Scary Good Sportfishing 

5.0/5 (6 reviews)
 1083 Erie Street, Sunset Bay, NY 14081, United States
5.0/5 (6 reviews)
map-thumbnail
1083 Erie Street
Sunset Bay, NY, United States

Come spend a day with me chasing big walleyes! I’m a professional tournament guy as well as a charter captain with tons of experience in catching giant walleye! I will show you how and let you have as much hands on experience you want, I enjoy teaching my techniques and watching clients put that to use and catch the fish by them selves if they choose, please consider me for your next charter and lets fill that freezer!

Top targets include Walleye, and more, depending on the season. On the day of your trip, you’re likely to troll and bottom fish using light tackle.

Trips with Scary Good Sportfishing are fun for all ages, so get ‘em offline and onto the water! Children must wear life vests, so please make sure you have the right fitting one when coming on board. Also, remember to bring snacks so that nobody gets grumpy on an empty stomach!

You’ll be dropping lines from a 21’ Starcraft aluminum fishing boat with a capacity for 4 passengers. It has downriggers and all the essentials no fishing machine can run without. You’ll find rods, reels, and tackle waiting for you, along with lures. Live bait is available, but be sure to ask about it so you know if you’ll be catching it yourself.

You will need to buy a local fishing license before the trip. This information is usually available online, or you can ask the captain. Some species might be protected or require a tag to keep them, so make sure you know what to expect. A few items to bring include sunglasses, sunblock (non-spray), and bottled water. If you’d like to bring other drinks, just ask. Alcohol is allowed in moderation, but try to avoid hard liquor as well as glass bottles.

The click of a button is the only thing keeping you from a great day on the water with Scary Good Sportfishing!

Loading
Loading
Loading
Loading
Loading
Loading
Loading
Loading

Customer reviews

Rating summary

5.0/5
out of 5 stars from 6 reviews
Boat
5.0/5
Crew
5.0/5
Experience
5.0/5

Photos & videos by reviewers (8)

This guy is good... Scary Good!
This guy is good... Scary Good!
This guy is good... Scary Good!
+5

Angler rating

6
0
0
0
0

Anglers claimed

Good experience

100%

Appropriate for children

100%

Friendly captain

100%

Satisfied with the boat

100%

Recommend this charter

100%

Caught fish

100%

Showing 1 - 5 of 6 reviews
Showing: 5 of 6 reviews
Tina J.
Tina J.
5.0/5

Aug 6, 2025

Evening Trip

This guy is good... Scary Good!

VERIFIED
NEW

Our family of three had an amazing day out on the water with Captain Rob! He was incredibly attentive to our 8-year-old’s endless curiosity about fishing, and even hockey! He patiently answered every question, from types of fish and their size and weight, to which lures to use and how he came up with the name for his charter. He truly made the whole experience unforgettable. Thanks again, Captain Rob

Our family of three had an amazing day out on the water with Captain Rob! He was incredibly attentive to our 8-year-old’s endless...  

Review media 0
Review media 1
Review media 2
 Tina J. recommends Scary Good Sportfishing
 Tina J. recommends Scary Good Sportfishing

Ronald N.
Ronald N.
5.0/5

Jul 28, 2025

Half Day Trip (AM)

Great fishing trip!

VERIFIED
NEW

We had a great fishing trip thanks to captain Rob. He was very smart and had all the perfect equipment for our fishing trip. We all had our limit on walleye on that given day. My grandson will never forget that experience. He also caught the biggest fish that day! What else can I say?

We had a great fishing trip thanks to captain Rob. He was very smart and had all the perfect equipment for our fishing trip....  

Review media 0
Review media 1
 Ronald N. recommends Scary Good Sportfishing
 Ronald N. recommends Scary Good Sportfishing

Thomas P.
Thomas P.
5.0/5

Sep 29, 2024

Half Day Trip (AM)

Great captain, great day of fishing!

VERIFIED

Captain Rob was awesome from the moment we met him at the launch to cleaning our catch at the end of the day. Booked the trip with two young adult sons, all of us relatively novice fisherman. He was patient, shared information in a way that made it easy for us to understand it. Got us on fish early and often; not only did we catch quantity but we caught quality. Some real big walleye and steelhead trout. Can’t wait to cook it up.

Captain Rob was awesome from the moment we met him at the launch to cleaning our catch at the end of the day. Booked the trip...  

Review media 0
 Thomas P. recommends Scary Good Sportfishing
 Thomas P. recommends Scary Good Sportfishing

Christopher B.
Christopher B.
5.0/5

Jul 31, 2025

Half Day Trip (AM)

Amazing trip

VERIFIED
NEW

Tons of amazing fish

Tons of amazing fish  

Review media 0
Review media 1
 Christopher B. recommends Scary Good Sportfishing
 Christopher B. recommends Scary Good Sportfishing

Matthew N.
Matthew N.
5.0/5

Jun 27, 2025

Half Day Trip (AM)

Great trip!

VERIFIED

Captain Rob, Scary Good Sports Fishing, put us right on the fish immediately. He is extremely knowledgeable, fun, easy going and accommodating. I will use him again and highly recommend!

Captain Rob, Scary Good Sports Fishing, put us right on the fish immediately. He is extremely knowledgeable, fun, easy going and...  

