New Buffalo Fishing Charters
The best out of 22 charter fishing deals in New Buffalo - enter dates to check availability
5.0/5 (10 reviews)
St. Joseph (34 min drive from New Buffalo)
St. Joseph has a fish with your name on it, so let Fishful Thinking Charters LLC help you catch it! Depending on the season, you might hook into Salmon, Lake Trout, Brown Trout, Rainbow Trout (Steelhead), and anything else that bites.
"My husband and I did the “Lake Trout Charter Half Day $700” on Capt Bryce Watson’s Fishful Thinking in St." — Teresa,
"My husband and I did the “Lake Trout Charter Half Day $700” on Capt Bryce Watson’s Fishful Thinking in St." — Teresa,
Trips from
US $500
MJ's Sportfishing Charters – Lake Michigan
5.0/5 (39 reviews)
St. Joseph (34 min drive from New Buffalo)
Spend a day with MJ’s Sportfishing Charters and get bit fishing the clear blue waters of Lake Michigan! Your guide for the day is Captain Mike Jones. Fishing out of St.
Trips from
US $700
5.0/5 (58 reviews)
St. Joseph (33 min drive from New Buffalo)
Book your next trip with Flagship Fishing Charters and find out what keeps anglers coming back to St. Joseph for more. Having logged many hours on these waters, Captain Chris knows how to put you on the fish.
"I am not an Angler but my nephews were visiting from upstate NY…having never been to Michigan before and they requested to go fishing…." — Liz,
"I am not an Angler but my nephews were visiting from upstate NY…having never been to Michigan before and they requested to go fishing…." — Liz,
Trips from
US $700
4.9/5 (163 reviews)
St. Joseph (33 min drive from New Buffalo)
If you are looking for some classic lake trolling you have found the perfect charter for you. In The Box Fishing Charters offer great fishing trips for those needing to escape the hustle and bustle of day-to-day life.
"The best charter experience! The captain was amazing- very knowledgeable and patient with our kids." — James,
"The best charter experience! The captain was amazing- very knowledgeable and patient with our kids." — James,
Trips from
US $450
4.8/5 (39 reviews)
St. Joseph (28 min drive from New Buffalo)
Excited to catch some fish in St. Joseph? Make it happen, with Blue Harbor Charters! Having logged many hours on these tides, Captain Joshua is prepared to put you on fish.
"We had the absolute best experience with Captain Josh! From the moment we stepped aboard, everything was top-notch - clean boat, professional, and an atmosphere that made us feel welcome and excited." — Nick,
"We had the absolute best experience with Captain Josh! From the moment we stepped aboard, everything was top-notch - clean boat, professional, and an atmosphere that made us feel welcome and excited." — Nick,
Trips from
US $700
4.8/5 (195 reviews)
St. Joseph (33 min drive from New Buffalo)
Silver Beach Fishing Co invites you to team up with Captain Kyle Ender for an unforgettable fishing adventure out of St. Joseph, Michigan. Capt.
"I can’t say enough good things about Capt Kyle and our trip!" — Robyn,
"I can’t say enough good things about Capt Kyle and our trip!" — Robyn,
Trips from
US $550
5.0/5 (133 reviews)
St. Joseph (34 min drive from New Buffalo)
Fish Stalker Charters - think friendliness, professionalism, cleanliness and comfort. All this on the pristine waters of Lake Michigan! If you want a seasoned Captain with a firm grip, this is it.
"Captain Kevin did us proud on our full day’s trip. We caught a huge 33inch lake trout and a bunch of steelhead trout and coho salmon." — Richard,
"Captain Kevin did us proud on our full day’s trip. We caught a huge 33inch lake trout and a bunch of steelhead trout and coho salmon." — Richard,
Trips from
US $650
4.9/5 (30 reviews)
St. Joseph (28 min drive from New Buffalo)
Our Leg-A-Sea Charters runs angling trips out of St. Joseph, MI and shows you what the local fishery is all about. Come aboard with Captain Christopher & Captain Pepper, whose main priority is to get you on some fish.
"We had to reschedule twice due to bad conditions. We COULD have gone out but they suggested we reschedule and offered other dates." — Tori,
"We had to reschedule twice due to bad conditions. We COULD have gone out but they suggested we reschedule and offered other dates." — Tori,
Trips from
US $748
Benton Harbor (32 min drive from New Buffalo)
There's a fish with your name on it in Benton Harbor and On Mission Fishing will help you catch it! Captain John will be your guide, which means you'll tap into years of knowledge and experience.
Trips from
US $700
MJ's Sportfishing Charters – St. Joseph River
5.0/5 (5 reviews)
Berrien Springs (35 min drive from New Buffalo)
If you’re here to make the most of fishing in Berrien Springs, look no further than MJ’s Sportfishing Charters. We move to indiana waters in March to finish the steelhead season.
"MJ charters is the best we got fish when the weather wasn’t..." — Ricky,
"MJ charters is the best we got fish when the weather wasn’t..." — Ricky,
Trips from
US $400
Frequently Asked Questions about Fishing Charters in New Buffalo
What are the best private fishing charters in New Buffalo?
According to customer reviews, some of the most popular fishing charters in New Buffalo, Michigan are: