Crunch Time Sport Fishing

5.0/5 (179 reviews)

59 Star Island Road, Montauk, NY 11954, United States–

Crunch Time Sport Fishing

5.0/5 (179)

•

Angler's Choice

Meet the Captain

59 Star Island Road

Montauk, NY, United States

Trips & prices Targeted species Boat info What's biting What's included Contact captain

Trips & prices What's included Targeted species Boat info Reviews Contact captain

Montauk is home to many exciting species that dwell in both the inshore and the offshore areas. This great diversity isn’t the only thing going for Montauk, as the nature of the shoreline is resplendent. Crunch Time Sport Fishing will take you on a great adventure, that will leave you with pleasant memories for years to come!

Climb aboard their 48ft Rose Brothers Custom Sport Fishing Boat restored in 2013 - all the modern fishing amenities are available. She can carry up to 12 anglers fishing simultaneously, in comfort, with ample room to work. She is powered by a twin 375hp caterpillar engines. She’s fully equipped for serious fishing, A full-head toilet on board ensures comfort even on longer trips.

Join Captain TJ as you fish the inshore and offshore waters of Montauk. You can expect to go after Striped Bass, Bluefish, Fluke , Blackfish, Black Seabass, and others in the inshore areas. Offshore though, the adventure is afoot as you target Mako and Thresher Sharks, as well as Yellowfin Tuna and it’s prestigious cousin the Bluefin Tuna. Light and heavy tackle jigging, spinning and popping can be utilized, as well as trolling and bottom fishing.

A professional first mate is available on board to assist you in rigging your line and to clean and fillet your catch. Top-of-the-line equipment is available for use on Crunch Time Sport Fishing. Children are welcome onboard but the minimum age is 5. Fishing licenses are included. Customers are advised to bring sunscreen, polarized sunglasses, adequate clothing, and a waterproof camera.

Customer reviews

Review summary

These summary reviews were generated by AI based on recent reviews

Crunch Time Charters consistently puts guests on abundant fish quickly with a spacious, family-friendly boat and an attentive crew.

Fishing results can be influenced by weather and water conditions, causing day-to-day variation in bite intensity.

What Guests loved

Keep in mind

Rapid action and high catch counts across trips, with families landing dozens of fish in a day (one group estimated 50–70 fish among six visitors).
Kid-focused service with hands-on guidance: crew members help land fish, teach fishing techniques, and fillet and ice the catch for transport; tackle is prepped before the first spot.
Vessel amenities and readiness: a spacious boat that accommodates 6–9 guests, with an air-conditioned cabin, a clean restroom, and on-board filleting/icing for convenient take-home fish.

Rating summary

5.0/5

out of 5 stars from 179 reviews

See details

Boat

4.9/5

Crew

5.0/5

Experience

5.0/5

Photos & videos by reviewers (187)

+184

Anglers claimed

Good experience

100%

Appropriate for children

97%

Friendly captain

100%

Satisfied with the boat

100%

Recommend this charter

96%

Caught fish

95%

Review summary

These summary reviews were generated by AI based on recent reviews

Crunch Time Charters consistently puts guests on abundant fish quickly with a spacious, family-friendly boat and an attentive crew.

Fishing results can be influenced by weather and water conditions, causing day-to-day variation in bite intensity.

What Guests loved

Keep in mind

Rapid action and high catch counts across trips, with families landing dozens of fish in a day (one group estimated 50–70 fish among six visitors).
Kid-focused service with hands-on guidance: crew members help land fish, teach fishing techniques, and fillet and ice the catch for transport; tackle is prepped before the first spot.
Vessel amenities and readiness: a spacious boat that accommodates 6–9 guests, with an air-conditioned cabin, a clean restroom, and on-board filleting/icing for convenient take-home fish.

Showing 1 - 5 of 179 reviews

Sort by

Showing: 5 of 179 reviews

Tom Hemmick

5.0

Verified

Absolutely perfect

Kids Summer Fishing Camp - 1:00 PM on July 16, 2025 • 4 adults • 2 children

Yesterday my family enjoyed an absolutely perfect day aboard the Crunch Time with TJ and Dave. Although my son and I had limited fishing experience, my wife, daughter-in-law and two granddaughters had nearly none. While Dave piloted from one fishing spot to another, TJ taught my granddaughters everything thing they needed to know. It was exactly at their level (12 & 16) and pretty soon they were hauling in fish. The catch was nothing short of spectacular. As advertised for the “Kids” package, we were in calm water east of Montauk Lighthouse bottom fishing for porgies and sea bass equipped with a sinker and two hooks. Many times we got strikes the moment the sinker hit bottom. We had SIX times when there was a fish on each the two hooks! We lost track of the huge catch and TJ estimated 50-70 fish among the 6 of us. They call it fishing, but today it was catching. This trip was the highlight of the granddaughter’s visit and they had an absolutely wonderful time. We’re so grateful to TJ and Dave. The trip was worth every penny.

Reported catch:

Response from Captain

July 17, 2025

It was a pleasure having your group aboard. Thank you for the kind words. Hope to see you again soon.

Michael Coggins

5.0

Verified

New

Awesome Striped Bass Fishing

3/4 Day Trip – Inshore Fishing (AM) on November 2, 2025 • 3 adults • 6 children

We had an awesome trip for 9 anglers, including our boys, who had an incredible time reeling in slot sized bass. Capt TJ and Brian on the Crunch time are an outstanding team and worked hard getting us on the fish. Definitely plan on more trips on the Crunch time.

Reported catch:

Gary Costanzo

The captain canceled

October 26, 2025

The charter operator canceled 3 days prior to the trip date. This is an automated posting.

Chris Adamo

5.0

Verified

Great Time For All

Half Day Trip (AM) - Inshore on July 12, 2025 • 6 adults

We were a party of 6 and all had a great time. The captain put us on the fish, and Brian, the mate, never stopped moving. He was ahead of us all the time. Our rods and bait were ready to drop every time we stopped. We all agreed that we would definitely book again.

Response from Captain

July 15, 2025

Thanks for coming aboard. Hope to see you again soon!

Sean Burgess

5.0

Verified

Great Family Fishing

Kids Summer Fishing Camp on July 11, 2025 • 2 adults • 3 children

We did the kids fishing trip. Captain and crew were great with the entire family (kids age 8-12). Everyone caught fish, learned, and had fun. The captain also helped us with a cook what you catch restaurant which worked out great.

Reported catch:

Response from Captain

July 15, 2025

Thanks for coming aboard. Hope to see you again soon!

Trip availability and prices

Trip Date:

Days:

Group Size:

Select date to see availability

November 2025

Su	Mo	Tu	We	Th	Fr	Sa

Number of days

Group Size

2 adults • 0 children

Change

Almost there...

Half Day Trip (AM) - Inshore