Crunch Time Sport Fishing
Montauk is home to many exciting species that dwell in both the inshore and the offshore areas. This great diversity isn’t the only thing going for Montauk, as the nature of the shoreline is resplendent. Crunch Time Sport Fishing will take you on a great adventure, that will leave you with pleasant memories for years to come!
Climb aboard their 48ft Rose Brothers Custom Sport Fishing Boat restored in 2013 - all the modern fishing amenities are available. She can carry up to 12 anglers fishing simultaneously, in comfort, with ample room to work. She is powered by a twin 375hp caterpillar engines. She’s fully equipped for serious fishing, A full-head toilet on board ensures comfort even on longer trips.
Join Captain TJ as you fish the inshore and offshore waters of Montauk. You can expect to go after Striped Bass, Bluefish, Fluke , Blackfish, Black Seabass, and others in the inshore areas. Offshore though, the adventure is afoot as you target Mako and Thresher Sharks, as well as Yellowfin Tuna and it’s prestigious cousin the Bluefin Tuna. Light and heavy tackle jigging, spinning and popping can be utilized, as well as trolling and bottom fishing.
A professional first mate is available on board to assist you in rigging your line and to clean and fillet your catch. Top-of-the-line equipment is available for use on Crunch Time Sport Fishing. Children are welcome onboard but the minimum age is 5. Fishing licenses are included. Customers are advised to bring sunscreen, polarized sunglasses, adequate clothing, and a waterproof camera.
Customer reviews
Rating summary
Photos & videos by reviewers (170)
+167Angler rating
Anglers claimed
Good experience
100%
Appropriate for children
96%
Friendly captain
100%
Satisfied with the boat
100%
Recommend this charter
96%
Caught fish
95%
Jul 16, 2025
Kids Summer Fishing Camp PM
Absolutely perfect
Yesterday my family enjoyed an absolutely perfect day aboard the Crunch Time with TJ and Dave. Although my son and I had limited fishing experience, my wife, daughter-in-law and two granddaughters had nearly none. While Dave piloted from one fishing spot to another, TJ taught my granddaughters everything thing they needed to know. It was exactly at their level (12 & 16) and pretty soon they were hauling in fish. The catch was nothing short of spectacular. As advertised for the “Kids” package, we were in calm water east of Montauk Lighthouse bottom fishing for porgies and sea bass equipped with a sinker and two hooks. Many times we got strikes the moment the sinker hit bottom. We had SIX times when there was a fish on each the two hooks! We lost track of the huge catch and TJ estimated 50-70 fish among the 6 of us. They call it fishing, but today it was catching. This trip was the highlight of the granddaughter’s visit and they had an absolutely wonderful time. We’re so grateful to TJ and Dave. The trip was worth every penny.
Yesterday my family enjoyed an absolutely perfect day aboard the Crunch Time with TJ and Dave. Although my son and I had limited...
Captain replied
Aug 25, 2024
Half Day Trip (PM) - Inshore
Picture perfect day
We couldn’t have asked for a better crew and a better day. Captain TJ and his mate, Brian, were super friendly and enthusiastic, eager to share their love of fishing and “tricks of the trade” with us. This was only the second time I’ve gone fishing, and the first for my young kids (7 and 4), and they both made sure that everyone was always having fun. We easily caught several pounds worth of porgies, sea bass, and fluke, and the captain expertly filleted and cleaned all of it for us. We ended the day with a delicious feast at home and leftovers that will last us the rest of the week!
We couldn’t have asked for a better crew and a better day. Captain TJ and his mate, Brian, were super friendly and enthusiastic,...
Captain replied
Aug 16, 2024
Late Afternoon/Twilight trip
Excellent Fishing experience! The Best Captain and mate!
We had the greatest fishing trip and highly recommend this trip. From the moment we arrived at the boat, Captain TJ and Cristina were helpful, encouraging, experts in their knowledge and engaged and fun. Truly helped us at every step of the trip. We caught a lot of sizable fish and the day was beautiful for us and our 12 year old son. We watched the sun going down at the end while Cristina filleted the fish. For dinner we ate some that evening and have some in the freezer. We recommend this trip without hesitation. They are amazing and fun too. Thanks for the great experience, Captain TJ and Cristina.
We had the greatest fishing trip and highly recommend this trip. From the moment we arrived at the boat, Captain TJ and Cristina...
Captain replied
Aug 14, 2024
Late Afternoon/Twilight trip
Fishing with TJ
I took my 3 teenage sons on a private charter so they could learn more about fishing. They caught fish every time they dropped a line and were even catching 2 at a time. TJ and Christine were great. They took the time to teach my boys and were very friendly and professional. Christine filleted all the fish for us like a boss, you could tell she really loves what she does. To top it off the weather was perfect and TJ was willing to adjust the time of our charter so we also caught a great sunset on our way back to the dock. We couldn’t have been happier, we had an amazing time. Great experience all around.
I took my 3 teenage sons on a private charter so they could learn more about fishing. They caught fish every time they dropped...
Captain replied
Jul 12, 2025
Half Day Trip (AM) - Inshore
Great Time For All
We were a party of 6 and all had a great time. The captain put us on the fish, and Brian, the mate, never stopped moving. He was ahead of us all the time. Our rods and bait were ready to drop every time we stopped. We all agreed that we would definitely book again.
We were a party of 6 and all had a great time. The captain put us on the fish, and Brian, the mate, never stopped moving. He was...
