Jonathan Gelman
Captain

Jonathan Gelman

Marco Island, United States
100+ reviews
Angler's choice
Captain Jonathan has been fishing since he was big enough to hold a rod and has been exploring the waters around Marco Island for over 25 years. The captain has worked in the restaurant industry since he was 12 years old and has just recently made his passion a career, making his dream come true. He enjoys taking all anglers but has a real passion for teaching the basics to new anglers and getting a kid on its first fish. Captain Jonathan feels honored to get to be part of a special moment between family and friends.

Charter

Rating

4.9
243 reviews
4.9
Boat & Equipment
5.0
Captain & Crew
4.9
Fishing Experience

What anglers say

98%
Good experience
100%
Friendly captain
99%
Recommend this charter
100%
Appropriate for children
100%
Satisfied with the boat
99%
Caught fish

Reviews (243)

  • Chris Correira
    Chris Correira
    us
    Florida, US
    Member since 2026
    5.0
    Verified

    Stop looking! This is the charter you want.

    Family Fun Fishing 4hr on July 13, 2026 • 3 adults

    Yesterday (July 13) was our 2nd time using Captain Johnathan and Red Snarpon for a 4-hour shark fishing charter, and once again he did not disappoint. He's extremely accommodating, friendly, professional, and the bottom line is simple: he delivers. Yesterday we caught 4 sharks total: 3 bulls and a nurse. Plus, we hooked a tarpon using catfish for bait believe it or not! It jumped twice but then spit out the hook. We also hooked some lady fish, snapper, and catfish. Last year we caught 3 bulls and a small lemon. He can make moody teenagers smile, and as a parent, that says a lot to me. 😁 I highly recommend Captain Johnathan and Red Snarpon Charters!

  • Joe Foust
    Joe Foust
    us
    Ohio, US
    Member since 2026
    5.0
    Verified

    Fantastic day on the water

    3/4 Day Trip on March 31, 2026 • 4 adults • 1 child

    This was my second 3/4 day trip in 6 months with Jonathan of Red Snarpon Charters. The first was back in November for a guys trip with my 14-year old son, brother-in-law and father-in-law and just this week with my wife, son, and 11-year old daughter. Both trips were fantastic. Jonathan is a very easygoing captain, very hands on for baiting and releasing (for those that want that), and very knowledgeable of the area, the fish, and the wildlife. Both times we caught sharks (6 foot bull the first trip and two 5 ft black tips on the second trip). On both trips we caught a variety of cool fish including flounder, red snapper, redfish, trout, pompano, jack, stingray, and of course countless catfish and ladyfish. On this second trip, Jonathan was very attentive to my 11 year old daughter who has some emotional regulation challenges. She was upset that she wasn’t having a ton of luck in the first 30 minutes so he hooked her a fish which she was able to real in. Can’t say enough nice things about Jonathan and his easygoing but attentive manner. 100% would recommend Jonathan and Red Snarpon Charters for a guys trip or family outing!

  • James Waters
    James Waters
    us
    Massachusetts, US
    Member since 2025
    4.7
    Verified

    Fantastic!

    Half Day Trip Morning on December 4, 2025 • 1 adult

    I had an absolutely fantastic time on this fishing trip—easily one of the most enjoyable experiences I’ve had in a long while. From the moment we pushed off, the captain set the tone: welcoming, knowledgeable, and genuinely invested in making sure I had a great day on the water. The boat was comfortable and well-equipped, and the pacing of the entire trip felt effortless—never rushed, never slow, just the right rhythm for a perfect day. What made it truly special was how fun and hands-on everything felt. Whether it was learning small tips that instantly improved my cast or getting that burst of excitement when a line went tight, every moment had its own little spark. We pulled in a mix of fish throughout the day, and even when the action slowed, the scenery alone made it worth it. There’s something about being out on open water that resets you—and this trip delivered that feeling in the best way. By the time we headed back, I was already thinking about when I could do it again. If you’re looking for a trip that balances relaxation, fun, and just enough adventure, this is the one. Highly recommend

  • Bill Johnston
    Bill Johnston
    Repeat angler
    us
    Minnesota, US
    Member since 2026
    2 trips
    5.0
    Verified

    Fantastic

    Half day Afternoon on January 4, 2026 • 4 adults • 2 children

    Jonathan got us hooked up on all the inshore species we were targeting. My young anglers had a fantastic time setting personal bests on redfish and snook throughout the afternoon. The captain is great with kids and flexible with launch times to ensure we were on the water during the most opportune bite window. We will definitely book our annual family charter with him again and are already considering a more advanced sport-fishing day this spring!

