Mayhem Sportfishing & Lobstering
Mayhem Sportfishing & Lobstering
Looking for an unforgettable fishing adventure in the Florida Keys? Mayhem Sportfishing delivers high-energy, hands-on trips designed for anglers who want action, variety, and serious local knowledge. With trips available year-round, you'll be fishing right in the heart of the Keys when it works for you.
Most trips are run by Capt. Brad, but depending on scheduling and conditions, your adventure may be led by Capt. Janis, an experienced USCG-licensed captain who runs trips aboard Dauntless, a well-equipped 32' Pro-Line Express. Same great fishing, same local expertise—just another excellent boat and captain dedicated to giving you an outstanding day on the water.
You may fish aboard the Mayhem, a 30' SuperSport Pro-Line center console with twin 250 HP Mercury engines, or the Dauntless, a spacious walk-around vessel offering extra comfort, shade, and a cabin with a marine head—ideal for longer trips and mixed groups. Both boats are outfitted with quality electronics, live bait wells, and everything needed for a successful day offshore or nearshore.
Stay closer to shore targeting Yellowtail and Mutton Snapper, Grouper, Spanish Mackerel, and sharks, or try your hand at lobster snorkeling. Head offshore to chase fan favorites like Mahi Mahi, Wahoo, Amberjack, Cobia, King Mackerel, Tuna, and—on the right day—trophy Sailfish.
Your captain will have top-quality reels on custom rods, bait, tackle, and fishing licenses ready for your group. Just bring food, drinks, and sunscreen—everything else is handled.
Whether you're chasing dinner, a bucket-list catch, or just a killer day on the water, Mayhem Sportfishing is ready to deliver.
Come fish with us—and catch a memory.
Looking for an unforgettable fishing adventure in the Florida Keys? Mayhem Sportfishing delivers high-energy, hands-on trips designed for anglers who want action, variety, and serious local knowledge. With trips available year-round, you'll be fishing right in the heart of the Keys when it works for you.
Most trips are run by Capt. Brad, but depending on scheduling and conditions, your adventure may be led by Capt. Janis, an experienced USCG-licensed captain who runs trips aboard Dauntless, a well-equipped 32' Pro-Line Express. Same great fishing, same local expertise—just another excellent boat and captain dedicated to giving you an outstanding day on the water.
You may fish aboard the Mayhem, a 30' SuperSport Pro-Line center console with twin 250 HP Mercury engines, or the Dauntless, a spacious walk-around vessel offering extra comfort, shade, and a cabin with a marine head—ideal for longer trips and mixed groups. Both boats are outfitted with quality electronics, live bait wells, and everything needed for a successful day offshore or nearshore.
Stay closer to shore targeting Yellowtail and Mutton Snapper, Grouper, Spanish Mackerel, and sharks, or try your hand at lobster snorkeling. Head offshore to chase fan favorites like Mahi Mahi, Wahoo, Amberjack, Cobia, King Mackerel, Tuna, and—on the right day—trophy Sailfish.
Your captain will have top-quality reels on custom rods, bait, tackle, and fishing licenses ready for your group. Just bring food, drinks, and sunscreen—everything else is handled.
Whether you're chasing dinner, a bucket-list catch, or just a killer day on the water, Mayhem Sportfishing is ready to deliver.
Come fish with us—and catch a memory.
Select date to see availability
Trip availability and prices
| Su | Mo | Tu | We | Th | Fr | Sa | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Customer reviews
Rating
Anglers' gallery (10)
Reviews (27)
Nicholas Hughes•
Louisiana, USMember since 20255.0VerifiedTurn of Events
4 Hour – Lobster Snorkeling on October 17, 2025 • 6 adultsWe booked our trip but the night before our captain called us to let us know that he had some issues with the boat (if you habe ever owned a boat you understand) but was able to line us up with one of his friends so we were still able to go on our trip. to me this speaks volumes about this captain he could have very well just refunded me the money for the trip and said he was sorry but he went above and beyond to make sure we got on a boat and snagged some lobsters. I will definitely reach out for our next trip.
Dennis StarrettRepeat angler•Indiana, US•Member since 20262 trips5.0VerifiedThis Trip was amazing!
