John Kostinas

Rating

Anglers' gallery (34)

• 

  Michelle Noble

  

  Virginia, US

  •

  Member since 2026

  5.0

  Verified

  Amazing Experience

  4 Hour Trip on June 20, 2026 • 6 adults

  I booked the Old School charter for my son, nephew, and their friends, and I couldn’t be happier with the experience! I was a little apprehensive at first since they were new on FishingBooker, but Captain John was incredibly helpful from the very beginning and quickly put my mind at ease. All six young men had an absolute blast on the morning half-day trip. Before they left, I told them that fishing is all about the experience and not to be disappointed if they didn’t catch anything. Well, I didn’t need to worry! Every single one of them caught multiple fish—more than two each—and they were beyond excited. The first mate went above and beyond by cleaning, filleting, and packaging all of their fish for us. As soon as they got home, we made fish tacos using the crew’s recommendation, and they were amazing! Most importantly, thank you to Captain John and the crew for keeping my babies safe while giving them an unforgettable experience. I highly, highly recommend Old School to anyone looking for a fun, professional, and family-friendly fishing charter. We will definitely be back!

  • 
  • 
  • 
  • 

  

  Response from Captain

  June 21, 2026

  Michelle, thanks for the review. we really enjoyed having you son an his friends on board. They are a great bunch of guys and were a pleasure to fish with. everybody had a good time and there was enough fishing action to keep things exciting. I hope to see your group again, and maybe next time you can save a spot in the group for yourself. Moms need to have fun and catch fish too.

• 

  Frank Kapp

  Repeat angler

  

  Washington D.C., US

  •

  Member since 2022

  •

  2 trips

  5.0

  Verified

  Bluefish galore!

  2 Hour Trip – Cruise With Fishing - 4:00 PM on August 12, 2026 • 3 adults • 2 children

  Great 2 hour trip with lots of action! A little lull in the middle after some quick catches but Capt John (Gene) got us back on the fish and we almost caught our limit. We were only 2 short and he even stayed out a few extra minutes to try and get them. Our mate, Cam, kept the lines going after all the catches and then did a great job cleaning the fish. Will definitely reach out again next year! Thanks for a great trip!

  Reported catch:

  

  

  Response from Captain

  August 13, 2026

  Frank, thanks for the review. We really enjoyed fishing with you and your son and daughter. Everyone had fun and everone caught fish, that's what fishing is all about. we hope to se you guys again in the future.

• 

  Patricia Kauffman

  

  Maryland, US

  •

  Member since 2026

  5.0

  Verified

  Best trip EVER!

  2 Hour Trip – Cruise With Fishing on June 13, 2026 • 5 adults

  We all had a great experience! We caught Spanish Mackerels and Blues. That was the first time in years we ever got fish while out on a boat. The Captain was wonderful showed my boys around the boat and answered all of their questions. The mate(crew) did a GREAT job as well . We all had the BEST trip ever. Even got a little sun tan! Thanks so much for the memories we made!

  • 
  • 
  • 

  

  Response from Captain

  June 14, 2026

  Thanks Patricia. we loved having you and you family onboard, and it was an honor to be part of your son's birthday memories. I hope to see you guys again in the future. .

• 

  Lauren Alexander

  

  Maryland, US

  •

  Member since 2026

  5.0

  Verified

  Awesome trip!!

  2 Hour Trip – Cruise With Fishing on July 29, 2026 • 5 adults • 3 children

  We had a fantastic time on Old School charter boat!! The Captain and mate were very knowledgable and helpful. We had 3 young kids and they helped teach them how to fish. They helped us catch almost 20 bluefish and the mate cleaned then for us. We also saw dolphins and had a great time out on the water. We will book with them again.

  Reported catch:

  
• 

  Kelsey Stock

  

  Pennsylvania, US

  •

  Member since 2026

  5.0

  Verified

  NEW

  Such a sweet team

  2 Hour Trip – Cruise With Fishing on August 22, 2026 • 6 adults • 1 child

  John and Brit are a dynamic duo!! Very knowledgeable very kind. The boat was very clean and very well organized. I would 100% fish with them again!

  • 

  Reported catch:

  

  

  Response from Captain

  August 24, 2026

  Thanks Kelsey, really enjoyed fishing wiyh you.