Tried And True Charters
Tried And True Charters
Tried And True Charters and Captain Donnie Cyphers invite you to join them on a memorable fishing journey in Carolina Beach, North Carolina. Head out inshore, nearshore, as well as offshore to search for many different fish species and enjoy beautiful nature.
The captain is an experienced and cordial angler who’ll take you to the best spots and help you chase a variety of fish. Join him today and create wonderful memories on the water with Tried And True Charters!
You’ll be fishing from a 33’ Contender center console that can accommodate up to 5 guests. It runs on a twin 300 HP Yamaha engine and uses comprehensive navigation electronics so you can have a safe and quick trip to the fish and back.
The boat’s also got downriggers, outriggers, a livewell, a 96” Rhodan wireless trolling motor, and an icebox. A first mate will also join you on board to give you all the help you may need.
The species you can target include Barracuda, Mahi Mahi, Spanish Mackerel, Goliath Grouper, Sailfish, Black Seabass, and many more. To catch them, you’ll bottom fish, troll, spin, and jig on both light and heavy tackle. If you wish, you can keep and take home all of your catch and you’re free to bring kids on your trip.
The captain will cover all the fishing gear and licenses you need, as well as fish cleaning. This means that all you need to bring for your trip are any food and drinks you’d like to enjoy on board.
Join Capt. Donnie on the waters around Carolina Beach and experience a fishing adventure with Tried And True Charters!
Customer reviews
Rating summary
Photos & videos by reviewers (77)
+74Angler rating
Anglers claimed
Good experience
98%
Appropriate for children
98%
Friendly captain
100%
Satisfied with the boat
100%
Recommend this charter
99%
Caught fish
92%
Sep 7, 2025
Half Day Trip (AM)
Charter boat trip
What a wonderful day!! Donnie and Jack🏋️ were two of the best guys to hang out with for four hours! We caught six different kinds of fish and we came back with plenty of Spanish mackerel and flounder. They were both very knowledgeable during the entire trip and help us to understand everything about fishing. We would recommend their fishing charter to anybody that’s a novice to an expert! We had a great day and it’s one we will remember for a long time. Plan to book with him every time we’re down in Carolina Beach. Look him up on your next trip down here you will not be disappointed. We had a great time!! Mike and Donna A.🐟🐠🐡🍤🎏
What a wonderful day!! Donnie and Jack🏋️ were two of the best guys to hang out with for four hours! We caught six different kinds...
Jul 25, 2025
3 Hour Trip (PM)
First Charter – An Amazing Experience!
Our very first charter experience could not have been better! The five of us were celebrating a bachelorette, and even though none of us had ever been on a fishing trip before, we were instantly hooked. The boat ride was smooth, scenic, and surprisingly relaxing—no seasickness, no dull moments. We ended up reeling in an impressive 26 fish! The captain and first mate were incredible hosts, keeping the vibes high with our favorite music and making the whole day unforgettable. We’ll absolutely be back for round two!
Our very first charter experience could not have been better! The five of us were celebrating a bachelorette, and even though...
Jul 25, 2025
Special 3 hour trip for Tyler Plaster
First Charter - Memories Made
My Son (7) & I's first charter experience, It did not disappoint, Capt. Don & First Mate Nate know there fishing. They got us on the fish. If we return to Carolina Beach and want to do another charter, Ill be looking for these guys again.
My Son (7) & I's first charter experience, It did not disappoint, Capt. Don & First Mate Nate know there fishing. They got us...
Jun 25, 2025
3 Hour Trip - “Kids Trip” (PM )
Family had a great time
Captain Donnie and Jack were great. Super nice and knowledgeable. We caught the fish we were after and then they let my each one of my kids catch a shark. They will remember that forever. We will definitely book a trip with them again.
Captain Donnie and Jack were great. Super nice and knowledgeable. We caught the fish we were after and then they let my each one...
Aug 18, 2025
6 Hour Trip
Fish on!
Awesome day with Captain Donnie and his mate Jack. Fought huge amberjacks and caught a basket full of Spanish Mackerel. Lots of laughs along the way and will definitely book another trip in the near future.
