
Voted the #1 charter service on Sarasota Bay, Fish Ami Fishing Charters offers unbeatable prices and an exceptional fishing experience. Captain David M., a Sarasota native with over 20 years of local fishing expertise, leads our professional guides who fish these waters daily. With their knowledge and passion, you’re guaranteed to be on the best bite every time. We proudly offer a catch guarantee to make your trip worry-free and rewarding.
The rich waters of Sarasota Bay are teeming with Spanish Mackerel, Spotted Seatrout, Redfish, Snook, Sharks, Mangrove Snapper, Cobia, King Mackerel, Key West Grunts, Black Grouper, Gag Grouper, Red Grouper, and many more. Whether you’re a seasoned angler or a beginner, you’ll find yourself with tight lines and thrilling action.
Families are welcome aboard, with child-sized life vests available for safety and comfort. Feel free to bring snacks to keep your energy up throughout the trip. Your journey begins aboard a top-of-the-line 24-foot Godfrey pontoon or a 24-foot Pathfinder, both fully equipped to comfortably accommodate up to six passengers. The boats come loaded with all the essentials for an exciting day on the water.
Captain David supplies all rods, reels, lures, and live bait, along with a YETI cooler stocked with ice and water. Your fishing license is covered, so you can come aboard hassle-free. When it’s time to head in, your captain will expertly fillet and bag your catch. Please note that depending on the trip or regulations, some fish may need to be released; your captain will guide you through all fishing rules to ensure a responsible and enjoyable experience.
For your comfort, bring sunglasses and non-spray sunscreen. Drinks are provided, and moderate alcohol consumption is allowed, though hard liquor and glass bottles should be avoided. Treat yourself to a memorable day on the water with Fish Ami Sarasota—the island’s top-rated charter service. We look forward to welcoming you at the dock.
Rating summary
Photos & videos by reviewers (43)
Angler rating
Anglers claimed
Good experience
79%
Appropriate for children
100%
Friendly captain
100%
Satisfied with the boat
96%
Recommend this charter
81%
Caught fish
95%
Jun 13, 2025
4 Hour Trip – Inshore (PM)
Kyle, our captain, was a very knowledgeable and friendly guide. We were a family of young children and he offered plenty of patience with our kids lines getting tangled and baits being lost. We ended up catching several different types of fish and created many great memories for our kids. I highly recommend.
Kyle, our captain, was a very knowledgeable and friendly guide. We were a family of young children and he offered plenty of patience...
May 11, 2025
4 Hour Trip – Inshore (AM)
We had a wonderful Mother's Day morning out on the water with Kyle. My wife and I fish regularly but we had our three kids (11, 9, and almost 4) this trip and they all had a great experience. He was patient and we all had a wonderful half day. We would recommend Kyle to anyone.
We had a wonderful Mother's Day morning out on the water with Kyle. My wife and I fish regularly but we had our three kids (11,...
May 28, 2025
1.5 Hour Catch and Release (11 AM)
We caught fish in the mangroves which was awesome! David and Isaac are very knowledgeable and friendly. We got red drum and trout. Almost a cat fish! Everyone enjoyed it and david chopped up our fish and we made tacos for dinner!!
We caught fish in the mangroves which was awesome! David and Isaac are very knowledgeable and friendly. We got red drum and trout....
Aug 1, 2025
4 Hour Trip – Offshore (PM)
Captain Dave was awesome! We went out to the 20 mile buoy and found a big school of mahi mahi. 13 catches later and we were set for dinner! We had an excellent time and would definitely charter with Fish Ami again!
Captain Dave was awesome! We went out to the 20 mile buoy and found a big school of mahi mahi. 13 catches later and we were set...
Jun 7, 2025
1.5 Hour - Catch and Release (9 AM)
We had a great time out with Captain Kyle! He was wailing to take pictures of us (great pics too!). Every one of us caught multiple fish. We definitely recommend and will be doing this again!!
We had a great time out with Captain Kyle! He was wailing to take pictures of us (great pics too!). Every one of us caught multiple...
| Su | Mo | Tu | We | Th | Fr | Sa | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Rating summary
Photos & videos by reviewers (43)
Angler rating
Anglers claimed
Good experience
79%
Appropriate for children
100%
Friendly captain
100%
Satisfied with the boat
96%
Recommend this charter
81%
Caught fish
95%

Experience:
Boat
Crew
Overall
4 Hour Trip – Inshore (PM) on June 13, 2025
Kyle, our captain, was a very knowledgeable and friendly guide. We were a family of young children and he offered plenty of patience with our kids lines getting tangled and baits being lost. We ended up catching several different types of fish and created many great memories for our kids. I highly recommend.
Kyle, our captain, was a very knowledgeable and friendly guide. We were a family of young children and he offered plenty of patience with our kids lines getting tangled and baits being lost. We ended up catching several different types of fish and created many great memories for our kids. I highly recommend.
Experience:
Boat
Crew
Overall
4 Hour Trip – Inshore (AM) on May 11, 2025
We had a wonderful Mother's Day morning out on the water with Kyle. My wife and I fish regularly but we had our three kids (11, 9, and almost 4) this trip and they all had a great experience. He was patient and we all had a wonderful half day. We would recommend Kyle to anyone.
We had a wonderful Mother's Day morning out on the water with Kyle. My wife and I fish regularly but we had our three kids (11, 9, and almost 4) this trip and they all had a great experience. He was patient and we all had a wonderful half day. We would recommend Kyle to anyone.
Experience:
Boat
Crew
Overall
1.5 Hour Catch and Release (11 AM) on May 28, 2025
We caught fish in the mangroves which was awesome! David and Isaac are very knowledgeable and friendly. We got red drum and trout. Almost a cat fish! Everyone enjoyed it and david chopped up our fish and we made tacos for dinner!!
We caught fish in the mangroves which was awesome! David and Isaac are very knowledgeable and friendly. We got red drum and trout. Almost a cat fish! Everyone enjoyed it and david chopped up our fish and we made tacos for dinner!!
Experience:
Boat
Crew
Overall
4 Hour Trip – Offshore (PM) on August 1, 2025
Captain Dave was awesome! We went out to the 20 mile buoy and found a big school of mahi mahi. 13 catches later and we were set for dinner! We had an excellent time and would definitely charter with Fish Ami again!
Captain Dave was awesome! We went out to the 20 mile buoy and found a big school of mahi mahi. 13 catches later and we were set for dinner! We had an excellent time and would definitely charter with Fish Ami again!

Experience:
Boat
Crew
Overall
1.5 Hour - Catch and Release (9 AM) on June 7, 2025
We had a great time out with Captain Kyle! He was wailing to take pictures of us (great pics too!). Every one of us caught multiple fish. We definitely recommend and will be doing this again!!
We had a great time out with Captain Kyle! He was wailing to take pictures of us (great pics too!). Every one of us caught multiple fish. We definitely recommend and will be doing this again!!
