Search
Jay Prescott
Captain

Jay Prescott

Hilton Head Island, United States
Federal waters
Angler's choice
250+ reviews
Captain Jay Prescott has been a Hilton Head Island resident for over 30 years and is the owner and operator of Top Shot Sport Fishing. You will find that Captain Jay is a real people's person who loves kids and taking them fishing. He is a knowledgeable man and is an expert in his field who makes sure all his guest have a good time.

Charter

Rating

4.8
407 reviews
4.7
Boat & Equipment
4.9
Captain & Crew
4.8
Fishing Experience

What anglers say

96%
Good experience
100%
Friendly captain
98%
Recommend this charter
97%
Appropriate for children
98%
Satisfied with the boat
88%
Caught fish

All reviews (407)

Showing 1 – 5 of 407 reviews
  • Michelle Austin
    Michelle Austin
    us
    Tennessee, US
    Member since 2026
    5.0
    Verified

    Fun and Relaxing!

    5 Hour Trip (1 PM) • 6 adults • 3 children

    Captain Jay and Lucas make a great team! Our group included me, and three young teens. My kids and I had been out before, but my daughter's friend had never been on a boat. We told Captain Jay we were up for anything and had them take us where they thought we'd have the most fun. They made our trip relaxing, easy, and fun! Everything we needed was ready to go, the boat was comfortable, and we started catching almost immediately. With Lucas's help, my son was able to reel in a massive drum fish (45lbs maybe). My son has an exciting story to tell and a memory to last a lifetime. My daughter kept reeling in small sea bass; we lost count after 20. I would highly recommend going out with Captain Jay if you are looking for an enjoyable experience. When we are back in Hilton Head, we will definitely be booking again!

    Reported catch:
    Black Seabass
    King Mackerel (Kingfish)
    Response from Captain

    Thanks again Michelle! That sure was a massive drum!!

  • Sakkapol Ongwijitwat
    Sakkapol Ongwijitwat
    us
    California, US
    Member since 2026
    4.0
    Verified
    NEW

    Nice and knowledgeable captain, didn't catch a lot of fish

    Half Day Trip • 4 adults

    Captain Jay and his deck hand were friendly and helpful. We had kids who are not experienced with fishing and they had a good time on the boat. Saw a lot of dolphins on the way. We end up catching a lot of sharks, but no sizable fish that we could keep. But that is just luck of the draw. I can't help but notice that the boat needed a bit of maintenance including I new, unbroken seat and maybe a working toilet. I would try my luck again with Captain Jay. Hopefully we get more fish next time we come back.

    Reported catch:
    Blacktip Shark
  • Marnie Ochs
    Marnie Ochs
    Repeat angler
    us
    Pennsylvania, US
    Member since 2022
    4 trips
    5.0
    Verified

    Great day on the water!

    Half Day Trip • 5 adults

    Captain Jay and Lucas were tried very hard to get us on some fish. Although the fish were playing hard to get, we had great conversation and learned a lot about Hilton Head Island. The dolphins that followed the boat the whole way home definitely made it worth the trip! If we ever make it back to Hilton Head, we will be calling Captain Jay for a charter.

    Reported catch:
    King Mackerel (Kingfish)
    Response from Captain

    Thanks again Marnie! It was a tough day. The dolphins definitely helped out!

  • Leigh Anne Clark
    Leigh Anne Clark
    us
    Tennessee, US
    Member since 2026
    5.0
    Verified

    Surprise birthday/Father’s Day gift

    Half Day Trip • 3 adults

    The fishing trip was a wonderful surprise! We were able to catch some pretty cool fish and enjoy some time on the ocean. Captain Jay was an excellent captain and all-around great guy. His first mate was super helpful and knowledgeable as well. We had a wonderful day and hope to do it again!

    Reported catch:
    Blacktip Shark
    Response from Captain

    We sure did enjoy the day Leigh Ann! Enjoy the weekend!

  • George Jewell
    George Jewell
    Repeat angler
    us
    Indiana, US
    Member since 2021
    2 trips
    5.0
    Verified

    11th Birthday Trip

    Half Day Trip • 4 adults • 1 child

    Wonderful half day trip!!! Celebrated (belatedly) our sons 11th birthday with Jay and Brad. We had a great time even if the fish only minimally cooperated. Landed some Whitting, Croakers and a Bonnethead. Overall, great time and highly recommend Jay and Brad.

    Reported catch:
    King Mackerel (Kingfish)
    Response from Captain

    Thanks again Jay and Kim! enjoyed the morning with you and the boys!

