Florida Keys Island Fishing Charters
+136Make the most of your time in Big Pine Key with an unforgettable fishing adventure aboard Florida Keys Island Fishing Charters! Led by seasoned local guide Captain Tony, this family-run charter offers the perfect blend of excitement, expertise, and island hospitality.
Step aboard our 24’ Aquasport Tournament Series center console, powered by a 300HP Suzuki engine and built for comfort, safety, and performance. The boat is equipped with cushioned seating, a shaded canopy (available on request), Simrad GPS and Fishfinder, Bluetooth stereo, a live bait well, plenty of rod holders, and an under-deck fish box to keep your catch fresh. Whether you're an experienced angler or trying fishing for the first time, this boat is ready for action!
Depending on the season and conditions, you’ll have the opportunity to catch species like Mutton Snapper, Yellowtail Snapper, Great Barracuda, Cero Mackerel, Skipjack, Cobia, Tarpon, Black Grouper, Red Grouper, African Pompano, Mahi Mahi, Bull Shark, and many more. You’ll use proven techniques like spinning, jigging, trolling, bottom fishing, drift fishing, or cast and retrieve, with Captain Tony offering expert guidance along the way.
This charter is kid-friendly, family-friendly, and beginner-approved—and we love seeing young anglers light up when they reel in their first fish! Please let us know if you’ll need a child-size life vest. You’re welcome to bring your own snacks and sunscreen. We'll provide cold water in the onboard cooler, all gear, bait, tackle, and fishing licenses.
You can even bring beer (in cans only)—just no hard liquor or glass bottles. While some fish species may have seasonal regulations or size limits, Captain Tony will help you understand what's in season and what you can keep.
Fishing in the Lower Florida Keys has never been more fun or more personal. Whether you’re hoping to reel in dinner, chase a shark, or just enjoy quality time with loved ones on the water, your adventure starts here!
Captain
Anthony Polizze
Most popular features:
Trip availability and prices
Customer reviews
Rating summary
Photos & videos by reviewers (52)
+49Angler rating
Anglers claimed
Good experience
100%
Appropriate for children
100%
Friendly captain
100%
Satisfied with the boat
100%
Recommend this charter
100%
Caught fish
100%
Big Pine Key, Florida
Experience:
Boat
Crew
Overall
Captain Tony Taught Me How To Fish!
4 Hour Trip – Bridge Fishing (AM) on June 1, 2025
I've been fishing with Captain Tony for the past 22 years, and I can truly say he’s one of the best out there. He taught me everything I know about fishing—from bridge fishing to chasing trophy fish offshore—and thanks to him, I’ve caught some incredible prize fish over the years! Captain Tony is not only experienced and knowledgeable, but also incredibly patient and caring, especially with kids and families. He makes everyone feel comfortable and welcomed on the boat. Whether you're a seasoned angler or it's your first time holding a rod, he’ll make sure your trip is unforgettable. Highly recommend Florida Keys Island Fishing Charters for a fun, safe, and exciting day on the water!
I've been fishing with Captain Tony for the past 22 years, and I can truly say he’s one of the best out there. He taught me everything I know about fishing—from bridge fishing to chasing trophy fish offshore—and thanks to him, I’ve caught some incredible prize fish over the years! Captain Tony is not only experienced and knowledgeable, but also incredibly patient and caring, especially with kids and families. He makes everyone feel comfortable and welcomed on the boat. Whether you're a seasoned...
Lodz, Poland
Experience:
Boat
Crew
Overall
Great trip with Captain Tony
4 Hour Trip – Reef Fishing (AM) on May 27, 2025
Florida Keys Island Fishing is hands down the best fishing charter in the Keys! Captain Tony creates an experience that’s not just fun—but truly unforgettable. He’s fantastic with kids, patiently teaching them how to hook bait, cast properly, and reel in their catches. It’s more than just a fishing trip—it’s a hands-on education that my whole family loved. While they were busy reeling in fish after fish, I got to relax in the back of the boat, lounging comfortably under the canopy and soaking in the peaceful beauty of the Florida Keys. It was the perfect balance of adventure and serenity. We also asked Captain Tony for a scenic cruise, and he took us to explore the islands, bridges, and even out to the stunning Sombrero Lighthouse. Every moment was magical. This trip exceeded all expectations—highly recommend for families, couples, or anyone looking to experience the Keys from the water!
Florida Keys Island Fishing is hands down the best fishing charter in the Keys! Captain Tony creates an experience that’s not just fun—but truly unforgettable. He’s fantastic with kids, patiently teaching them how to hook bait, cast properly, and reel in their catches. It’s more than just a fishing trip—it’s a hands-on education that my whole family loved. While they were busy reeling in fish after fish, I got to relax in the back of the boat, lounging comfortably under the canopy and soaking...
