Captain

Garrett Frey

Stock Island, United States

10+ reviews

Captain Garret Frey has been fishing since he was a kid. He moved to Key West because he wanted to do fishing full time, and hasn't looked back since. Nothing excites him like the adrenaline rush when a big one starts tugging at the line. Always eager to share the knowledge with his guests, you can count on Capt. Garret to always give his 110%.

Charters

All In Fishing Charters
Stock Island
Trips from
US $700
ALL IN Fishing Charters
Stock Island
Instant Confirmation
Trips from
US $700

Rating

5.0

14 reviews

5.0

Boat & Equipment

5.0

Captain & Crew

5.0

Fishing Experience

Anglers' gallery (15)

All reviews (14)

Showing 1 – 5 of 14 reviews

Jessica Irick
Repeat angler
South Carolina, US
Member since 2022
3 trips
5.0
Verified
December fishing trip
3/4 Day Trip – Wreck & Reef on December 29, 2025 • 4 adults
Anthony Bianco
Florida, US
Member since 2020
5.0
Verified
Half day trip with Captain Garret Frey
Half Day Trip — Offshore on August 30, 2020 • 4 adults
We set out to do some Mahi Mahi fishing while on vacation here in Key West. We booked a reservation and we were on our way at 0800 on a Sunday. Captain Frey took us out and about an hour into the trip we were still looking for our signs of life, not a bird in the sky, no weed line, no balls of bait, nodda. Captain Frey didn’t give up though. Eventually we found some life and landed a nice tuna. We moved a bit, and found another. The next thing you know we had all three lines tight and we got 3 more black fins in the boat. We continued this chasing birds and splashes on top of the water for the remainder of the day. It was great, our arms were TIRED. When we got back in, Captain Frey filet our fish and bagged them up. I’ve been on several charters before this and I’ll say without a double this was the most fun!
Frank Rodriguez
Repeat angler
Florida, US
Member since 2019
8 trips
5.0
Verified
3/4 day trip
3/4 Day Trip — Wreck & Reef Fishing on August 29, 2020 • 2 adults
What a great day of fishing! We landed 6 black groupers, all of them legal size. It was nonstop action through the trip, first 2 casts we landed 2 amberjacks within minutes. Captain Garrett definitely knows what he’s doing. He kept moving us to different spots and put us on fish immediately. We had quite a few fish breaks us off, there were definitely some monster fish down there. The boat and equipment are all in excellent condition and captain Garrett is constantly washing off any blood and keeping his eyes open for fish. Highly recommend him if your aim is to be battling fish the whole trip.
Joe Kelly
Repeat angler
California, US
Member since 2020
7 trips
5.0
Verified
3/4 day with All In
3/4 Day Trip — Wreck & Reef Fishing on April 8, 2021 • 2 adults
We had a great 3/4 day reef and wreck trip with Captain Garrett. We caught plenty of fish for dinner and got to pull on some big Sharks and jacks. Steady action from start to finish!
David Ritzenthaler
Ohio, US
Member since 2020
5.0
Verified
Fishing with Garrett
Half Day Trip — Wreck and Reef on January 5, 2021 • 5 adults
Professional, fun, great experience.......Capt. Garrett knows where and how to catch fish. We will use him again.