Search
Vince Silvaggi
Captain

Vince Silvaggi

Fairview, United States
50+ reviews
I've been hooked since I was 3 years old. I grew up fishing the Great Lakes with my dad and grandfather. I've had the dream of becoming a charter captain since I was about 12 years old. Now I own and operate Old Timer Charters.
Daniel S.
Daniel S.
First mate
Heather Z.
Heather Z.
First mate

Charter

Rating

4.9
95 reviews
4.9
Boat & Equipment
4.9
Captain & Crew
4.8
Fishing Experience

What anglers say

96%
Good experience
99%
Friendly captain
97%
Recommend this charter
91%
Appropriate for children
99%
Satisfied with the boat
98%
Caught fish

All reviews (95)

Showing 1 – 5 of 95 reviews
  • Emma Pitta
    Emma Pitta
    us
    Virginia, US
    Member since 2026

    The captain canceled

    Trip was supposed to happen on October 23, 2026
    The charter operator canceled 2 days prior to the trip date. This is an automated posting.
  • Dean Talmonti
    Dean Talmonti
    us
    Pennsylvania, US
    Member since 2025
    4.7
    Verified

    great trip.

    Full Day Trip – Walleye • 4 adults

    The trip itself was great, but the customer service afterward was unacceptable. My group was reduced by one person, and the captain specifically instructed me to contact Fish Booker for a refund. I did exactly that and received absolutely no response. Being completely ignored after following the captain’s is unacceptable. This experience has left me extremely disappointed, and because of the lack of communication and customer service, I do not know if i will be recommending Fish Booker.

    Reported catch:
    Walleye
  • Daniel Steingraber
    Daniel Steingraber
    us
    Pennsylvania, US
    Member since 2026
    5.0
    Verified

    Awesome choice!

    Half Day Trip – Walleye (AM) • 3 adults

    Had a great trip with Vince and his first mate. Had us on fish all day. Very friendly and prompt and professional communication before the trip. I highly recommend and will be booking again for sure!

    Reported catch:
    Walleye
    Response from Captain

    I'm glad everyone had a good time and look forward to doing it again.

  • Pam Kline
    Pam Kline
    us
    Pennsylvania, US
    Member since 2026
    5.0
    Verified

    Great, knowledgeable crew

    Half Day Trip – Walleye (AM) • 2 adults

    Captain Vince made sure we caught our daily limit so we wouldn't go home with any less. He and the first mate were great to fish with and talk to. Would recommend his service to others interested in the experience.

    Response from Captain

    I'm glad you enjoyed your trip! It was a pleasure getting to fish with you guys and enjoy your filets.

  • Ben Morrow
    Ben Morrow
    us
    Pennsylvania, US
    Member since 2026
    5.0
    Verified

    Great Trip

    Half Day Trip – Walleye (AM) • 3 adults

    Captain and crew were fantastic, caught our limit in walleye, fish on every few minutes!

Real catches shared by our community

  • Old Timer Charters – Lake Erie
    Old Timer Charters – Lake ErieFairview, PA
    Awesome choice!
    Daniel S.
    Daniel S.
  • Old Timer Charters – Lake Erie
    Old Timer Charters – Lake ErieFairview, PA
    great trip.
    Dean T.
    Dean T.
  • Old Timer Charters – Lake Erie
    Old Timer Charters – Lake ErieFairview, PA
    Bait and Switch
    Calvin M.
    Calvin M.
  • Old Timer Charters – Lake Erie
    Old Timer Charters – Lake ErieFairview, PA
    Good trip
    Ben P.
    Ben P.
  • Old Timer Charters – Lake Erie
    Old Timer Charters – Lake ErieFairview, PA
    A skilled team aboard a well-sized vessel.
    Susan B.
    Susan B.
  • Old Timer Charters – Lake Erie
    Old Timer Charters – Lake ErieFairview, PA
    July fishing trip
    Casey T.
    Casey T.
  • Old Timer Charters – Lake Erie
    Old Timer Charters – Lake ErieFairview, PA
    Master class in guiding
    Doug C.
    Doug C.
  • Old Timer Charters – Lake Erie
    Old Timer Charters – Lake ErieFairview, PA
    Great trip!
    Felicia H.
    Felicia H.
  • Old Timer Charters – Lake Erie
    Old Timer Charters – Lake ErieFairview, PA
    August fishing trip
    Eric S.
    Eric S.
  • Old Timer Charters – Lake Erie
    Old Timer Charters – Lake ErieFairview, PA
    Great trip high class fishing
    James T.
    James T.

What's biting with Old Timer Charters – Lake Erie in Fairview

Top catches for October

Fishing reports

Two anglers engaged in fishing on a calm sea, showcasing the excitement of reeling in a catch.

Did someone say fish fry?

Jun 28, 2025 • Fairview
The walleye are biting as fast as we can get the lines in the water!! Book your trips while the bite is still on fire!
Show more
Group of anglers actively fishing from a boat, with rods bent and anticipation in the air, enjoying a day on the water.

Double trips today and coolers full of f

Jun 8, 2025 • Fairview
48 more eyes made their way to the ice box on this sunny calm day.
Show more
Young angler proudly displaying a large fish on a fishing boat, with a foggy backdrop, showcasing a fun family fishing experience.

6/6 walleye

Jun 6, 2025 • Fairview
30 eyes hit the coffin today. Despite the rain and wind we still managed to put a nice box of fish together
Show more
Group of anglers proudly displaying their catch of several trout while aboard a fishing boat in open waters.

King Me!

May 18, 2025 • Fairview
Once again Lake Ontario didn't disappoint. Lots of smiles and laughs as fish hit the deck.
Show more
An angler proudly displaying a large Lake Trout while fishing on a boat in open water.

Cloudy and rain made for a great day on

Apr 25, 2025 • Fairview
Our half day trip turned out to be a great one with lots of Lake trout hitting the deck and smiles everywhere!
Show more
An angler proudly displaying a striped bass while fishing on a boat, showcasing a successful day on the water.

Silver and Gold!!!

Sep 30, 2023 • Fairview
Steady action with walleye and steelhead during our 4hrs trip!
Show more