Big Pine Key, Florida
Experience:
Boat
Crew
Overall
Multiple Fishing and Sightseeing Trips with Captain Tony
4 Hour Trip – Bridge Fishing (AM) on April 16, 2025
Captain Tony has taken us out on the water multiple times, and every trip is a fantastic experience! Whether we’re catching delicious reef fish, battling sharks and barracudas, or exploring the islands by boat, it's always an adventure. We also work with Captain Tony to film beautiful footage of the Florida Keys from the water, and he always makes the process smooth and enjoyable. He’s excellent with kids and anglers of all ages—patient, knowledgeable, and fun. If you're looking for one of the best fishing charters in the Florida Keys, Florida Keys Island Fishing Charters is it!
Captain Tony has taken us out on the water multiple times, and every trip is a fantastic experience! Whether we’re catching delicious reef fish, battling sharks and barracudas, or exploring the islands by boat, it's always an adventure. We also work with Captain Tony to film beautiful footage of the Florida Keys from the water, and he always makes the process smooth and enjoyable. He’s excellent with kids and anglers of all ages—patient, knowledgeable, and fun. If you're looking for one of the...
Lodz, Poland
Experience:
Boat
Crew
Overall
Fishing with Captain Tony discovering a new passion!
4 Hour Trip – Bridge Fishing (AM) on March 24, 2025
When we visited the Florida Keys this spring, I never imagined our family would discover a brand new passion—fishing! But that’s exactly what happened after we booked a trip with Captain Tony at Florida Keys Island Fishing. My husband was battling sharks and reeling mutton snappers, while our seven-year-old son caught yellowtail snappers and a variety of other fish—all with the biggest smile on his face. Watching his excitement and pride was truly priceless! While the boys fished, I got to unwind on the comfy back bed under the shade of the canopy—something you don’t find on most charters. Captain Tony and his wife Eva went above and beyond to make sure we were comfortable, safe, and having a great time from start to finish. If you're looking for a family-friendly, unforgettable experience on the water, this is the charter to book. Highly, highly recommend!
When we visited the Florida Keys this spring, I never imagined our family would discover a brand new passion—fishing! But that’s exactly what happened after we booked a trip with Captain Tony at Florida Keys Island Fishing. My husband was battling sharks and reeling mutton snappers, while our seven-year-old son caught yellowtail snappers and a variety of other fish—all with the biggest smile on his face. Watching his excitement and pride was truly priceless! While the boys fished, I got to...
Warsaw, Poland
Experience:
Boat
Crew
Overall
Fishing with Captain Tony - Amazing adventure!
4-Hour Afternoon Fishing Trip (PM) on March 24, 2025
During our vacation in the Florida Keys, we booked a bridge fishing trip with Captain Tony of Florida Keys Island Fishing Charters—and it turned out to be the highlight of our entire trip! Visiting from Europe, I never imagined I’d be battling a shark right off the Bahia Honda Bridge! It was an unforgettable fight and a once-in-a-lifetime experience. My son was absolutely thrilled to see the shark up close, and now he has a story to tell his friends back home that they'll never believe. Captain Tony’s wife, Eva, joined us on the trip and captured some incredible photos and videos for their YouTube channel. I can’t wait to see the final footage! Tony and Eva are a fantastic team—professional, welcoming, and especially great with kids. If you're looking for an authentic Florida Keys fishing adventure, this is the charter to book. Highly recommend!
During our vacation in the Florida Keys, we booked a bridge fishing trip with Captain Tony of Florida Keys Island Fishing Charters—and it turned out to be the highlight of our entire trip! Visiting from Europe, I never imagined I’d be battling a shark right off the Bahia Honda Bridge! It was an unforgettable fight and a once-in-a-lifetime experience. My son was absolutely thrilled to see the shark up close, and now he has a story to tell his friends back home that they'll never believe. Captain...
FAQs about Florida Keys Island Fishing Charters
What are the trip rates for Florida Keys Island Fishing Charters?
Florida Keys Island Fishing Charters offers the following trips to customers:
- US $575 per group - 3 Hour Trip – Backcountry (AM) (3 hours)
- US $575 per group - 3 Hour Trip – Bridge Fishing (AM) (3 hours)
- US $575 per group - 3-Hour Afternoon Fishing Trip (PM) (3 hours)
- US $699 per group - 4 Hour Trip – Backcountry (AM) (4 hours)
- US $699 per group - 4 Hour Trip – Bridge Fishing (AM) (4 hours)
- US $699 per group - 4 Hour Trip – Reef Fishing (AM) (4 hours)
- US $699 per group - 4-Hour Afternoon Fishing Trip (PM) (4 hours)
Which amenities are available onboard with Florida Keys Island Fishing Charters?