  • Jason Januszewski
    Jason Januszewski
    us
    Ohio, US
    Member since 2026
    4.3
    Verified

    Great Day on the Water

    3/4 Day Trip on July 14, 2026 • 4 adults

    My wife, two teenage daughters and I had a great time with Captain Jonathan. He was very accommodating and personable. We caught a ton of species including shark, ladyfish, trout and even hooked into a tarpon. While the boat doesn’t have a head we were never more than 10 minutes from the dock if someone had to go. I’d definitely recommend this charter and the 3/4 trip was the perfect amount if time!

  • Abe D'amato
    Abe D'amato
    us
    Connecticut, US
    Member since 2024
    5.0
    Verified

    Perfect day

    Family Fun Fishing 4hr on April 14, 2026 • 2 adults • 1 child

    My son and I were lucky enough to book with Captain Jonathan. It was my son‘s first time fishing in the ocean. We caught at least seven species. Saw multiple different areas and had a wonderful time. Captain Jonathan was able to work with my seven-year-old teaching him good technique and getting him on to fish. Cannot recommend highly enough.

  • Chris Wylie
    Chris Wylie
    us
    North Carolina, US
    Member since 2026
    5.0
    Verified

    Great trip and captain!

    Half day Afternoon on August 13, 2026 • 2 adults

    I highly recommend Jonathan. I would book with him again. He's very knowledgeable and accommodating. We caught the red drum that I wanted.

  • Megan Tress
    Megan Tress
    us
    Maryland, US
    Member since 2026
    5.0
    Verified

    Best fishing trip ever!

    Family Fun Fish, Shell, Dolphin - 7:30 AM on April 18, 2026 • 2 adults • 1 child

    We had such an exciting day! We caught lots of different fish and on our last stop we caught a Bull Shark!!! It made my 12 year old Grandson's day. Captain Jonathan was great! We are already looking forward to our next trip with Red Snarpon Charters! Thank you Captain Jonathan!

  • Jack  Porter
    Jack Porter
    Repeat angler
    us
    Michigan, US
    Member since 2020
    6 trips
    4.7
    Verified

    Marco Island-Goodland fishing

    Half Day Trip Morning on March 23, 2026 • 4 adults

    Captain Jonathan was great! He worked hard to put us on fish and we did eventually boated a couple nice Trout which we kept. We did catch several other fish... snapper, ladyfish & one smaller flounder. His boat is very nice with great equipment. He did pick us up at the dock with a load of bait & ready to go fishing. We recommend his boat/charter and will use him again.

  • Michael Bostick
    Michael Bostick
    Repeat angler
    us
    South Carolina, US
    Member since 2026
    3 trips
    5.0
    Verified

    great day on the water with Cptn. Johnathan

    Half day Afternoon on October 6, 2026 • 2 adults

    caught some monster reds, highly recommend to!