 Matthew N. recommends Scary Good Sportfishing
 Matthew N. recommends Scary Good Sportfishing

Trip availability and prices

Trip Date:
Days:
Group Size:
Select date to see availability
August 2025
SuMoTuWeThFrSa
Loading...
Number of days
13
Group Size
3 adults • 0 children
Change
Almost there...
Evening Trip
FREE Cancellation 7 days notice
4 Hour Trip, starts at 3:00 PM
Loading...
US $5,200 
Entire boat: up to 4 people
Half Day Trip (AM)
FREE Cancellation 7 days notice
5 Hour Trip, starts at 6:00 AM
Loading...
US $5,525 
Entire boat: up to 4 people
Full Day Trip
FREE Cancellation 7 days notice
8 Hour Trip, starts at 6:00 AM
Loading...
US $7,475 
Entire boat: up to 4 people
There are 3 people looking at this charter.

Customer reviews

Rating summary

5.0/5
out of 5 stars from 6 reviews
Boat
5.0/5
Crew
5.0/5
Experience
5.0/5

Photos & videos by reviewers (8)

This guy is good... Scary Good!
This guy is good... Scary Good!
This guy is good... Scary Good!
+5

Angler rating

6
0
0
0
0

Anglers claimed

Good experience

100%

Appropriate for children

100%

Friendly captain

100%

Satisfied with the boat

100%

Recommend this charter

100%

Caught fish

100%

Showing 1 - 5 of 6 reviews
Showing: 5 of 6 reviews
Tina J.
Tina J.
5.0/5

Experience:

5.0/5

Boat

5.0/5

Crew

5.0/5

Overall

This guy is good... Scary Good!

VERIFIED
NEW

Evening Trip on August 6, 2025

Our family of three had an amazing day out on the water with Captain Rob! He was incredibly attentive to our 8-year-old’s endless curiosity about fishing, and even hockey! He patiently answered every question, from types of fish and their size and weight, to which lures to use and how he came up with the name for his charter. He truly made the whole experience unforgettable. Thanks again, Captain Rob

Our family of three had an amazing day out on the water with Captain Rob! He was incredibly attentive to our 8-year-old’s endless curiosity about fishing, and even hockey! He patiently answered every question, from types of fish and their size and weight, to which lures to use and how he came up with the name for his charter. He truly made the whole experience unforgettable. Thanks again, Captain Rob  

Review media 0
Review media 1
Review media 2
 Tina J. recommends Scary Good Sportfishing

Ronald N.
Ronald N.
5.0/5

Experience:

5.0/5

Boat

5.0/5

Crew

5.0/5

Overall

Great fishing trip!

VERIFIED
NEW

Half Day Trip (AM) on July 28, 2025

We had a great fishing trip thanks to captain Rob. He was very smart and had all the perfect equipment for our fishing trip. We all had our limit on walleye on that given day. My grandson will never forget that experience. He also caught the biggest fish that day! What else can I say?

We had a great fishing trip thanks to captain Rob. He was very smart and had all the perfect equipment for our fishing trip. We all had our limit on walleye on that given day. My grandson will never forget that experience. He also caught the biggest fish that day! What else can I say?  

Review media 0
Review media 1
 Ronald N. recommends Scary Good Sportfishing

Thomas P.
Thomas P.
5.0/5

Experience:

5.0/5

Boat

5.0/5

Crew

5.0/5

Overall

Great captain, great day of fishing!

VERIFIED

Half Day Trip (AM) on September 29, 2024

Captain Rob was awesome from the moment we met him at the launch to cleaning our catch at the end of the day. Booked the trip with two young adult sons, all of us relatively novice fisherman. He was patient, shared information in a way that made it easy for us to understand it. Got us on fish early and often; not only did we catch quantity but we caught quality. Some real big walleye and steelhead trout. Can’t wait to cook it up.

Captain Rob was awesome from the moment we met him at the launch to cleaning our catch at the end of the day. Booked the trip with two young adult sons, all of us relatively novice fisherman. He was patient, shared information in a way that made it easy for us to understand it. Got us on fish early and often; not only did we catch quantity but we caught quality. Some real big walleye and steelhead trout. Can’t wait to cook it up.  

Review media 0
 Thomas P. recommends Scary Good Sportfishing

Christopher B.
Christopher B.
5.0/5

Experience:

5.0/5

Boat

5.0/5

Crew

5.0/5

Overall

Amazing trip

VERIFIED
NEW

Half Day Trip (AM) on July 31, 2025

Tons of amazing fish

Tons of amazing fish  

Review media 0
Review media 1
 Christopher B. recommends Scary Good Sportfishing

Matthew N.
Matthew N.
5.0/5

Experience:

5.0/5

Boat

5.0/5

Crew

5.0/5

Overall

Great trip!

VERIFIED

Half Day Trip (AM) on June 27, 2025

Captain Rob, Scary Good Sports Fishing, put us right on the fish immediately. He is extremely knowledgeable, fun, easy going and accommodating. I will use him again and highly recommend!

Captain Rob, Scary Good Sports Fishing, put us right on the fish immediately. He is extremely knowledgeable, fun, easy going and accommodating. I will use him again and highly recommend!  

 Matthew N. recommends Scary Good Sportfishing

FAQs about Scary Good Sportfishing

Loading
Loading
Loading
Loading
Loading
Loading
Loading

The fish you can target

Loading
Loading
Loading
Loading
Loading

What is the boat like?

Boat Image
Boat category
Speed boats
Capacity
4 persons
Boat length
21 ft
Year built
2012
Boat manufacturer
Starcraft
Boat type
Runabout

Engine model
Yamaha
Powered by
1 x 200HP
Max cruising speed
35 knots
Loading
Loading
Loading
Loading
Loading
Loading
Loading
Loading
Loading
Loading

What’s biting in Sunset Bay right now

Loading