Awesome day with Captain Donnie and his mate Jack. Fought huge amberjacks and caught a basket full of Spanish Mackerel. Lots of...
Trip availability and prices
| Su | Mo | Tu | We | Th | Fr | Sa | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Customer reviews
Rating summary
Photos & videos by reviewers (77)
+74Angler rating
Anglers claimed
Good experience
98%
Appropriate for children
98%
Friendly captain
100%
Satisfied with the boat
100%
Recommend this charter
99%
Caught fish
92%
Experience:
Boat
Crew
Overall
Charter boat trip
Half Day Trip (AM) on September 7, 2025
What a wonderful day!! Donnie and Jack🏋️ were two of the best guys to hang out with for four hours! We caught six different kinds of fish and we came back with plenty of Spanish mackerel and flounder. They were both very knowledgeable during the entire trip and help us to understand everything about fishing. We would recommend their fishing charter to anybody that’s a novice to an expert! We had a great day and it’s one we will remember for a long time. Plan to book with him every time we’re down in Carolina Beach. Look him up on your next trip down here you will not be disappointed. We had a great time!! Mike and Donna A.🐟🐠🐡🍤🎏
What a wonderful day!! Donnie and Jack🏋️ were two of the best guys to hang out with for four hours! We caught six different kinds of fish and we came back with plenty of Spanish mackerel and flounder. They were both very knowledgeable during the entire trip and help us to understand everything about fishing. We would recommend their fishing charter to anybody that’s a novice to an expert! We had a great day and it’s one we will remember for a long time. Plan to book with him every time we’re...
Experience:
Boat
Crew
Overall
First Charter – An Amazing Experience!
3 Hour Trip (PM) on July 25, 2025
Our very first charter experience could not have been better! The five of us were celebrating a bachelorette, and even though none of us had ever been on a fishing trip before, we were instantly hooked. The boat ride was smooth, scenic, and surprisingly relaxing—no seasickness, no dull moments. We ended up reeling in an impressive 26 fish! The captain and first mate were incredible hosts, keeping the vibes high with our favorite music and making the whole day unforgettable. We’ll absolutely be back for round two!
Our very first charter experience could not have been better! The five of us were celebrating a bachelorette, and even though none of us had ever been on a fishing trip before, we were instantly hooked. The boat ride was smooth, scenic, and surprisingly relaxing—no seasickness, no dull moments. We ended up reeling in an impressive 26 fish! The captain and first mate were incredible hosts, keeping the vibes high with our favorite music and making the whole day unforgettable. We’ll absolutely...
Experience:
Boat
Crew
Overall
First Charter - Memories Made
Special 3 hour trip for Tyler Plaster on July 25, 2025
My Son (7) & I's first charter experience, It did not disappoint, Capt. Don & First Mate Nate know there fishing. They got us on the fish. If we return to Carolina Beach and want to do another charter, Ill be looking for these guys again.
My Son (7) & I's first charter experience, It did not disappoint, Capt. Don & First Mate Nate know there fishing. They got us on the fish. If we return to Carolina Beach and want to do another charter, Ill be looking for these guys again.
Experience:
Boat
Crew
Overall
Family had a great time
3 Hour Trip - “Kids Trip” (PM ) on June 25, 2025
Captain Donnie and Jack were great. Super nice and knowledgeable. We caught the fish we were after and then they let my each one of my kids catch a shark. They will remember that forever. We will definitely book a trip with them again.
Captain Donnie and Jack were great. Super nice and knowledgeable. We caught the fish we were after and then they let my each one of my kids catch a shark. They will remember that forever. We will definitely book a trip with them again.
Experience:
Boat
Crew
Overall
Fish on!
6 Hour Trip on August 18, 2025
Awesome day with Captain Donnie and his mate Jack. Fought huge amberjacks and caught a basket full of Spanish Mackerel. Lots of laughs along the way and will definitely book another trip in the near future.
Awesome day with Captain Donnie and his mate Jack. Fought huge amberjacks and caught a basket full of Spanish Mackerel. Lots of laughs along the way and will definitely book another trip in the near future.
FAQs about Tried And True Charters
The fish you can target
What is the boat like?