Real catches shared by our community

  • Adult angler proudly holding a large redfish on the bow of a center-console boat in calm coastal waters.
    Fish 1
    Redfish
    Michael B.
    Michael B.
    caught some monster reds, highly recommend to!
  • Angler proudly displaying a large Redfish while fishing from a boat in a scenic waterway.
    Fish 1
    Redfish
    Chris W.
    Chris W.
    I highly recommend Jonathan. I would book with him again. He's very knowledgeable and accommodating. We caught the red drum that I wanted.
  • A young angler proudly holding a small shark while fishing on a sunny day.
    Fish 1
    Blacktip Shark
    Jason J.
    Jason J.
    My wife, two teenage daughters and I had a great time with Captain Jonathan. He was very accommodating and personable. We caught a ton of species including shark, ladyfish, trout and even hooked into a tarpon. While the boat doesn’t have a head we were never more than 10 minutes from the dock if someone had to go. I’d definitely recommend this charter and the 3/4 trip was the perfect amount if time!
  • A young angler and a guide are reeling in a shark while fishing on a boat in coastal waters, showcasing an exciting catch.
    Fish 1
    Fish 2
    +1
    Bull Shark
    Chris C.
    Chris C.
    Yesterday (July 13) was our 2nd time using Captain Johnathan and Red Snarpon for a 4-hour shark fishing charter, and once again he did not disappoint. He's extremely accommodating, friendly, professional, and the bottom line is simple: he delivers. Yesterday we caught 4 sharks total: 3 bulls and a nurse. Plus, we hooked a tarpon using catfish for bait believe it or not! It jumped twice but then spit out the hook. We also hooked some lady fish, snapper, and catfish. Last year we caught 3 bulls and a small lemon. He can make moody teenagers smile, and as a parent, that says a lot to me. 😁 I highly recommend Captain Johnathan and Red Snarpon Charters!
  • Angler proudly displaying a large Snook while fishing from a boat in a coastal waterway.
    Fish 1
    Jack Crevalle
    Mike Y.
    Mike Y.
  • A young angler proudly holding two fish on a boat, showcasing a successful fishing trip in a coastal setting.
    Megan T.
    Megan T.
    We had such an exciting day! We caught lots of different fish and on our last stop we caught a Bull Shark!!! It made my 12 year old Grandson's day. Captain Jonathan was great! We are already looking forward to our next trip with Red Snarpon Charters! Thank you Captain Jonathan!
  • A young angler proudly displaying a caught fish while standing on a boat in a sunny fishing environment.
    Fish 1
    Jack Crevalle
    Abe D.
    Abe D.
    My son and I were lucky enough to book with Captain Jonathan. It was my son‘s first time fishing in the ocean. We caught at least seven species. Saw multiple different areas and had a wonderful time. Captain Jonathan was able to work with my seven-year-old teaching him good technique and getting him on to fish. Cannot recommend highly enough.
  • Two young anglers proudly posing with a large shark on a cleaning table at a fishing dock.
    Fish 1
    Fish 2
    +1
    Bull Shark
    Dan K.
    Dan K.
    Awesome trip! Captain Jonathan was great with our boys ages 7 and 8. Memories they will not forget!
  • A large shark displayed on the side of a boat, showcasing a successful catch during a fishing trip.
    Fish 1
    Fish 2
    Hammerhead Shark
    Joe F.
    Joe F.
    This was my second 3/4 day trip in 6 months with Jonathan of Red Snarpon Charters. The first was back in November for a guys trip with my 14-year old son, brother-in-law and father-in-law and just this week with my wife, son, and 11-year old daughter. Both trips were fantastic. Jonathan is a very easygoing captain, very hands on for baiting and releasing (for those that want that), and very knowledgeable of the area, the fish, and the wildlife. Both times we caught sharks (6 foot bull the first trip and two 5 ft black tips on the second trip). On both trips we caught a variety of cool fish including flounder, red snapper, redfish, trout, pompano, jack, stingray, and of course countless catfish and ladyfish. On this second trip, Jonathan was very attentive to my 11 year old daughter who has some emotional regulation challenges. She was upset that she wasn’t having a ton of luck in the first 30 minutes so he hooked her a fish which she was able to real in. Can’t say enough nice things about Jonathan and his easygoing but attentive manner. 100% would recommend Jonathan and Red Snarpon Charters for a guys trip or family outing!
  • A couple enjoying a thrilling moment on the boat, posing with a caught shark during their fishing adventure.
    Fish 1
    Blacktip Shark
    Kim C.
    Kim C.
    Jonathon was a fantastic captain. We are family of 4 and each caught a shark and lots of other fish too! Such a memorable experience

What's biting with Red Snarpon Charters Inc. in Marco Island

The start of November may be your last chance to board a deep sea fishing charters for the year. Head offshore and catch large bottom fish or troll for a prize worth bragging about. The backwaters are promising, as always.

Top catches for November