My Mate Charters 

4.8/5 (5 reviews)
 32 Star Island Road, Montauk, NY 11954, United States

My Mate Charters 

4.8/5 (5 reviews)
map-thumbnail
32 Star Island Road
Montauk, NY, United States

Capt. Pete Casale owns and operates My Mate Charters out of Montauk New York. The boat is docked at the prestigious Montauk Yacht Club which is now Safe Harbor. A full-service resort that offers first-class accommodations, ample parking, and a variety of amenities for your convenience.

My Mate is a big comfortable 41’ Hatteras Sport Fisherman. Powered by twin Cummins engines, it is both fast and reliable. The boat is fitted with a range of navigational electronics to help the captain put you on fish and to keep you safe. Inside the boat features amenities like a private bathroom with sink, a galley with refrigerator to keep your lunch fresh. Private bed room in case your looking to stretch out for a nap or change into a swim suit. In the main salon there’s a big couch two two comfy chairs and a cooler with ice to keep your drinks cool.

There are a variety of fishing options you can partake in depending on what trip you choose to go on. You could be Tuna trolling offshore or Shark fishing. Inshore light tackle fishing for Striped Bass, Fluke, Sea Bass or Porgy. Whether you’re a beginner or an avid angler, Capt. Pete and his team will do very best to make your Montauk Fishing trip Exciting and Memorable.

The boat’s speed and comfort combined with the professionalism and experience of the captain and mate, make My Mate a very popular vessel in the Hamptons and Greater New York area. These trips are great fun for Family’s, couples, young professionals and avid Anglers alike. So how about capping off your Hampton vacation or a day trip from Manhattan with a memorable fishing trip on My Mate Charters?

Loading
Loading
Loading
Loading
Loading
Loading
Loading
Loading

Customer reviews

Rating summary

4.8/5
out of 5 stars from 5 reviews
Boat
4.8/5
Crew
4.8/5
Experience
4.8/5

Photos & videos by reviewers (7)

FN Awesome!! Pete & Steve the best!!!!!
FN Awesome!! Pete & Steve the best!!!!!
FN Awesome!! Pete & Steve the best!!!!!
+4

Angler rating

3
1
0
0
0

Anglers claimed

Good experience

100%

Appropriate for children

100%

Friendly captain

100%

Satisfied with the boat

100%

Recommend this charter

57%

Caught fish

100%

Showing 1 - 5 of 7 reviews
Showing: 5 of 7 reviews
Ben h.
Ben h.

Aug 26, 2025

The captain canceled

VERIFIED
NEW

The charter operator canceled on trip date. This is an automated posting.

 

Captain replied
undefined (The Captain)

Robert P.
Robert P.

New York, NY

5.0/5

Aug 11, 2023

Half Day Bass inshore Am Trip

Half Day w Capt Pete

VERIFIED

Great morning on the water. Captain Pete and 1st mate Brandon made the trip memorable with plenty of fights!

Great morning on the water. Captain Pete and 1st mate Brandon made the trip memorable with plenty of fights!  

 Robert P. recommends My Mate Charters

Mark review as helpful

1 person finds this review helpful
 Robert P. recommends My Mate Charters

Mark review as helpful

1 person finds this review helpful

Stan P.
Stan P.

East Hampton, New York

5.0/5

Aug 9, 2017

Half Day Bass inshore Am Trip

half day trip with Capt. Pete on My Mate

VERIFIED

Very pleasant, no-pressure day with Capt. Pete and mate, Steve. Competent, professional. All one could ask for. No one can put fish on your line, no matter what they advertise. The time we spent on the water was totally satisfying.

Very pleasant, no-pressure day with Capt. Pete and mate, Steve. Competent, professional. All one could ask for. No one can put...  

Captain replied
 Stan P. recommends My Mate Charters

Mark review as helpful

 Stan P. recommends My Mate Charters

Mark review as helpful

undefined (The Captain)
Replied on August 25, 2017
Awesome Stan was a pleasure having you guys on the boat

Gary W.
Gary W.

New York, New York

5.0/5

Jul 31, 2016

Half Day Inshore PM Trip

FN Awesome!! Pete & Steve the best!!!!!