8 Hour Trip – Reef & Offshore on July 19, 2026 • 2 adultsWe caught alot of fish! I recommend the reef fishing for sure. My buddy hooked a fish that was pulling him overboard and almost lost his rod and reel. I hooked a fish on light tackle rod that I couldn't turn. I have a gopro video of mine of over 10 minutes until it finally broke the line. Captain and mate Janice was totally amazing!
Jack NenstielRepeat angler•Alabama, US•Member since 20232 trips5.0VerifiedHalf day morning trip
4 Hour – Lobster Snorkeling on August 13, 2023 • 6 adultsWe had an awesome trip, had to book last minute due to another captain elsewhere ghosting us. Brad and Janice were very responsive and made sure we had a great time. Will absolutely be back.
Troy TolliverRepeat angler•Indiana, US•Member since 20215 trips5.0VerifiedLobster diving
4 Hour – Lobster Snorkeling on October 7, 2023 • 4 adultsThe captain and the dog seaba were very knowledgeable and knew their stuff. We were able to catch lobster right away.
Cheryl WhitsonRepeat angler•Georgia, US•Member since 20213 trips5.0VerifiedHalf day trip
4 Hour Trip – Reef & Wreck (PM) on April 2, 2023 • 3 adultsAwesome experience! You guys saved the day when our other charter fell through. Thank you so much!
Tom McmahenMember since 20215.0Full day with Captain Brad
4 Hour Trip – Reef & Wreck (PM) on January 31, 2021Good trip highly recommended
Paul PrillamanRepeat angler•Virginia, US•Member since 20233 trips5.0VerifiedJanuary fishing trip
Reef & Wreck Fishing 4HRS on January 3, 2026 • 4 adults • 2 children
Mark BurnettRepeat angler•Kentucky, US•Member since 20233 trips5.0VerifiedDecember fishing trip
6 Hour Trip – Reef & Offshore on December 29, 2025 • 3 adults • 2 children
Kristine Muncaster•Arizona, USMember since 20255.0VerifiedSuccessful lobstering trip!
Lobster Mini Season - 11:30 AM on July 31, 2025 • 2 adultsWe had a great time lobstering with Captain Brad! My husband an I were taken to three different spots to snorkel for lobster and caught several. Captain Brad was knowledgeable, personable and told us what to look for and how to use the tickle sticks and nets. The boat was a smooth ride and very comfortable. He had a rear canopy which was a life save (I'm a ginger). Meeting location was easy to get to and he was very communicative throughout the whole booking (I'm bad with directions so this really helped). We will defiantly book again! Thanks Captain Brad!!
John StrangeRepeat angler•New Mexico, US•Member since 20223 trips5.0VerifiedGreat time was had by all!!!!!
4 Hour Trip–Fishing & Sandbar (AM) on June 9, 2025 • 4 adults • 2 childrenWe had so much fun on a great boat with a very responsive captain who helped us catch fish!!!! Enjoyed some great snorkeling as well. Would highly recommend, especially for groups with children, Captain Janis was great with them and helped us check many boxes in one trip!!!!!
Rating
Anglers' gallery (10)
All reviews (27)
We booked our trip but the night before our captain called us to let us know that he had some issues with the boat (if you habe ever owned a boat you understand) but was able to line us up with one of his friends so we were still able to go on our trip. to me this speaks volumes about this captain he could have very well just refunded me the money for the trip and said he was sorry but he went above and beyond to make sure we got on a boat and snagged some lobsters. I will definitely reach out for our next trip.
We caught alot of fish! I recommend the reef fishing for sure. My buddy hooked a fish that was pulling him overboard and almost lost his rod and reel. I hooked a fish on light tackle rod that I couldn't turn. I have a gopro video of mine of over 10 minutes until it finally broke the line. Captain and mate Janice was totally amazing!
Loved having you! Thank you!
We had a great time lobstering with Captain Brad! My husband an I were taken to three different spots to snorkel for lobster and caught several. Captain Brad was knowledgeable, personable and told us what to look for and how to use the tickle sticks and nets. The boat was a smooth ride and very comfortable. He had a rear canopy which was a life save (I'm a ginger). Meeting location was easy to get to and he was very communicative throughout the whole booking (I'm bad with directions so this really helped). We will defiantly book again! Thanks Captain Brad!!
FAQs about Mayhem Sportfishing & Lobstering
- US $500 per group - 2 Hour Trip – Light Tackle Fishing (2 hours)
- US $850 per group - 4 Hour Trip–Fishing & Sandbar (AM) (4 hours)
- US $850 per group - 4 Hour Trip–Fishing & Sandbar (PM) (4 hours)
- US $925 per group - 4 Hour – Lobster Snorkeling (4 hours)
- US $925 per group - 4 Hour – Lobster Snorkeling - 1:00 PM (4 hours)
- US $925 per group - 4 Hour – Lobster Snorkeling 1:30 pm (4 hours)
- US $925 per group - 4 Hour – Lobster Snorkeling 1:30 pm - 1:00 PM (4 hours)
- US $975 per group - Reef & Wreck Fishing 4HRS (4 hours)
- US $975 per group - Reef & Wreck Fishing 4HRS - 1:00 PM (4 hours)
- US $1,200 per group - Lobster Mini Season (4PM) (4 hours)
- US $1,200 per group - Lobster Mini Season 11:30AM (4 hours)
- US $1,200 per group - Lobster Mini Season 11:30AM - 3:30 PM (4 hours)
- US $1,200 per group - Lobster Mini Season 7:AM (4 hours)
- US $1,200 per group - Lobster Mini Season 7:AM - 11:00 AM (4 hours)
- US $1,250 per group - 6 Hour Trip – Reef & Offshore (6 hours)
- US $1,250 per group - Reef & Wreck Fishing 6HRS (6 hours)
- US $1,250 per group - Reef & Wreck Fishing 6HRS - 1:00 PM (6 hours)
- US $1,500 per group - 8 Hour Trip – Reef & Offshore (8 hours)
- US $1,500 per group - Reef & Wreck Fishing 8HRS (8 hours)
- US $2,000 per group - 12 Hour Trip – Offshore (12 hours)
- US $2,300 per group - Deep drop Fishing (12 hours)
- Toilet Enclosed bathroom.
- GPS
- Fishfinder
- Snorkeling equipment
- Live bait well
- Outriggers
- Ice box
- Radar
- Rods, reels & tackle
- Live bait (Seasonal & depending on type of fishing. )
- Lures
- Catch cleaning & filleting (Included in trip price. )
- Drinks (Water is included )
- First mate (When needed)
- Fishing license (Included in trip price )
- Lunch (On request. )
- Nearshore fishing
- Offshore fishing (Up to 50 miles. )
- Reef fishing
- Wreck fishing
- Light tackle
- Heavy tackle
- Bottom fishing
- Trolling
- Spinning
- Jigging
- Drift fishing
- Kite fishing
- Deep sea fishing
- Amberjack
- Barracuda (Great)
- Dolphin (Mahi Mahi)
- King Mackerel (Kingfish)
- Lobster
- Sailfish
- Snapper (Yellowtail)
- Tilefish
- Tripletail
- Tuna (Blackfin)
- Wahoo
Your captain
Stock Island, Florida, United States
I have a passion for fishing and the outdoors. It all started as a hobby from a very young age and turned into something more. I decided to follow this dream and share it with other people.
Brad R.
Captain
Janis N.
Captain
Real catches by this captain
What is the boat like?
What kind of fishing will you do?
Which fishing techniques you can try
Which amenities are available onboard
How cancellations work
You can cancel or modify your booking up to 7 days before the trip date, free of charge. If you cancel or modify your booking later, or fail to show up, you'll forfeit 100% of what you've paid.
What the listing policies are
Pickup not included
Transfer to/from departure site is not included in trip rates.
How you can pay
Pay online in full through FishingBooker and save on credit card fees at the dock.
No additional fees.
What’s biting in Stock Island right now
Amberjack
Barracuda (Great)
Dolphin (Mahi Mahi)
King Mackerel (Kingfish)
Sailfish
Snapper (Yellowtail)
Tripletail
Tuna (Blackfin)
WahooCompare similar fishing charters
Federally permitted4.9(84)32 ftGroup size 1 - 41 - 4
+104 hour trip • 4 personsUS $895
Federally permitted5.0(33)32 ftGroup size 1 - 61 - 64 hour trip • 6 personsUS $895
