Search
Nicholas Shuler
Captain

Nicholas Shuler

Geneva-on-the-Lake, United States
10+ reviews
I have been fishing the central basin of Lake Erie since 1995. I decide to charter full time after I retired in 2021. There is nothing more enjoyable than fishing the great Lakes

Charter

Keepin It Reel

Keepin It Reel

Geneva-on-the-Lake
Instant Confirmation
Trips from
US $150

Rating

5.0
12 reviews
5.0
Boat & Equipment
5.0
Captain & Crew
5.0
Fishing Experience

All reviews (12)

Showing 1 – 5 of 12 reviews
  • John Gallow
    John Gallow
    Repeat angler
    us
    Ohio, US
    Member since 2023
    2 trips
    5.0
    Verified

    Great 2 days with Kick, several very large Walleyes, 28”27” amd seveal over 20”, max catch. Very nice to have a bathroom and lots of room in the fishing area.

    8 Hour Trip • 4 adults

    Great Captain Nick- max catch and several over 20”++, nice to have a bathroom and lots of room for fishing .

    Response from Captain

    Thanks for the review John It was a pleasure having you guys on board

  • Robert Friend
    Robert Friend
    us
    Ohio, US
    Member since 2026
    5.0
    Verified

    great trip

    8 Hour Trip • 4 adults • 2 children

    had a really good time took my grandsons out fishing and it was great 

    Response from Captain

    Thank you for choosing Keepin It Reel it was a pleasure having you guys

  • Matthew Zandier
    Matthew Zandier
    us
    Pennsylvania, US
    Member since 2026
    5.0
    Verified

    Fishing with Nicholas

    8 Hour Trip • 4 adults
    Reported catch:
    Walleye
    Response from Captain

    Thank you for fishing with us today

  • Sean Buckner
    Sean Buckner
    us
    Ohio, US
    Member since 2025
    5.0
    Verified

    Walleye master

    8 Hour Trip • 4 adults • 1 child

    I couldn’t be more happy with the whole experience. I got the charter for my son’s birthday and the capt. and dirt mate made sure we were on the bite and stayed on the bite. We limited out with in a few hours the 1st mate stayed busy netting fish and dropping line back in. As soon as we dropped a line in there was another fish. The whole experience was just out of this world I will be going back to this charter time and time again.

    Reported catch:
    Walleye
    Response from Captain

    Thank Sean it was a pleasure fishing with you and your crew

  • Jake Zimmerman
    Jake Zimmerman
    Repeat angler
    us
    Pennsylvania, US
    Member since 2024
    3 trips
    5.0
    Verified

    First time for the wife

    Walk On • 3 adults

    First time Whaley fishing for the wife she really enjoyed it wants to go again have an autistic son who is non verbal he also had a great time caught are limits plus most were keepers captain Nick Shuler and Doug couldn't have been any more accommodating would go with them again don't hesitate to book them they are the real deal thanks again guys it's all about making memories!!

