Fair Haven Fishing Charters

The best out of 142 charter fishing deals in Fair Haven - enter dates to check availability

Fair Haven: 142 fishing charters available

Showing 1 - 10
Listing image

29 ft

Up to 6 people

eFISHnsea Sportfishing – Raritan Bay

Highlands (14 min drive from Fair Haven)
eFISHnsea Sportfishing is all about fishing the stunning waters of Raritan Bay. With Captain William at the helm, you're in knowledgeable and experienced hands. You're likely to fish for Striped Bass, and more with any luck.
Trips from
US $650
Listing image

29 ft

Up to 6 people

Sandy Hook Charters – Fast & Family-friendly

5.0/5 (73 reviews)
Middletown Township (15 min drive from Fair Haven)
Sandy Hook Charters welcomes you aboard and invites you to embark on an unforgettable and private fishing adventure.

"TJ & Jack were great! We caught tons of fish, and they worked hard for us." —⁠ Stacy,
Trips from
US $460
Listing image

38 ft

Up to 6 people

Teacher's Pet Sport Fishing

5.0/5 (58 reviews)
Highlands (15 min drive from Fair Haven)
Teacher’s Pet Sport Fishing is located in Highlands and offers to show you a memorable time in these waters. It has got over 30 years in the charter boat business, fishing from the same slip for those 30 years and the same waters. Capt.

"Captain Jerry and His mate Timmy are top notch, put us on the fish and kept us in them best we could given the rough winds (choppy water)  and warm water." —⁠ Johnny,
Trips from
US $595
Listing image

55 ft

Up to 45 people

Ebbtide Fishing Charters

4.8/5 (34 reviews)
Atlantic Highlands (14 min drive from Fair Haven)
Come visit the quaint community of the Atlantic Highlands New Jersey, and discover the fishing potential of local bays. When in the neighborhood contact Ebbtide Fishing Charters and they’ll set you up with a fishing trip in comfort and style.

"Captain rob did a great job putting us on the fish! He is friendly and easygoing." —⁠ Josh,
Trips from
US $1,700

Angler's choice

Listing image

20 ft

Up to 3 people

PrimeTime Fishing Charters

4.9/5 (65 reviews)
Highlands (15 min drive from Fair Haven)
Whether you’re looking for the reel-screaming thrill of fighting a trophy-sized fish or you want to provide your family a relaxing day spent outdoors, PrimeTime Fishing Charters has a trip for you! Captain Karl McKenna will put you on the hottest bi

"Captain Karl is easygoing, knows his business, and provided a good trip." —⁠ Andy,
Trips from
US $500
Listing image

50 ft

Up to 40 people

Nighthawk Sport Fishing

Just listed
Atlantic Highlands (3.9 miles from Fair Haven)
Spend the day with Northeast Fishing LLC and let them show you what makes the fishing in Atlantic Highlands so memorable! Your guide for the day is Captain Ethan, bringing aboard their local experience.
Trips from
US $800
Listing image

30 ft

Up to 6 people

Westwind Charter Fishing

4.8/5 (35 reviews)
Middletown Township (15 min drive from Fair Haven)
Westwind Charter Fishing invites you on an unforgettable fishing adventure in the abundant waters of Middletown, New Jersey.

"Took my family out for a 4 hour fluke trip and had a blast. Captain Mike and his mate Jack were knowledgeable and friendly, and they took us where the fish were." —⁠ John,
Trips from
US $585
Listing image

32 ft

Up to 6 people

Father Time Charters

Highlands (14 min drive from Fair Haven)
If you're ready to experience fishing in the Raritan Bay and surrounding waters, look no further than Father Time Charters. With Captain Keith, Chris, or Ethan at the helm, you'll have a knowledgeable and experienced guide.
Trips from
US $900
Listing image

27 ft

Up to 4 people

Hook & Fin Fishing Charters

4.9/5 (51 reviews)
Middletown Township (20 min drive from Fair Haven)
Let Hook & Fin Fishing Charters take you out for a fun and productive fishing trip around Sandy Hook.

"Captain Steve was informative, helpful and provided us with a great experience." —⁠ Amy,
Trips from
US $580
Listing image

30 ft

Up to 6 people

Triple Header Charters

Highlands (15 min drive from Fair Haven)
Triple Header Charters is a light tackle guide service located in Highlands, New Jersey and offers to show you a memorable time in these waters. The crew targets inshore and offshore species using a variety of fishing methods. Capt.
Trips from
US $675

Frequently Asked Questions about Fishing Charters in Fair Haven

What are the best private fishing charters in Fair Haven?

According to customer reviews, some of the most popular fishing charters in Fair Haven, New Jersey are:

    Powered by AI

    Fishing in Fair Haven

    Fair Haven, New Jersey, is a premier fishing destination nestled along the Navesink River, offering diverse angling opportunities just minutes from the Atlantic coast. This charming town provides easy access to both riverine and saltwater fisheries, making it ideal for anglers of all skill levels. The historic Fair Haven Fishing Pier serves as a central hub for recreational fishing and crabbing, especially productive during high tides. Here, you can target species like Striped Bass, Bluefish, and Summer Flounder directly from the pier or nearby shorelines.

    The Navesink River's calm, protected waters are perfect for light-tackle fishing, with seasonal runs of Atlantic Menhaden and Hickory Shad drawing predator species. Beyond the river, charters quickly reach Sandy Hook Bay's rich inshore grounds for Tautog and Weakfish, or venture into Raritan Bay for Fluke and Black Sea Bass. Nearshore excursions yield larger pelagics like Bluefin Tuna during migration seasons.

    Freshwater enthusiasts find excellent options minutes inland at Shadow Lake and Shippees Pond, where Largemouth Bass and Panfish thrive. The area's intricate network of creeks and marshes also supports fly fishing for schoolie Stripers. With convenient public amenities including boat ramps, ample moorage, and free pier access, Fair Haven combines accessibility with exceptional year-round fishing. Its proximity to New York City adds to its appeal as a convenient yet immersive angling escape.

    Fair Haven

    Based on 29,217 reviews by FishingBooker anglers