Search
Andy Grisenthwaite
Captain

Andy Grisenthwaite

Oswego, United States
25+ reviews
With over 20 years of Lake Ontario angling experience and over 10 years of Guiding and Chartering experience, I strive to provide the Lake Ontario fishing experience you desire. Although my primary goal is to offer my Clients the best fishing opportunity possible, I also provide a social and comfortable environment to promote a well-rounded Lake Ontario fishing charter which is really more than 'just fishing.'

Charter

Rating

4.9
37 reviews
4.9
Boat & Equipment
5.0
Captain & Crew
4.9
Fishing Experience

What anglers say

100%
Recommend this charter
97%
Caught fish

All reviews (37)

Showing 1 – 5 of 37 reviews
  • Thomas Van Den Bergh
    Thomas Van Den Bergh
    Repeat angler
    us
    New York, US
    Member since 2023
    5 trips
    5.0
    Verified

    Broad Horizons Delivered

    Full Day Trip • 4 adults

    Can't say enough good things about our 8 hour trip with Capt Andy on Broad Horizons. Key notes include communications prior to the trip, on time and ready to go the morning of the trip, fishing within 45 minutes of leaving port, the Penn Yan boat being a roomy platform to fish from with a cabin to escape the sun when needed, excellent fishing gear and a Capt that worked all day keeping our lines in the water and fishing. Add on the benefit of a great weather day, and our party maxing our limit, and we could not have asked or expected more. We'll be back.

    Reported catch:
    Salmon
    Rainbow Trout (Steelhead)
  • Vince Splendido
    Vince Splendido
    Repeat angler
    us
    Pennsylvania, US
    Member since 2026
    2 trips
    4.7
    Verified

    Freezer is full

    6 Hour Trip (AM) • 2 adults

    Tough day to fish. Cold, windy and fog. Captain Andy worked hard to get us on fish. Despite all the challenges we scored big. My wife got her “bucket list “salmon at about 20 lbs. plus several more. Back at the dock he filleted and hand packed our catch neat and clean. Andy was friendly and accommodating. 5 star captain.

    Reported catch:
    Salmon
    Coho Salmon
  • Sean Todd
    Sean Todd
    Repeat angler
    us
    New York, US
    Member since 2025
    2 trips
    5.0
    Verified

    Great trip

    6 Hour Trip (AM) • 6 adults

    Captain Andy had a wealth of knowledge to share. We caught out first fish not 5 minutes after all the lines were in the water. All 4 of us tagged out.

    Reported catch:
    Chinook Salmon
    Brown Trout
  • Wayne Hummel
    Wayne Hummel
    us
    Pennsylvania, US
    Member since 2026
    5.0
    Verified

    Great trip very nice captain.

    6 Hour Trip (PM) • 3 adults

    First one we hooked was a great fish gave a good fight. That was the biggest for the day. But got into some other small salmon to finish out the day.

    Reported catch:
    Salmon
  • Will Covington
    Will Covington
    us
    New York, US
    Member since 2026
    5.0
    Verified

    Awesome trip!

    6 Hour Trip (PM) • 4 adults

    We had a great time with Captain Andy! Lots of a fish and a perfect day. Definitely recommend!

Real catches shared by our community

  • Broad Horizons Guide and Charter Service
    Broad Horizons Guide and Charter ServiceOswego, NY
    Angler proudly displaying a large Lake Trout while fishing on a boat, showcasing a successful day on the water.
    Fish 1
    Fish 2
    +1
    Lake Trout
    John S.
    John S.
  • Broad Horizons Guide and Charter Service
    Broad Horizons Guide and Charter ServiceOswego, NY
    An angler proudly displaying a large Salmon caught during a fishing trip, set against a scenic waterfront backdrop.
    Fish 1
    Fish 2
    Coho Salmon
    Vince S.
    Vince S.
    Tough day to fish. Cold, windy and fog. Captain Andy worked hard to get us on fish. Despite all the challenges we scored big. My wife got her “bucket list “salmon at about 20 lbs. plus several more. Back at the dock he filleted and hand packed our catch neat and clean. Andy was friendly and accommodating. 5 star captain.
  • Broad Horizons Guide and Charter Service
    Broad Horizons Guide and Charter ServiceOswego, NY
    Angler proudly displaying a freshly caught Rainbow Trout aboard a fishing boat, with sparkling water in the background.
    Fish 1
    Fish 2
    Rainbow Trout (Steelhead)
    Michael C.
    Michael C.
    Capt was awesome. End of the season he worked it and put us on fish. Would definitely recommend.
  • Broad Horizons Guide and Charter Service
    Broad Horizons Guide and Charter ServiceOswego, NY
    A relaxed angler seated at the helm of a fishing boat, enjoying the ocean view while preparing for a fishing adventure.
    Shawn S.
    Shawn S.
    Afternoon evening trip with Capt. Andy. Beautiful afternoon on the lake. Dynamite sunset. Capt. Andy kept pulling out all the tricks to attract the fish, but they were stubborn and only 1 came to join us. But a fun day ovrrall
  • Broad Horizons Guide and Charter Service
    Broad Horizons Guide and Charter ServiceOswego, NY
    Teen angler holding a striped fish aboard a charter boat, with fishing rods and open water visible in the background.
    Fish 1
    Fish 2
    Rainbow Trout (Steelhead)
    Greg M.
    Greg M.
    It was an amazing enjoyable day out on the lake. We caught two King Salmon. Wish we had caught a couple more fish. Look forward to doing it again!
  • Broad Horizons Guide and Charter Service
    Broad Horizons Guide and Charter ServiceOswego, NY
    Adult angler proudly holding a large lake trout aboard a fishing boat on open water, with rods and boat railings visible.
    Fish 1
    Lake Trout
    Shelley E.
    Shelley E.
  • Broad Horizons Guide and Charter Service
    Broad Horizons Guide and Charter ServiceOswego, NY
    Solo angler holding a large predatory fish aboard a fishing boat offshore, with trolling rods and open ocean visible.
    Fish 1
    Chinook Salmon
    Steven P.
    Steven P.
    Fantastic time. Captain Andy and Randall were awesome! Highly recommend.
  • Broad Horizons Guide and Charter Service
    Broad Horizons Guide and Charter ServiceOswego, NY
    A serene sunset view from inside the boat, showcasing a relaxed angler enjoying the peaceful waters.
    Fish 1
    Chinook Salmon
    Don B.
    Don B.
    Great trip with Andy.
  • Broad Horizons Guide and Charter Service
    Broad Horizons Guide and Charter ServiceOswego, NY
    Angler proudly holds a large bluefish aboard a fishing boat, with a second crew member visible offshore.
    Fish 1
    Fish 2
    Coho Salmon
    Gregory T.
    Gregory T.
    We have a great day On the Lake with Captain Andy and first mate Randle... thanks guys
  • Broad Horizons Guide and Charter Service
    Broad Horizons Guide and Charter ServiceOswego, NY
    Two anglers proudly displaying a large Lake Trout aboard a fishing boat, with a young boy in the background enjoying the experience.
    Fish 1
    Fish 2
    +4
    Lake Trout
    Nick B.
    Nick B.
    Andy and Rich crushed it from start to finish. They put us on fish constantly over two days including Browns, Lakers, Whitefish, Cohos, Atlantics, and even an early season King. Fantastic guys that have extensive knowledge and a great sense of humor. Would recommend 100%.

What's biting with Broad Horizons Guide and Charter Service in Oswego

Experienced anglers should head into the Salmon River to try their luck against Steehlead. Looking to hook Walleye? There's no better fishery than Oneida Lake.

Top catches for November