VERIFIED

Arrived and they we're ready to go fast. Hit the tide and immediately started bagging big striped bass Captain and Mate are experts. Great experience for me and my 3 kiddos 11, 15, 17 All rookies trained to pros. Bottom line: Captain Pete and Mate Steve's expertise ensured we killed it. -Gary.

Arrived and they we're ready to go fast. Hit the tide and immediately started bagging big striped bass Captain and Mate are experts....  

Review media 0
Review media 1
Review media 2
Review media 3
Review media 4
Review media 5
Captain replied
 Gary W. recommends My Mate Charters

Mark review as helpful

 Gary W. recommends My Mate Charters

Mark review as helpful

undefined (The Captain)
Replied on August 1, 2016
Awesome guys thanks for coming. You were a great crew. Capt Pete
Review media 0

Jack S.
Jack S.

Sag Harbor, New York

4.0/5

Aug 9, 2017

Half Day Inshore PM Trip

Fishing with Pete

VERIFIED

capt pete made the decision to go out to block island because the fish weren't biting by the point great move we had fish all day

capt pete made the decision to go out to block island because the fish weren't biting by the point great move we had fish all...  

Captain replied
 Jack S. recommends My Mate Charters

Mark review as helpful

 Jack S. recommends My Mate Charters

Mark review as helpful

undefined (The Captain)
Replied on August 25, 2017
Great trip with jack and crew

Trip availability and prices

Trip Date:
Days:
Group Size:
Select date to see availability
September 2025
SuMoTuWeThFrSa
Loading...
Number of days
1
Group Size
2 adults • 0 children
Change
Almost there...
4 Hour – Children Fishing Tutorial
Low rate deposit non-refundable
4 Hour Trip, starts at 8:00 AM
Seasonal trip May 26 - Sep 30
Loading...
US $800 
Entire boat: up to 6 people
Half Day Bass inshore Am Trip
Low rate deposit non-refundable
5 Hour Trip, starts at 6:00 AM
Seasonal trip May 26 - Oct 31
Loading...
US $900 
Entire boat: up to 6 people
5 Hour Trip – Fluke or Sea Bass
Low rate deposit non-refundable
5 Hour Trip, starts at 7:00 AM
Seasonal trip May 26 - Oct 31
Loading...
US $900 
Entire boat: up to 6 people
Half Day Inshore PM Trip
Low rate deposit non-refundable
5 Hour Trip, starts at 12:00 PM
Seasonal trip May 26 - Oct 15
Loading...
US $900 
Entire boat: up to 6 people
Full Day Inshore
Low rate deposit non-refundable
9 Hour Trip, starts at 6:00 AM
Loading...
US $1,500 
Entire boat: up to 6 people
Block Island Black Seabass trip
Low rate deposit non-refundable
8 Hour Trip, starts at 6:00 AM
Seasonal trip May 26 - Oct 31
Loading...
US $1,550 
Entire boat: up to 6 people
Full Day Trip - Shark Offshore
Low rate deposit non-refundable
10 Hour Trip, starts at 6:00 AM
Seasonal trip May 26 - Oct 31
Loading...
US $1,900 
Entire boat: up to 6 people
Block Island Excursion
Low rate deposit non-refundable
9 Hour Trip, starts at 8:00 AM
Seasonal trip May 26 - Oct 15
Loading...
US $2,000 
Entire boat: up to 6 people
Yellow or Blue Fin Tuna
Low rate deposit non-refundable
10 Hour Trip, starts at 4:00 AM
Seasonal trip May 26 - Oct 31
Loading...
US $2,900 
Entire boat: up to 6 people
extended day Tuna
Low rate deposit non-refundable
15 Hour Trip, starts at 3:00 AM
Seasonal trip May 26 - Oct 31
Loading...
US $4,000 
Entire boat: up to 6 people
There is 1 person looking at this charter.

Customer reviews

Rating summary

4.8/5
out of 5 stars from 5 reviews
Boat
4.8/5
Crew
4.8/5
Experience
4.8/5

Photos & videos by reviewers (7)

FN Awesome!! Pete & Steve the best!!!!!
FN Awesome!! Pete & Steve the best!!!!!
FN Awesome!! Pete & Steve the best!!!!!
+4

Angler rating

3
1
0
0
0

Anglers claimed

Good experience

100%

Appropriate for children

100%

Friendly captain

100%

Satisfied with the boat

100%

Recommend this charter

57%

Caught fish

100%

Showing 1 - 5 of 7 reviews
Showing: 5 of 7 reviews
Ben h.
Ben h.

