
Book your next trip with Allison’s Nightmare Sportfishing and find out what keeps anglers coming back to Cape May for more. With Captain Chris at the helm, you’ll benefit from years of knowledge and experience.
Depending on conditions and time of year, you might hook into Marlin, Tuna, Wahoo, Mahi, Striped Bass, Bluefish, Bonito, Flounder, Black Seabass, Shark, Spanish Mackerel, and whatever else takes the bait. You’ll target your catch by trolling, chunking, or bottom fishing depending on the species.
Families who love fishing together will be glad to know that kids are welcome aboard! Child-sized life vests are available, however you should bring your own if you feel it will be more comfortable. And, you can’t go wrong with snacks to stay fueled throughout your trip!
Your vessel for the day is a custom 50’ Buddy Davis Sportfish Express with a capacity for 6 passengers. It comes with outriggers, a fighting chair, and everything else you need for a productive day on the water. There’s a private toilet on board for your convenience. Premium rods, reels, and tackle are included, as well as lures and bait.
A First Mate will be there to make sure everything is running smoothly. The mate works for tips and it’s customary to offer them a 10–20% tip.
Your fishing license for the day is covered by the charter boat, just show up ready for some fishing! Be mindful that some species may have special rules or limited seasons. Your captain will help you follow regulations while you fish.
A few items to bring include sunglasses, sunblock (non-spray), bottled water, and a hat. Alcohol is allowed in moderation, just be sure to avoid hard liquor as well as glass bottles.
If there’s more you’d like to know about fishing with Allison’s Nightmare Sportfishing, just send Capt. Chris a message down below.
Rating summary
Photos & videos by reviewers (3)



Angler rating
Anglers claimed
Good experience
100%
Appropriate for children
100%
Friendly captain
100%
Satisfied with the boat
100%
Recommend this charter
100%
Caught fish
100%

Aug 5, 2025
6 Hour Trip
We thoroughly enjoyed our AM 6-hour inshore trip with Captain Chris, Dylan, and Dalton. We caught 4 Spanish mackerel within the first half hour, and rounded out the trip with 20 fish total (including bluefish, fluke, and sea bass). The weather was amazing, which admittedly the crew can’t take credit for, but if it hadn’t been, the boat offers ample shade, AC, and shelter if needed. We tried for some Mahi, but it wasn’t in the cards. The boat is big, fast, and comfortable. We will be booking again with them next year.
We thoroughly enjoyed our AM 6-hour inshore trip with Captain Chris, Dylan, and Dalton. We caught 4 Spanish mackerel within the...



Aug 29, 2025
6 Hour Trip
Captain Chris and his first mate Dylan were great! My family, including two young daughters, had an awesome time fishing on Allison’s Nightmare. The boat was immaculate and the captain had us “on the fish” all day. We had a great time on the water and caught several different species of fish. I was able to get some awesome pictures and make some wonderful memories. Allison’s Nightmare is hands down, our No. 1 Charter of choice in New Jersey! Thanks Captain Chris for an awesome time!
Captain Chris and his first mate Dylan were great! My family, including two young daughters, had an awesome time fishing on Allison’s...


Jul 18, 2025
Offshore Canyon
Captain Voss and his crew were amazing. It was a first time experience for 5 of our 6 members and they made sure we all had a great time, all caught fish... and had plenty of water for a hot July day :)
Captain Voss and his crew were amazing. It was a first time experience for 5 of our 6 members and they made sure we all had a...

Jul 22, 2025
6 Hour Trip
| Su | Mo | Tu | We | Th | Fr | Sa | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Rating summary
Photos & videos by reviewers (3)



Angler rating
Anglers claimed
Good experience
100%
Appropriate for children
100%
Friendly captain
100%
Satisfied with the boat
100%
Recommend this charter
100%
Caught fish
100%

Experience:
Boat
Crew
Overall
6 Hour Trip on August 5, 2025
We thoroughly enjoyed our AM 6-hour inshore trip with Captain Chris, Dylan, and Dalton. We caught 4 Spanish mackerel within the first half hour, and rounded out the trip with 20 fish total (including bluefish, fluke, and sea bass). The weather was amazing, which admittedly the crew can’t take credit for, but if it hadn’t been, the boat offers ample shade, AC, and shelter if needed. We tried for some Mahi, but it wasn’t in the cards. The boat is big, fast, and comfortable. We will be booking again with them next year.
We thoroughly enjoyed our AM 6-hour inshore trip with Captain Chris, Dylan, and Dalton. We caught 4 Spanish mackerel within the first half hour, and rounded out the trip with 20 fish total (including bluefish, fluke, and sea bass). The weather was amazing, which admittedly the crew can’t take credit for, but if it hadn’t been, the boat offers ample shade, AC, and shelter if needed. We tried for some Mahi, but it wasn’t in the cards. The boat is big, fast, and comfortable. We will be booking...



Experience:
Boat
Crew
Overall
6 Hour Trip on August 29, 2025
Captain Chris and his first mate Dylan were great! My family, including two young daughters, had an awesome time fishing on Allison’s Nightmare. The boat was immaculate and the captain had us “on the fish” all day. We had a great time on the water and caught several different species of fish. I was able to get some awesome pictures and make some wonderful memories. Allison’s Nightmare is hands down, our No. 1 Charter of choice in New Jersey! Thanks Captain Chris for an awesome time!
Captain Chris and his first mate Dylan were great! My family, including two young daughters, had an awesome time fishing on Allison’s Nightmare. The boat was immaculate and the captain had us “on the fish” all day. We had a great time on the water and caught several different species of fish. I was able to get some awesome pictures and make some wonderful memories. Allison’s Nightmare is hands down, our No. 1 Charter of choice in New Jersey! Thanks Captain Chris for an awesome time!


Experience:
Boat
Crew
Overall
Offshore Canyon on July 18, 2025
Captain Voss and his crew were amazing. It was a first time experience for 5 of our 6 members and they made sure we all had a great time, all caught fish... and had plenty of water for a hot July day :)
Captain Voss and his crew were amazing. It was a first time experience for 5 of our 6 members and they made sure we all had a great time, all caught fish... and had plenty of water for a hot July day :)

Experience:
Boat
Crew
Overall
6 Hour Trip on July 22, 2025
