Key West
Instant Confirmation
Trips from
US $800
Charter operator
Too Lethal Charters
Key West, United States
100+ reviews
The Too Lethal Charters crew prides itself on being transparent with their customers. Captain Scott enjoys his time with his customers out on the water. He is very helpful and will do everything he can to make sure your day out with him is great. He's up for fishing all day, every day, 365 days a year.
Charter
Rating
4.7
122 reviews
4.7
Boat & Equipment
4.7
Captain & Crew
4.7
Fishing Experience
Anglers' gallery (177)
What anglers say
85%
Good experience
90%
Friendly captain
91%
Recommend this charter
90%
Appropriate for children
98%
Satisfied with the boat
99%
Caught fish
All reviews (122)
Showing 1 – 5 of 122 reviews
Joe Berk
Ohio, US•Member since 20265.0VerifiedA very successful trip
Half Day Trip - 1:00 PM • 2 adultsThough the fish weren’t the biggest, it was better because we caught the best tasting. we ended up with 23 yellowtail snapper. Captain Scott Gordon made sure that we knew the technique of catching the fish and that we would maintain the technique. I have been fishing here in Key West for years and this was the most successful trip I’ve had. Also extremely involved as you’re not just trolling for fish. You cast, you reel, you catch! We will be booking again in November, when I come back.
Brandon HornsbyFlorida, US•Member since 20265.0VerifiedGreat trip!
Half Day Trip - 1:00 PM • 4 adults • 1 childGreat Fishing Charter Experience! We booked this charter at the last minute and couldn’t have been happier with how everything worked out. The trip was successful, the boat had plenty of room, and the equipment was in great shape and ready to go. The captain was friendly, knowledgeable, and clearly knew the area and what he was doing. He made the trip enjoyable and was great to spend the day on the water with. Definitely recommend this charter and would book with them again!
Laura BrueggerNorth Carolina, US•Member since 20255.0VerifiedAmazing!!!
3/4 Day Trip • 4 adultsIf you want to catch fish and have a great time Captain Scott owner of Too Lethal fishing is the way to go! None of us had fished on reefs before, but Captain Scott patiently showed us what to do to catch fish. We caught yellowtail snapper and black grouper. Captain Scott was polite, patient, funny and worked extremely hard to make sure we caught fish. I highly recommend Too Lethal Charter and Captain Scott!!!!
Reported catch:
Response from Charter operator
Craig EbersoldRepeat anglerTexas, US•Member since 2026•2 trips5.0VerifiedToo Lethal — Excellent Shark Fishing Trip
Half Day Trip - 1:00 PM • 3 adults • 1 childWe went out on a choppy day, but Captain Scott knew exactly what he was doing. He found a calm spot that made all the difference, and the fishing was incredible—we ended up catching some huge sharks. His experience, instincts, and ability to adapt to the conditions made for an awesome trip. Highly recommend fishing with Too Lethal if you want results and a great time on the water.
Reported catch:
Response from Charter operatorWow! Thank you for that awesome review! Hope to see you & Milo again
Gerwin Van Der Koppel
Netherlands•Member since 20265.0VerifiedAmazing with with my doughter
Half Day Trip • 2 adults • 1 childI had an amazing time with my doughter and captain Scott! We went out for a 4 ours fishing trip in the morning. Scott realy cares about the “little” girl and have a lot of patience! We cathed some nice fish like Yellow fin, Bonita and mackerel! I would recommand Scott and his boat to anyone who is looking for a nice fishing trip! Greetings from the Netherlands
Real catches shared by our community
- Too Lethal ChartersKey West, FL
- Too Lethal ChartersKey West, FL
- Too Lethal ChartersKey West, FL
- Too Lethal ChartersKey West, FL
- Too Lethal ChartersKey West, FL
- Too Lethal ChartersKey West, FL
- Too Lethal ChartersKey West, FL
- Too Lethal ChartersKey West, FL
- Too Lethal ChartersKey West, FL
- Too Lethal ChartersKey West, FL
What's biting with Too Lethal Charters in Key West
The weather cools and the crowds thin. This is the best time of year to score a Slam on the flats. The weather can be unpredictable with hurricanes, but the fishing makes it worth while.
Top catches for September
Fishing reports
Phillip &AJ Bell
Jun 1, 2026 • Key West
3/4 day trip
25 yellowtail snappers and 5 mutton snappers
Show more
Lane Snapper in Gulf of America
Feb 27, 2026 • Key West
Plenty action today ! Non stop bites kept 40 fish probably caught 100
Show more
Roxanne's Birthday fishing trip
Dec 9, 2025 • Key West
Stu -Jose -Roxanne & Yvonne did a 4 hr trip for Roxannes birthday - despite tough conditions we managed to pull together decent catch
Show more
40th birthday fishing trip
Nov 15, 2025 • Key West
Caught 23 yellowtail snappers 5 yellowjacks ( kept 3 ) 1 kingfish. 1 Barracuda couple cero mackerals released several small yellowtails and a horse eye jack - lots of action lots of bites
Show more
Non stop bites
Nov 4, 2025 • Key West
Had Dave & Sarah Markert out for a 4 hr trip yesterday - Non stop bites ! More catching than fishing -Dave did the catching and Sarah took the pictures -They took some of the catch to the Boathouse Bar &Grill where a feast was prepared
Show more
Backcountry fishing with The Bauer Famil
Oct 14, 2025 • Key West
The wind started blowing today so i took the Bauer Family to the calm backcountry waters -spent a little bit of time looking for snappers to no avail- then went to my shark where 11 year old Jacob caught 3 sharks
2 Lemons and 1 blacktip - Mom and Dad each caught one plus we pulled the hooks on a few
Show more