipped and the captain and deckhand seemed nice although was a lot of dialogue. Was the captain was being honest with me or did he just take advantage of us so he could make the money. I have really no idea on their fishing capabilities because we only spent maybe an hour and a half of fishing. So do I recommend this charter or not? I have to say no only based on the fact that we should have rescheduled the trip for another day when the conditions were more amenable to an enjoyable outing.

Response from Captain

Thanks for taking the time to review your trip Brad Although you did check in with us the day prior to your trip, the sea conditions on todays charter were not unfavourable for us to fish This weather is very typical for this time of the year, and sea conditions here are rarely ever flat calm We fish on the Caribbean Sea side of the island which is the calmest, and we were not the only fishing boat that went out today Unfortunately your wife did get seasick and you ended the charter early The Captain does not take advantage of our guests - some are just better able to handle the sea conditions than others

Compare similar fishing charters

Current
Mystic Amara Fishing Charters
4.8
(130)
31 ft
Group size 1 - 6
1 - 6
Fish 1
Fish 2
+10
4 hour trip • 6 persons
US $650

Rating

4.8
130 reviews
4.8
Boat & Equipment
4.8
Captain & Crew
4.7
Fishing Experience

What anglers say

  • 94%
    Great experience
  • 74%
    Family friendly
  • 98%
    Friendly captain
  • 100%
    Good boat
  • 93%
    Recommended
  • 93%
    Caught fish

All reviews (130)

Showing 15 of 130 reviews
  • Eric Lehman
    Eric Lehman
    us
    Delaware, Сједињене Државе
    Member since 2023
    5.0
    Verified

    Excellent time on board the Mystic Amara

    3/4 Day Trip2 adults

    We're an experienced crew and Captain Leroy along with 1st Mate Aaron put us on the fish. We knew it would be an adventure when the outriggers were touching. As soon as we cleared the reef we were already trolling and nearly right away a barracuda was brought in. After a few more 'cudas and then the purple teaser started singing. Spoke too soon and the fish spit the hook. This happened once more, then we were finally able to get 1 wahoo over the rails. Followed up by a few mahi and some bonito, we had a full day out of the 6 hour trip. The boat was very clean and comfortable. Captain and mate were very friendly, knowledgeable, and shared the eagerness to put some fish in the box. Highly recommend this boat and crew. I just wished they could do a resort pickup, but I understand all resorts may not have the ability to handle the deeper hulls and this could also shorten your fishing time. Driving to the pickup site was an adventure in itself, but doable. We'll be back for the Mystic Amara!

    Reported Catch
    Dolphin (Mahi Mahi)
    Wahoo
    Velika barakuda
    Response from Captain

    thanks for a great review eric so glad you had an awesome time

  • Bill Rushton
    Bill Rushton
    Repeat angler
    us
    Indiana, Сједињене Државе
    Member since 2019
    7 trips
    5.0
    Verified

    Another Fantastic Fishing Trip

    Half Day Trip (AM)2 adults

    Shoutout to Captain Leroy and First mate Arron on another great fishing trip in the books. Captain had my wife and I on fish in no time, landing a total of 8, 1 Mahi-mahi & 7 Barracudas. You couldn’t ask for a better crew, Captain coming down from upper deck to assist when needed, and Arron in constant support helping us to fight the fish, tending to the lines and bait, on top of keeping the deck safe and clean. Thank you again, let’s make it 3 years in a row!

    Reported Catch
    Dolphin (Mahi Mahi)
    Velika barakuda
    Response from Captain

    Awesome charter Bill - always a pleasure to have you on board See you next trip!!!

  • Cathy Collins
    Cathy Collins
    ca
    Ontario, Канада
    Member since 2025
    5.0
    Verified

    Fishing with Denfield

    Half Day Trip (AM)2 adults

    my wife and i went out fishing with mystic amara for a 1/2 day morning trip. captain Leroy and first mate Edwin greeted us and gave a quick safety and boat info chat. The boat was spotless and well equipped. We were onto our first fish quickly and more followed. The crew worked hard making all 8 lines were out and freshly baited. We landed 7 fish, 3 species and brought a black fin tuna back to our resort where they cooked it up for our dinner. It tasted amazing. All in all an enjoyable experience.

    Response from Captain

    Ric & Cathy - so glad you enjoyed your trip with us - thanks for a great review and for choosing Mystic Amara III

  • Jim Randazzo
    Jim Randazzo
    Repeat angler
    us
    New Jersey, Сједињене Државе
    Member since 2019
    3 trips
    5.0
    Verified

    Great Trip

    3/4 Day Trip2 adults

    Captain had us on the fish quick and delivered for the whole trip. The mate was one of the best I ever fished with and kept the gear ready for the hits. Highly recommended.

    Reported Catch
    Velika barakuda
    Dolphin (Mahi Mahi)
    Blackfin Tuna
    Response from Captain

    thanks for a great review Jim and so glad you had an awesome trip

  • Rick DaPrato
    Rick DaPrato
    us
    Massachusetts, Сједињене Државе
    Member since 2019
    5.0
    Verified

    Blackfin tuna & 4 barracuda

    Half Day Trip (AM)2 adults

    While it was a bit rough captain Lee put us on finish while first mate Aaron did a great job working the eight lines we were trolling.

    Response from Captain

    Thank you for your review Richard