Brookhaven Fishing Charters
61 fishing charters
The best out of 61 charter fishing deals in Brookhaven - enter dates to check availability
5.0/5 (11 reviews)
Mastic Beach (17 min drive from Brookhaven)
If you're going to cast a line in the Moriches waters, look no further than Just One Bite Charters. With Captain Paul Nilsson at the helm, you'll have a knowledgeable and experienced guide.
"We had a great day fishing with Captain Paul! While the boat is a bit older, it’s been re-powered recently and ran beautifully, making for a smooth and comfortable trip." — Lawrence,
"We had a great day fishing with Captain Paul! While the boat is a bit older, it’s been re-powered recently and ran beautifully, making for a smooth and comfortable trip." — Lawrence,
Blue Point (18 min drive from Brookhaven)
Valhalla Voyages invites you for a thrilling day of surfcasting on the peaceful Atlantic coast! Let knowledgeable guide Keith take you to some of the best spots to fish for some of the most popular species in the area.
Blue Point (17 min drive from Brookhaven)
Looking to go fishing in Blue Point? Then Kelly Anne Charters has a trip with your name on it! Striped Bass, Bluefish, Flounder, Black Seabass, Weakfish, and more can be found in these waters if you come at the right time of year.
4.8/5 (43 reviews)
Mastic (14 min drive from Brookhaven)
Fishing in New York is something that needs to be ticked off your bucket list as soon as possible. It’s very rare that a short ride out can suddenly make you feel a world away. But with D.C. Outdoor Adventures, that’s exactly what happens.
"The Yellowfin tuna charter was AMAZING. Captain Dennis and his first mate are the BEST around." — Sean,
"The Yellowfin tuna charter was AMAZING. Captain Dennis and his first mate are the BEST around." — Sean,
D.C. Outdoor Adventures 21' Inshore
4.9/5 (7 reviews)
Mastic (14 min drive from Brookhaven)
Whether you have tried inshore fishing before or not, you need to book with D.C. Outdoor Adventures today. Captain Dennis Caracciolo has been fishing his whole life and is confident that you will have a great day on the water with him.
"The captain went out of his way to make sure my 10 year old son had good action he caught 3 sharks and a fluke." — Jake,
"The captain went out of his way to make sure my 10 year old son had good action he caught 3 sharks and a fluke." — Jake,
5.0/5 (3 reviews)
Port Jefferson (35 min drive from Brookhaven)
Looking to catch some fish in Port Jefferson? Long Island Light Tackle is here to make it happen! With Captain Rick at the helm, you’re in knowledgeable and experienced hands.
"Captain Richard was friendly and motivated. He worked hard to find the fish." — Kevin,
"Captain Richard was friendly and motivated. He worked hard to find the fish." — Kevin,
Mount Sinai (33 min drive from Brookhaven)
The best fishing on Long Island and half the distance to Montauk! You can catch Striped Bass, Tautog, Black Seabass, Scup (Porgy), Thresher Shark, Bluefin Tuna, and more.
5.0/5 (35 reviews)
Hampton Bays (29 min drive from Brookhaven)
If you’re in the market for a day to remember, look no further than Open Water Charters. Your guide for the day is Captain Brett, offering years of sportfishing experience.
"Captain Brett was the best. He was well prepared, gave us a couple different options and he helped teach my 6 year old son." — Scott,
"Captain Brett was the best. He was well prepared, gave us a couple different options and he helped teach my 6 year old son." — Scott,
Bay Shore (17.7 miles from Brookhaven)
Excited to go fishing in Bay Shore? Brady Boys Charters is your ticket! With Captain Michael at the helm, you'll benefit from years of knowledge and experience.
4.8/5 (40 reviews)
Babylon (33 min drive from Brookhaven)
15-20% tip is customary to the mate. Captree fishing charters aboard the Patty Ann offers fishing trips in and around Babylon, New York. The crew is made up of professional guides, who have won many tournaments throughout their careers.
"We went with Patty Charter last year and had such a positive experience that we went again this year!" — Melissa,
"We went with Patty Charter last year and had such a positive experience that we went again this year!" — Melissa,