The captain canceled

VERIFIED
NEW

Trip was supposed to happen on August 26, 2025

The charter operator canceled on trip date. This is an automated posting.

 

undefined (The Captain)

Robert P.
Robert P.

New York, NY

5.0/5

Experience:

5.0/5

Boat

5.0/5

Crew

5.0/5

Overall

Half Day w Capt Pete

VERIFIED

Half Day Bass inshore Am Trip on August 11, 2023

Great morning on the water. Captain Pete and 1st mate Brandon made the trip memorable with plenty of fights!

Great morning on the water. Captain Pete and 1st mate Brandon made the trip memorable with plenty of fights!  

 Robert P. recommends My Mate Charters

Mark review as helpful

1 person finds this review helpful

Stan P.
Stan P.

East Hampton, New York

5.0/5

Experience:

5.0/5

Boat

5.0/5

Crew

5.0/5

Overall

half day trip with Capt. Pete on My Mate

VERIFIED

Half Day Bass inshore Am Trip on August 9, 2017

Very pleasant, no-pressure day with Capt. Pete and mate, Steve. Competent, professional. All one could ask for. No one can put fish on your line, no matter what they advertise. The time we spent on the water was totally satisfying.

Very pleasant, no-pressure day with Capt. Pete and mate, Steve. Competent, professional. All one could ask for. No one can put fish on your line, no matter what they advertise. The time we spent on the water was totally satisfying.  

 Stan P. recommends My Mate Charters

Mark review as helpful

undefined (The Captain)
Replied on August 25, 2017
Awesome Stan was a pleasure having you guys on the boat

Gary W.
Gary W.

New York, New York

5.0/5

Experience:

5.0/5

Boat

5.0/5

Crew

5.0/5

Overall

FN Awesome!! Pete & Steve the best!!!!!

VERIFIED

Half Day Inshore PM Trip on July 31, 2016

Arrived and they we're ready to go fast. Hit the tide and immediately started bagging big striped bass Captain and Mate are experts. Great experience for me and my 3 kiddos 11, 15, 17 All rookies trained to pros. Bottom line: Captain Pete and Mate Steve's expertise ensured we killed it. -Gary.

Arrived and they we're ready to go fast. Hit the tide and immediately started bagging big striped bass Captain and Mate are experts. Great experience for me and my 3 kiddos 11, 15, 17 All rookies trained to pros. Bottom line: Captain Pete and Mate Steve's expertise ensured we killed it. -Gary.  

Review media 0
Review media 1
Review media 2
Review media 3
Review media 4
Review media 5
 Gary W. recommends My Mate Charters

Mark review as helpful

undefined (The Captain)
Replied on August 1, 2016
Awesome guys thanks for coming. You were a great crew. Capt Pete
Review media 0

Jack S.
Jack S.

Sag Harbor, New York

4.0/5

Experience:

4.0/5

Boat

4.0/5

Crew

4.0/5

Overall

Fishing with Pete

VERIFIED

Half Day Inshore PM Trip on August 9, 2017

capt pete made the decision to go out to block island because the fish weren't biting by the point great move we had fish all day

capt pete made the decision to go out to block island because the fish weren't biting by the point great move we had fish all day  

 Jack S. recommends My Mate Charters

Mark review as helpful

undefined (The Captain)
Replied on August 25, 2017
Great trip with jack and crew

FAQs about My Mate Charters

Loading
Loading
Loading
Loading
Loading
Loading
Loading

The fish you can target

Loading
Loading
Loading
Loading
Loading

What is the boat like?

Boat Image
Boat category
Sportfishing boats
Capacity
6 persons
Boat length
41 ft
Year built
2005
Restored in
2019
Boat manufacturer
Hatteras
Boat type
Sportfishing

Engine model
Cummins
Powered by
2 x 630HP
Max cruising speed
25 knots
Loading
Loading
Loading
Loading
Loading
Loading
Loading
Loading
Loading
Loading

What’s biting in Montauk right now

Loading