We had an outstanding experience aboard Play N Hooky! Captain Teoni and deckhand Nick were both fantastic from start to finish. They were professional, knowledgeable, friendly, and worked hard to make sure everyone had a great time on the water.
The fishing was excellent, and thanks to their expertise we landed some beautiful mahi-mahi. Captain Teoni put us on the fish, and Nick was always there to help, making the entire trip enjoyable and stress-free.
If you’re looking for a top-notch fishing charter, I highly recommend Play N Hooky. Great crew, great boat, and great memories. We’ll definitely be booking another trip the next time we’re back!

An absolutely incredible fishing trip and easily one of the highlights of our time here. Huge spotlight to Captain Teoni and First Mate Nick,
they were truly outstanding. From the moment we got on the boat, they made us feel comfortable, confident, and excited for the day ahead. Their professionalism, experience, and passion for fishing really showed throughout the trip. They were patient, encouraging, and always attentive, making sure we had the best possible chance to succeed while also enjoying every moment on the water.

Thanks to their expertise, we caught four mahi mahi, and each catch was an unforgettable experience. The energy on the boat was amazing, and you can tell they genuinely care about giving their guests a meaningful and memorable trip, not just a quick charter.

If you’re looking for a top-tier fishing experience with a knowledgeable and dedicated crew, we highly recommend Captain Teoni and Nick. We are truly grateful for such a special day on the ocean and would absolutely book with them again.

What a trip!  Captain Teoni has the gift - he found us Mahi, yellowfin tuna, marlin, and even a Hawaiian Shortbill spearfish!  And Mate Nick was incredible helping us get them all in the boat and keeping us entertained the whole way with his great personality!  Literally cannot recommend this crew more if you want to get out there for some great sportfishing!

Was very impressed with Teoni and the deck hand Nick. The water was super rough while we were on the island but thankfully Teoni still took us out. He put us on fish multiple times and we had 3 bites. We were able to land a 24 lbs skip jack tuna with Nicks help. Would absolutely book with them again.

My husband and I went out to celebrate his birthday (his dream has always been to catch a Marlin) I told Captain Teoni and Nic the mission and they MADE IT HAPPEN! We had a great day on the water with great people and caught lots of fish!! 100/10 recommend!