Captain repliedTrip availability and prices
| Su | Mo | Tu | We | Th | Fr | Sa | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Customer reviews
Rating summary
Photos & videos by reviewers (170)
+167Angler rating
Anglers claimed
Good experience
100%
Appropriate for children
96%
Friendly captain
100%
Satisfied with the boat
100%
Recommend this charter
96%
Caught fish
95%
Experience:
Boat
Crew
Overall
Absolutely perfect
Kids Summer Fishing Camp PM on July 16, 2025
Yesterday my family enjoyed an absolutely perfect day aboard the Crunch Time with TJ and Dave. Although my son and I had limited fishing experience, my wife, daughter-in-law and two granddaughters had nearly none. While Dave piloted from one fishing spot to another, TJ taught my granddaughters everything thing they needed to know. It was exactly at their level (12 & 16) and pretty soon they were hauling in fish. The catch was nothing short of spectacular. As advertised for the “Kids” package, we were in calm water east of Montauk Lighthouse bottom fishing for porgies and sea bass equipped with a sinker and two hooks. Many times we got strikes the moment the sinker hit bottom. We had SIX times when there was a fish on each the two hooks! We lost track of the huge catch and TJ estimated 50-70 fish among the 6 of us. They call it fishing, but today it was catching. This trip was the highlight of the granddaughter’s visit and they had an absolutely wonderful time. We’re so grateful to TJ and Dave. The trip was worth every penny.
Yesterday my family enjoyed an absolutely perfect day aboard the Crunch Time with TJ and Dave. Although my son and I had limited fishing experience, my wife, daughter-in-law and two granddaughters had nearly none. While Dave piloted from one fishing spot to another, TJ taught my granddaughters everything thing they needed to know. It was exactly at their level (12 & 16) and pretty soon they were hauling in fish. The catch was nothing short of spectacular. As advertised for the “Kids” package,...
Experience:
Boat
Crew
Overall
Picture perfect day
Half Day Trip (PM) - Inshore on August 25, 2024
We couldn’t have asked for a better crew and a better day. Captain TJ and his mate, Brian, were super friendly and enthusiastic, eager to share their love of fishing and “tricks of the trade” with us. This was only the second time I’ve gone fishing, and the first for my young kids (7 and 4), and they both made sure that everyone was always having fun. We easily caught several pounds worth of porgies, sea bass, and fluke, and the captain expertly filleted and cleaned all of it for us. We ended the day with a delicious feast at home and leftovers that will last us the rest of the week!
We couldn’t have asked for a better crew and a better day. Captain TJ and his mate, Brian, were super friendly and enthusiastic, eager to share their love of fishing and “tricks of the trade” with us. This was only the second time I’ve gone fishing, and the first for my young kids (7 and 4), and they both made sure that everyone was always having fun. We easily caught several pounds worth of porgies, sea bass, and fluke, and the captain expertly filleted and cleaned all of it for us. We ended...
Experience:
Boat
Crew
Overall
Excellent Fishing experience! The Best Captain and mate!
Late Afternoon/Twilight trip on August 16, 2024
We had the greatest fishing trip and highly recommend this trip. From the moment we arrived at the boat, Captain TJ and Cristina were helpful, encouraging, experts in their knowledge and engaged and fun. Truly helped us at every step of the trip. We caught a lot of sizable fish and the day was beautiful for us and our 12 year old son. We watched the sun going down at the end while Cristina filleted the fish. For dinner we ate some that evening and have some in the freezer. We recommend this trip without hesitation. They are amazing and fun too. Thanks for the great experience, Captain TJ and Cristina.
We had the greatest fishing trip and highly recommend this trip. From the moment we arrived at the boat, Captain TJ and Cristina were helpful, encouraging, experts in their knowledge and engaged and fun. Truly helped us at every step of the trip. We caught a lot of sizable fish and the day was beautiful for us and our 12 year old son. We watched the sun going down at the end while Cristina filleted the fish. For dinner we ate some that evening and have some in the freezer. We recommend this...
Experience:
Boat
Crew
Overall
Fishing with TJ
Late Afternoon/Twilight trip on August 14, 2024
I took my 3 teenage sons on a private charter so they could learn more about fishing. They caught fish every time they dropped a line and were even catching 2 at a time. TJ and Christine were great. They took the time to teach my boys and were very friendly and professional. Christine filleted all the fish for us like a boss, you could tell she really loves what she does. To top it off the weather was perfect and TJ was willing to adjust the time of our charter so we also caught a great sunset on our way back to the dock. We couldn’t have been happier, we had an amazing time. Great experience all around.
I took my 3 teenage sons on a private charter so they could learn more about fishing. They caught fish every time they dropped a line and were even catching 2 at a time. TJ and Christine were great. They took the time to teach my boys and were very friendly and professional. Christine filleted all the fish for us like a boss, you could tell she really loves what she does. To top it off the weather was perfect and TJ was willing to adjust the time of our charter so we also caught a great sunset...
Experience:
Boat
Crew
Overall
Great Time For All
Half Day Trip (AM) - Inshore on July 12, 2025
We were a party of 6 and all had a great time. The captain put us on the fish, and Brian, the mate, never stopped moving. He was ahead of us all the time. Our rods and bait were ready to drop every time we stopped. We all agreed that we would definitely book again.
We were a party of 6 and all had a great time. The captain put us on the fish, and Brian, the mate, never stopped moving. He was ahead of us all the time. Our rods and bait were ready to drop every time we stopped. We all agreed that we would definitely book again.
FAQs about Crunch Time Sport Fishing
The fish you can target
What is the boat like?