    Response from Captain

    Thank you so much. I am glad everyone enjoyed the it

Real catches shared by our community

  • Keepin It Reel
    Keepin It ReelGeneva-on-the-Lake, OH
    A group of four anglers proudly posing in front of a catch board displaying a successful haul of Walleye after a fishing trip on Lake Erie.
    Fishing continues to be very good out of Geneva
  • Keepin It Reel
    Keepin It ReelGeneva-on-the-Lake, OH
    A family proudly poses in front of a catch board displaying multiple Walleye after a successful fishing trip on Lake Erie.
    Robert F.
    Robert F.
    had a really good time took my grandsons out fishing and it was great 
  • Keepin It Reel
    Keepin It ReelGeneva-on-the-Lake, OH
    A family poses proudly in front of a catch board displaying multiple Walleye after a successful fishing trip on Lake Erie.
    It wasn't fast but we got it done and those young boys hung in there to get there limits
  • Keepin It Reel
    Keepin It ReelGeneva-on-the-Lake, OH
    An angler proudly displaying a large Walleye caught while fishing on a boat, showcasing a beautiful day on the water.
    Ed's wife booked Ed a fishing charter for his 87th Birthday and although the weather did not let us get them out on his birthday we did manage to get him out on Tuesday. Ed pulled in a 27 in hog to start the trip and we added 12 more nice fish before the lake kicked up. I think it's safe to say Ed enjoyed his time on the water and we were very blessed to be able to get Ed and his wife out in celebration ? of his birthday. God Bless
  • Keepin It Reel
    Keepin It ReelGeneva-on-the-Lake, OH
    Group of anglers proudly posing in front of a catch board displaying a successful haul of Walleye after a fishing trip on Lake Erie.
    Season is starting to wind down but the action is still on fire
  • Keepin It Reel
    Keepin It ReelGeneva-on-the-Lake, OH
    Group of anglers proudly posing in front of a catch board displaying multiple Walleye after a successful fishing trip on Lake Erie.
    Fish 1
    Yellow Perch
    Matthew Z.
    Matthew Z.
  • Keepin It Reel
    Keepin It ReelGeneva-on-the-Lake, OH
    A proud angler displays a large Walleye caught during a fishing trip at Lake Erie, with a backdrop of multiple fish hanging on a display board.
    Fish 1
    Yellow Perch
    Another day of slamming Walleye. The fishing out of Geneva is incredible
  • Keepin It Reel
    Keepin It ReelGeneva-on-the-Lake, OH
    Adult angler displaying a large walleye in front of a Lake Erie catch board with multiple mounted fish and a cooler.
    Fish 1
    Yellow Perch
    The fishing out of Geneva is as good as it's going to get. The Big Boys are here and if your thinking about getting out now is the time
  • Keepin It Reel
    Keepin It ReelGeneva-on-the-Lake, OH
    Three anglers proudly posing in front of a catch board displaying a successful haul of Walleye after a fishing trip on Lake Erie.
    We had a quick 3 person trip this morning. The fishing is on fire. If your looking to fill your freezer now is the time
  • Keepin It Reel
    Keepin It ReelGeneva-on-the-Lake, OH
    Two anglers proudly posing beside a catch board displaying an impressive haul of Walleye after a successful fishing trip on Lake Erie.
    Dipseys and wire were both working today and the quality of fish is awesome. Give me a call to get on board

What's biting with Keepin It Reel in Geneva-on-the-Lake

Top catches for November

Fishing reports

A group of four anglers proudly posing in front of a catch board displaying a successful haul of Walleye after a fishing trip on Lake Erie.

Great Fishing Out of Geneva

Sep 9, 2026 • Geneva-on-the-Lake
Fishing continues to be very good out of Geneva
Show more
A family poses proudly in front of a catch board displaying multiple Walleye after a successful fishing trip on Lake Erie.

We Hauled In Limits — Young Anglers Stay

Sep 2, 2026 • Geneva-on-the-Lake
It wasn't fast but we got it done and those young boys hung in there to get there limits
Show more
An angler proudly displaying a large Walleye caught while fishing on a boat, showcasing a beautiful day on the water.

Ed's 87th: 27" Hog and a Dozen More

Aug 18, 2026 • Geneva-on-the-Lake
Ed's wife booked Ed a fishing charter for his 87th Birthday and although the weather did not let us get them out on his birthday we did manage to get him out on Tuesday. Ed pulled in a 27 in hog to start the trip and we added 12 more nice fish before the lake kicked up. I think it's safe to say Ed enjoyed his time on the water and we were very blessed to be able to get Ed and his wife out in celebration ? of his birthday. God Bless
Show more
Angler holding a fishing lure in front of a large arranged display of Lake Erie walleye on a charter catch board.

Season Is Starting to Wind Down

Aug 15, 2026 • Geneva-on-the-Lake
Season is starting to wind down but the action is still on fire
Show more
A proud angler displays a large Walleye caught during a fishing trip at Lake Erie, with a backdrop of multiple fish hanging on a display board.

Slamming Walleye Out of Geneva

Aug 10, 2026 • Geneva-on-the-Lake
Another day of slamming Walleye. The fishing out of Geneva is incredible
Show more
Adult angler proudly holding a large walleye beside a fish display board at a Geneva, Ohio fishing location.

The Big Boys are here

Aug 4, 2026 • Geneva-on-the-Lake
The fishing out of Geneva is as good as it's going to get. The Big Boys are here and if your thinking about getting out now is the time
Show more