When you book a trip with Florida Keys Island Fishing Charters, you can expect the following amenities onboard:
- GPS
- Fishfinder
- Live Bait Well
- Ice Box
What's included in the trip price with Florida Keys Island Fishing Charters?
Trips booked with Florida Keys Island Fishing Charters include:
- Rods, reels & tackle
- Live Bait
- Lures
- Catch cleaning & filleting
- Drinks
- Fishing License
What types of fishing does Florida Keys Island Fishing Charters offer?
Florida Keys Island Fishing Charters offers the following types of fishing:
- Inshore Fishing
- Nearshore Fishing
- Reef Fishing
- Wreck Fishing
- Backcountry Fishing
What fishing techniques does Florida Keys Island Fishing Charters offer?
Florida Keys Island Fishing Charters offers the following fishing techniques:
- Light Tackle
- Heavy Tackle
- Bottom Fishing
- Trolling
- Spinning
- Jigging
Which fish species can I catch with Florida Keys Island Fishing Charters?
Top targeted fish species with Florida Keys Island Fishing Charters include:
- Barracuda (Great)
- Bonito
- Cero Mackerel
- Cobia
- Dolphin (Mahi Mahi)
- Grouper (Black)
- Grouper (Red)
- Jack (African Pompano)
- Shark (Bull)
- Snapper (Mutton)
- Snapper (Yellowtail)
- Tarpon
Your captain
Big Pine Key, Florida, United States
Hi, I’m Captain Tony Polizze. Originally from the Jersey Shore, I grew up in Wildwood Crest and Cape May, New Jersey—where my love for fishing began the day I landed a 38” striped bass right off the beach. From that moment on, I was hooked. Growing up, I spent my summers fishing up north and my winters down in South Florida, where I explored the waters of the southeast and southwest coasts—and eventually, the Florida Keys. The contrast between northern and southern fisheries shaped me as an angler, giving me a deep respect for the challenge and strategy each species brings. Even now, I’m always thinking through how to land the next trophy fish these beautiful waters have to offer. Today, I’m proud to call the Florida Keys home and run my fishing charter out of Big Pine Key—right in the heart of some of the best fishing in the world. From backcountry, bridge, and patch reef fishing to thrilling offshore trips, there's always something exciting to chase in any season or condition. But fishing isn't the only thing that drives me—family is everything to me. My wife and I share a deep love for the ocean and the lifestyle that comes with living in the Keys. We’ve spent countless days together exploring these waters, and it never gets old. We're raising our two beautiful daughters, Olivia and Claudia, to appreciate the same sense of adventure, nature, and connection that fishing brings. One of my greatest joys is sharing this experience with other families—especially kids. I love teaching children how to fish and seeing their excitement when they reel in something colorful and wild. For me, fishing is about more than just the catch. It’s about the experience, the patience, and the lasting memories created on the water. Whether you’re a seasoned angler or a first-time fisherman, I invite you to join me for an unforgettable day on the water. Let’s create memories that will last a lifetime. Tight lines, Captain Tony Your Fishing Guide to the Florida Keys
The fish you can target
What is the boat like?
What kind of fishing will you do?
Inshore Fishing
Nearshore Fishing
Reef Fishing
Wreck Fishing
Backcountry Fishing
Which fishing techniques you can try
Light Tackle
Heavy Tackle
Bottom Fishing
Trolling
Spinning
Jigging
Which amenities are available onboard
GPS
Fishfinder
Live Bait Well
Ice Box
What’s included in the trip price
Rods, reels & tackle
Live Bait
Lures
Catch cleaning & filleting
Drinks
Fishing License
How cancellations work
Free cancellation up to 1 day prior to trip
You can cancel or modify your booking up to 1 day before the trip date, free of charge. If you cancel or modify your booking later, or fail to show up, you'll forfeit 100% of what you've paid.
What the listing policies are
Pickup not included
Transfer to/from departure site is not included in trip rates.
Child Friendly
No Smoking
You Keep Catch
How you can pay
Pay online in full
Pay online in full through FishingBooker and save on credit card fees at the dock.
No additional fees.
Book with 10% deposit, pay rest to captain
When the captain confirms your trip, FishingBooker charges your credit card a 10% deposit to guarantee your reservation.
The remaining balance is to be paid directly to the charter operator on or prior to your trip date in one of the following payment methods:
Cash
Visa
Mastercard
PayPal
When paying the remaining balance with a credit card, an additional 3% charge will apply.
What’s biting in Big Pine Key right now
Barracuda (Great)
Bonito
Cobia
Dolphin (Mahi Mahi)
Grouper (Black)
Grouper (Red)
Snapper (Mutton)
Snapper (Yellowtail)
TarponCompare similar fishing charters
