angler's choice
One of our top picks in Islamorada.
USCG Licensed Master Captain Tony Nagel
Located at Mile Market 74.5 Islamorada Fl
Let Captain Tony give you the Sportfishing experience of a lifetime.
Let us put you on your fish of your choice, whether it is Sailfish, Wahoo, Mahi Mahi, Tuna, Yellowtail, Grouper, Shark or Tarpon. The Signing Reel is equipped for all types of sportfishing.
Tony was born with a fishing rod in hand while living at the shore all of his life. He has been sportfishing since he was a young child. Growing up on the seas gave him the advantages and knowledge to make him the great fisherman he is today.
Fishing with many great fishermen, he learned many skills as well as custom rod building. His love of Sportfishing adventures has brought him to many different locations and tournaments from Montauk Point to the Canyons off New Jersey to Ocean City Maryland, as well as Costa Rica and Dominican Republic to name a few. All while learning different and valuable fishing techniques along the way.
Tony is personable and is excellent at assisting seasoned fisherman as well as teaching new beginners the basics of fishing, making them comfortable with their fishing experience while helping them catch fish.
Tony and his wife (fishing partner) Janice are at home Residing in Islamorada Lower Matecumbe Key
We also offer training Charters on your boat or ours.
USCG Licensed Master Captain Tony Nagel
Located at Mile Market 74.5 Islamorada Fl
Let Captain Tony give you the Sportfishing experience of a lifetime.
Let us put you on your fish of your choice, whether it is Sailfish, Wahoo, Mahi
Availability
Select date to see available trips and rates:
About this listing
Sea Craft (Center console) originally built in 1974, and restored in 2016. Powered by a 300HP Mercruiser engine, with a maximum cruising speed of 25 knots.
15% deposit charged upfront by FishingBooker to guarantee your reservation. The remaining balance is to be paid directly to the charter operator on or prior to your trip date in one of the following payment methods: Cash.
About the Captain
Member since August 2016
Islamorada Fishing Calendar
Customer Reviews
5 out of 5 stars from 9 reviews
| 5 stars |
|
9 |
| 4 stars |
|
0 |
| 3 stars |
|
0 |
| 2 stars |
|
0 |
| 1 star |
|
0 |
VERIFIED Went fishing on July 17, 2017
It was absolutely perfect! I told Captain Toney beforehand that it was a fishing trip for my daughter and he didn’t disappoint! I felt he went above and beyond in making sure we caught a shark and we did(6ft 150lbsblacktip)! My daughter left saying it was the funniest coolest thing ever! She has truly not stop smiling and snap chatting about her experience!!! So thanks Captain Toney!!!
Fished July 2017
Fished July 17, 2017Replied to this review on July 19, 2017
We are so happy that you enjoyed your fishing adventure with us. That is our number one goal.! Thank you for choosing us and we can’t wait to see you again. These photos say and smile say it all. Thank you, Capt Tony
Brandon Craus recommends Singing Reel Charters
- Boat
- Crew
- Overall
Replied to this review on July 19, 2017
We are so happy that you enjoyed your fishing adventure with us. That is our number one goal.! Thank you for choosing us and we can’t wait to see you again. These photos say and smile say it all. Thank you, Capt Tony
VERIFIED Went fishing on July 12, 2017
My fiance and I had awesome time fishing with Captain Tony. We went deep into the open ocean and right away Tony put us on fish! The blackfin tuna were biting like crazy and it was nonstop action! Tony was great! He is very friendly, outgoing, humble, and down to earth. He also is extremely knowledgeable about fishing and knows the ocean like the back of his hand! we ended up catching 12 Blackfin tuna all very good size, 1 large barracuda, and 1 mahi! If you want to get the most for your money and experience fishing at its best than this is the charter for you! Why pay 1200 to 1500bux per day elsewhere?! Here you pay half that and catch more fish. We had a great time! Thanks again Tony! Oh and cant forget his wife Janice who was super nice and welcomed us back to the dock. She made us a fish print that will be framed and will be a lifelong memory. Awesome experience!!
Fished July 2017
Fished July 12, 2017Replied to this review on July 14, 2017
We are so humbled by your review. Thank you so very much for choosing Singing Reel Charters for your Sportfishing adventure. You guys are so nice it was so nice to make a new friend. We will see you again soon. Yours truly, Capt Tony & Janice
Michael Maso recommends Singing Reel Charters
- Boat
- Crew
- Overall
Replied to this review on July 14, 2017
We are so humbled by your review. Thank you so very much for choosing Singing Reel Charters for your Sportfishing adventure. You guys are so nice it was so nice to make a new friend. We will see you again soon. Yours truly, Capt Tony & Janice
VERIFIED Went fishing on June 26, 2017
Fabulous time! I took my two teenage kids fishing and we had a great time. Caught lots of fish (yellowtail, snappers and more) Spectacular ocean views. Tony was very patient (we’re novices.) He had anything you may have forgotten… Water, sun screen and ice. To end the trip his talented wife Janice made gyotaku prints of the fish. The icing on the cake was meeting their dog, Nadhera
Fished June 2017
Fished June 26, 2017Replied to this review on June 28, 2017
Thank you for allowing us to be a important part of your visit to the Florida Keys and your Sportfishing adventure. We enjoyed meeting you all. We hope that we will see you next time. Always. Capt Tony, Janice & Nadirah.
Julie Shupp recommends Singing Reel Charters
- Boat
- Crew
- Overall
Replied to this review on June 28, 2017
Thank you for allowing us to be a important part of your visit to the Florida Keys and your Sportfishing adventure. We enjoyed meeting you all. We hope that we will see you next time. Always. Capt Tony, Janice & Nadirah.
Top Fishing Charters
4654 pro captains at your fingertips
Fast & Easy Booking
Book online to lock in your dates
Instant Confirmation
Look for the Instant Book symbol
