Anglers Choice Sport Fishing

5.0/5 (127 reviews)

Federally permitted

99701 Overseas Highway, Key Largo, FL 33037, United States–

Meet the Captain

Anglers Choice Sport Fishing

Federally permitted

5.0/5 (127)

•

Angler's Choice

Meet the Captain

99701 Overseas Highway

Key Largo, FL, United States

Trips & prices Targeted species Boat info What's biting What's included Contact captain

Trips & prices What's included Targeted species Boat info Reviews Contact captain

Booked with us before? You may qualify for a Loyalty Discount. Sign in to check.

If you're ready to experience fishing in Key Largo, book a trip with Anglers Choice Sport Fishing. Your guide for the day is Captain Ryan, which allows you to benefit from years of local experience.

These waters hold game fish like Amberjack, Great Barracuda, Cobia, Mahi Mahi, Black Grouper, Goliath Grouper, Red Grouper, Snowy Grouper, Scamp Grouper, Blue Marlin, Sailfish, Tilefish, and more, depending on conditions. Depending on the species you’re after, you may find yourself spinning, popping, trolling, drifting, jigging, bottom fishing, or maybe something more specialized in this area. Capt.Ryan can also help you try kite fishing.

Families who love fishing together will be glad to know that kids are welcome aboard! Children must wear life vests, so find out if the appropriate size is available on board. And, you can't go wrong with snacks so that nobody gets grumpy on an empty stomach!

You'll step aboard a 40' custom flybridge with a capacity for 6 passengers. It comes with outriggers, downriggers, and all the essentials. There's a toilet on board for your convenience. Rods, reels, and tackle are covered by the charter, as well as lures. Live bait is on offer, but be sure to ask about it so you know if you'll be catching it yourself.

A First Mate will be there to make sure everything is running smoothly. Mates often work for tips and it's customary to offer them a 20% tip.

There's no need to buy a fishing license, so you can drive right over and come aboard without any hassle! Be mindful that some species may have special rules or limited seasons. Your captain will help you follow regulations while you fish. You can't go wrong when you bring bottled water, sunscreen (non-spray), and sunglasses. If you'd like to bring other drinks, just ask. Alcohol is allowed in moderation, but you should avoid hard liquor as well as glass bottles.

And that's it! Your fishing trip with Anglers Choice Sport Fishing is just a click away.

Rating

5.0

127 reviews

122

5.0

Boat & equipment

5.0

Captain & crew

5.0

Fishing Experience

Anglers' gallery (154)

+148

What anglers say

98%

Great experience

93%

Family friendly

100%

Friendly captain

100%

Good boat

97%

Recommended

100%

Caught fish

All reviews (127)

Filter

Sort by: Featured

Featured

Showing 1 – 5 of 126 reviews

Lisette Rodriguez

5.0

Verified

New

Incredible crew!

Half Day PM on January 17, 2026 • 4 adults • 2 children

My family and I have been fishing the Keys for many 30 years and have experienced many fishing crews. Captain Ryan and Cayden were hands down the best team. Captain Ryan was an expert managing his boat and the ocean. Cayden’s expertise came in while baiting and fishing. Together, they were the best duo. We went fishing with two small boys. The crew brought so much energy and patience along for the ride. Thank you for an unforgettable day out at sea. We’ll be seeing you again soon!

Reported catch:

Response from Captain

January 20, 2026

Thank you Lisette, it was so much fun fishing with you and the family! I hope Grayson had a great birthday. We really look forward to fishing with you all again.

Jacob Wiersum

5.0

Verified

night time shark trip

Shark and Tarpon on January 2, 2026 • 6 adults

while we didn't catch any sharks on this trip, the captain and mate worked their butts off and did everything they could to make it happen. saddly conditions were not in our favor, but that's just how it goes sometimes. we did, however, not leave empty-handed! they kept us busy catching yellow tail snapper, blue runners, horse eye jacks, and barracuda while we waited on the sharks. the conditions were tough across the board but they really did their best to show us a good time and despite not catching a shark i can honestly say this was one of the most enjoyable charters i have been on. i would recommend this crew to anyone, experienced or not. great boat, gear, and communication both before and during the trip.

Response from Captain

January 15, 2026

Hey Jacob, thank you very much for the great review. Hope we can get a chance go get you guys out there again some time.

Keevin Allred

5.0

Verified

New

Great day

3/4 Day Trip on January 11, 2026 • 6 adults

6 people and everyone caught fish Captain Ryan and first mate Luke were awesome. Friendly and super helpful. Luke was on top of things even when we were fighting 3 fish at once. Recommend 3/4 day if you are fairly serious about fishing. That's what we did and it still went pretty quick.

Response from Captain

January 15, 2026

Hey Keevin, thank you for the review. It was great fishing with you and your family. Hope we get a chance to get out with you all again.

Jeffrey Kotzan

5.0

Verified

Barracuda and tuna!

Half Day Trip (AM) on August 7, 2025 • 2 adults

My 15 yo son and I chartered a 4 hour morning fishing trip…..What a great day. Started out catching a bunch of yellowtail snapper fishing over the reef. Then moved offshore and did some trolling. We caught 5 beautiful blackfin tuna…..and my son reeled in a monster 49 inch barracuda! We are having a mount made as a souvenir! My son tells his mom it will look great over her bed! The boat was fast clean and beautiful. There is an air conditioned salon that is rare on charter fishing boats…..a very nice touch for families or fishermen that just don’t want to be out in the elements the whole time. The captain and mate were extremely knowledgeable and efficient. Back at the dock they cleaned our catch and arranged for our barracuda mount. Highly recommended!

Reported catch:

Jon Duren

5.0

Verified

An Unforgettable Day on the Water with Anglers Choice!

Full Day Trip on August 2, 2025 • 2 adults

If you're looking for a top-tier fishing experience in the Keys, Anglers Choice is the perfect choice! We had the pleasure of fishing with Captain Ryan and his mate Andrew, and from start to finish, they exceeded every expectation. Captain Ryan was personable, patient, and highly communicative. Before we even stepped on the boat, he made sure we knew exactly what to expect. He took the time to walk us through how the trip would unfold, answered all our questions, and made the entire experience feel approachable and exciting. Even if you are a seasoned angler, this professional team will provide you with an excellent fishing adventure. Andrew was just as impressive. He ensured our rods were ready and handled every fish with remarkable speed and precision. It was clear we were in the hands of true professionals who genuinely love what they do. Captain Ryan took us to multiple locations, maximizing our chances to hook a variety of fish, and it paid off as we caught plenty and had a blast doing it. Throughout the trip, Ryan's easygoing nature made it feel like we were fishing with an old friend. That kind of atmosphere can’t be taught, it’s just who he is. If you're thinking about booking a fishing charter, don’t hesitate. Anglers Choice with Captain Ryan and Andrew is the way to go. You’ll walk away with sore arms, great memories, and probably a cooler full of fish!

Reported catch:

Trip availability and prices

Trip Date:

Days:

Group Size:

Select date to see availability

February 2026

Su	Mo	Tu	We	Th	Fr	Sa

Number of days

Group Size

2 adults • 0 children

Change

Almost there...

Half Day Trip (AM)