Bay Shore Fishing Charters

The best out of 75 charter fishing deals in Bay Shore - enter dates to check availability

Bay Shore Fishing Charters

Compare 75 captains, read reviews, and book in minutes

Trip date
banner
Loading...

Top Fishing Charters in Bay Shore

Bay Shore: 75 fishing charters available

Showing 1 - 10
 Show on map
Listing image
24 ft
Up to 5 people
Fire Island Fishing Charters Llc
5.0
/5
(29 reviews)
Bay Shore
Just off the coast of Long Island lies Fire Island, a thin line separating Long Island from the Atlantic Ocean.

"If your looking for someone who’s from here, knows the water, knows the spots and has a good personality, Capt." —⁠ Gail,
trips from
US $600
Listing image
36 ft
Up to 6 people
Brady Boys Charters
Bay Shore
Excited to go fishing in Bay Shore? Brady Boys Charters is your ticket! With Captain Michael at the helm, you'll benefit from years of knowledge and experience.
trips from
US $1,200
Listing image
26 ft
Up to 6 people
Keep It Tight Fishing Charters
5.0
/5
(47 reviews)
East Massapequa (25 min drive from Bay Shore)
Based out of Jones inlet, Keep It Tight Fishing Charters is your ticket to a memorable time on the water. Capt. George will do his best to make sure you have a fun day full of fishing.

"We had an unforgettable fishing trip on July 5th, which was my son’s 10th birthday!" —⁠ Saravana,
trips from
US $600
Listing image
25 ft
Up to 4 people
JMPNMAKO II Sport Fish Charters
4.6
/5
(4 reviews)
Bay Shore
Excited to catch some fish in the great south bay? That's what JMPNMAKO II Sport Fish Charters is here for! We will be targeting striped bass and blackfish in the spring, then tuna, shark and bottom fish in the summer out of ISLIP On the day of your

"Capt. Gary knows his stuff. He immediately found the signs of fish—birds diving, bait on the sounder, fish busting—and was able to put us on some fish." —⁠ Peter,
trips from
US $650
Listing image
35 ft
Up to 6 people
Patty Ann Charters
4.8
/5
(40 reviews)
Babylon (15 min drive from Bay Shore)
15-20% tip is customary to the mate. Captree fishing charters aboard the Patty Ann offers fishing trips in and around Babylon, New York. The crew is made up of professional guides, who have won many tournaments throughout their careers.

"We went with Patty Charter last year and had such a positive experience that we went again this year!" —⁠ Melissa,
trips from
US $660
Angler's Choice
Listing image
25 ft
Up to 4 people
Just One Bite Charters
5.0
/5
(13 reviews)
Mastic Beach (35 min drive from Bay Shore)
If you're going to cast a line in the Moriches waters, look no further than Just One Bite Charters. With Captain Paul Nilsson at the helm, you'll have a knowledgeable and experienced guide.

"We had a great day fishing with Captain Paul! While the boat is a bit older, it’s been re-powered recently and ran beautifully, making for a smooth and comfortable trip." —⁠ Lawrence,
trips from
US $350
Listing image
25 ft
Up to 4 people
Cast Net Charters
5.0
/5
(15 reviews)
Island Park (44 min drive from Bay Shore)
There's a fish with your name on it in Island Park and Cast Net Charters will help you catch it! Your guide for the day is Captain Ryan, which means you'll tap into years of local experience.

"Wow!!! Had a fantastic outing with capt Ryan. Went with my wife and two sons age 16 and 18." —⁠ Jin,
trips from
US $500
Listing image
30 ft
Up to 4 people
Dog House Charters
5.0
/5
(12 reviews)
West Sayville (16 min drive from Bay Shore)
Dog House Charters is here to help you experience the stunning waters of Long Island. Your guide for the day is Captain Ted, allowing you to benefit from years of professional experience.

"We did a 5 hour trip with Captain Ted recently and had a great day on the water." —⁠ Bob,
trips from
US $350
Listing image
33 ft
Up to 6 people
Keepin It Reel Sportfishing – Long Island
Lindenhurst (19 min drive from Bay Shore)
Light Tackle Tuna Fishing in Long Island | Keepin It Reel Sportfishing If you’re searching for the ultimate light tackle Tuna fishing in Long Island, Keepin It Reel Sportfishing delivers a hands-on offshore experience designed for anglers who want m
trips from
US $3,000
Listing image
36 ft
Up to 6 people
Shut Up & Fish LI
4.9
/5
(7 reviews)
Massapequa Park (25 min drive from Bay Shore)
Massapequa has a fish with your name on it, so let Shut Up & Fish LI help you catch it! Captain Steve has over 25 years of experience fishing the waters off the south shore of Long Island.

"very friendly Cap and first mate." —⁠ Yuri,
trips from
US $850

Top deep sea fishing trips in Bay Shore

  • Loading...
  • Loading...
  • Loading...
  • Loading...

Top-rated family fishing trips in Bay Shore

  • Loading...
  • Loading...
  • Loading...
  • Loading...

Half-day fishing trips in Bay Shore

  • Loading...
  • Loading...
  • Loading...
  • Loading...

Frequently Asked Questions about Fishing Charters in Bay Shore

Loading
Loading
Loading
Loading
Loading
Powered by AI

Fishing in Bay Shore

Bay Shore, New York, is a premier fishing destination on Long Island's south shore, renowned for its diverse angling opportunities across saltwater and freshwater environments. Access to the Great South Bay, Fire Island Inlet, and the Atlantic Ocean positions Bay Shore fishing charters at the heart of productive waters teeming with species like Striped bass, Largemouth bass, Summer flounder, and Bluefish. These charters leverage local expertise to navigate prime spots such as Captree State Park—home to Long Island's largest public fishing fleet—and the nutrient-rich channels around Captree Island and Snakehill.

Charters offer tailored experiences for every angler, from beginners to seasoned enthusiasts, with comprehensive gear provision and guidance. Beyond boat-based adventures, Bay Shore provides exceptional pier, surf, and shoreline fishing, particularly at state parks and county access points where night fishing permits extend angling hours. The region's estuaries and inlets create dynamic ecosystems supporting year-round catches, making Bay Shore fishing charters a gateway to both inshore tranquility and open-ocean challenges.

Bay Shore

4.8
/5
Based on 30,770 reviews by FishingBooker anglers

Bay Shore Fishing Calendar

Loading

Recent Catches in Bay Shore

  • Loading...
  • Loading...
  • Loading...
  • Loading...
  • Loading...
  • Loading...

What anglers said about fishing in Bay Shore

  • Loading...
  • Loading...
  • Loading...
  • Loading...

How did anglers rate fishing charters in Bay Shore?

  • Loading...
  • Loading...
  • Loading...
  • Loading...

Nearby Fishing Destinations

  • Loading...
  • Loading...
  • Loading...
  • Loading...