Real catches shared by our community

  • Top Shot Sport Fishing Hilton Head
    Top Shot Sport Fishing Hilton HeadHilton Head Island, SC
    Angler reeling in a small shark beside a boat over coastal waters.
    Fish 1
    Fish 2
    Atlantic Sharpnose Shark
    Barbara S.
    Barbara S.
    great crew! Jay and Brad were great!
  • Top Shot Sport Fishing Hilton Head
    Top Shot Sport Fishing Hilton HeadHilton Head Island, SC
    Young angler proudly holding a small shark aboard a fishing boat on open water.
    Fish 1
    Bonnethead Shark
    George J.
    George J.
    Wonderful half day trip!!! Celebrated (belatedly) our sons 11th birthday with Jay and Brad. We had a great time even if the fish only minimally cooperated. Landed some Whitting, Croakers and a Bonnethead. Overall, great time and highly recommend Jay and Brad.
  • Top Shot Sport Fishing Hilton Head
    Top Shot Sport Fishing Hilton HeadHilton Head Island, SC
    Angler proudly displaying a caught shark while fishing on a boat in calm waters.
    Fish 1
    Fish 2
    Blacktip Shark
    Michael D.
    Michael D.
    Captain Jay and his mate Lucas were very friendly and accommodating to whatever we wanted to do. From trollling for Spanish Mackerel to bottom fishing for sharks, the half day tour gave a nice variety of experiences with a nice end of having our haul freshly fileted for us to enjoy later. Highly recommend this for anyone else looking for a fun/laid back experience.
  • Top Shot Sport Fishing Hilton Head
    Top Shot Sport Fishing Hilton HeadHilton Head Island, SC
    A young boy proudly holds a small shark with the help of an adult on a fishing boat, showcasing a memorable fishing experience.
    Fish 1
    Fish 2
    +1
    Bonnethead Shark
    Megan S.
    Megan S.
    We went out on an evening shark fishing trip with Capt Jay and Brad. The boat ride is majority of the time of the 3 hours but we did catch several sharks and my kids were able to hold them. You don’t cast the lines or do any bait ect. Very cool experience!
  • Top Shot Sport Fishing Hilton Head
    Top Shot Sport Fishing Hilton HeadHilton Head Island, SC
    A variety of fish including Spanish Mackerel and other species neatly laid out on the deck of a fishing boat, showcasing a successful catch.
    Fish 1
    Fish 2
    Spanish Mackerel
    Luke S.
    Luke S.
    Our only goal for the trip was to catch something that would make a tasty lunch and we were able to do that and so much more! Captain Jay and Lucas were both very friendly, helpful, and knowledgeable of the area. The boat was nice with lots of shade and places to sit.
  • Top Shot Sport Fishing Hilton Head
    Top Shot Sport Fishing Hilton HeadHilton Head Island, SC
    Angler proudly displaying a large shark caught while fishing on a boat in open waters.
    Fish 1
    Fish 2
    Hammerhead Shark
    Charles B.
    Charles B.
    Caught quite a few bluefish and ladyfish. Went out a bi furtherand reeled in 3 sharks, including a Hammerhead weighing 70ish lbs. Captain Jay an Lucas were great guidingus in fishing and fun to chat with. Would recommend ths trip for all ages.
  • Top Shot Sport Fishing Hilton Head
    Top Shot Sport Fishing Hilton HeadHilton Head Island, SC
    A woman proudly displaying a large shark caught during a fishing trip, with a scenic backdrop of water and sky.
    Fish 1
    Fish 2
    Blacktip Shark
    Amy W.
    Amy W.
    crew was great. we caught 3 sharks. also had visits from Nick the dolphin - we had never seen one so close and so friendly. all of thay together made for the best fishing trip weve had in HH.
  • Top Shot Sport Fishing Hilton Head
    Top Shot Sport Fishing Hilton HeadHilton Head Island, SC
    A young angler proudly holding a large fish while aboard a boat, showcasing a successful fishing trip.
    Fish 1
    King Mackerel (Kingfish)
    Frances M.
    Frances M.
    captain Jay and Lucas were awesome. caught lots of Spanish mackeral and a King Mackerel of 30 lbs!!!!
  • Top Shot Sport Fishing Hilton Head
    Top Shot Sport Fishing Hilton HeadHilton Head Island, SC
    A variety of fish, including Spanish Mackerel and other species, neatly laid out on the deck of a fishing boat, showcasing a successful catch.
    Fish 1
    Spanish Mackerel
    Shaun C.
    Shaun C.
    We had a lot of fun and limited out on Blue fish and about 7 spanish mackerel. we didnt get the King but i know we did everything we could to be in position to catch one. Next time.
  • Top Shot Sport Fishing Hilton Head
    Top Shot Sport Fishing Hilton HeadHilton Head Island, SC
    Two young anglers proudly displaying a caught shark while fishing on a boat in calm waters.
    Fish 1
    Fish 2
    Blacktip Shark
    Leigh A.
    Leigh A.
    The fishing trip was a wonderful surprise! We were able to catch some pretty cool fish and enjoy some time on the ocean. Captain Jay was an excellent captain and all-around great guy. His first mate was super helpful and knowledgeable as well. We had a wonderful day and hope to do it again!

What's biting with Top Shot Sport Fishing Hilton Head in Hilton Head Island

This is the best time to catch some eating fish! In the sound and on the wrecks you can target Bull Redfish, or stay closer to shore and fish for Speckled Trout, Flounder, and Shrimp.

Top catches for November