Cayuga Fishing Charters

55 fishing charters

The best out of 55 charter fishing deals in Cayuga - enter dates to check availability

Loading...

Top Fishing Charters in Cayuga

Cayuga: 55 fishing charters available

Showing 1 - 10
Listing image
Loading...

33 ft

Up to 6 people

Whiskey Runner Charters – 33'

5.0/5 (9 reviews)
Cayuga
Captain Dan, owner of Whiskey Runner Charters has over 35 years of experience. He will provide you with an exciting and successful fishing trip! We offer the best in sport fishing on Cayuga Lake.

"It was my family’s first time on a charter and so glad we chose Whiskey Runner Charters!" —⁠ Philip,
Trips from
US $450
Trips from
US $450
Listing image
Loading...

18 ft

Up to 3 people

Fish Pimpin Guide Service LLC

5.0/5 (17 reviews)
Romulus (26 min drive from Cayuga)
Looking for a reasonably priced trip for 3 or less people? Then book a date or send me a message to get out on the water. I have over 30+ years of fishing experince, look forward to sharing the water and getting ya on some fish and having a fun time.

"My wife and I booked a charter on Cayuga Lake with Captain Steve and had an incredible experience." —⁠ Wiliam,
Trips from
US $200
Trips from
US $200

Angler's choice

Listing image
Loading...

24 ft

Up to 4 people

Locked With Lorensen - Cayuga & Otisco Lake

5.0/5 (24 reviews)
Romulus (24 min drive from Cayuga)
Locked with Lorensen is owned and operated by a local family man, Captain Ryan Lorensen, from the Oswego County area. He offers trips for any NYS freshwater species that you would like to target.

"We started out slow, no fish or bites for a few hours, with a..." —⁠ JAMES,
Trips from
US $400
Trips from
US $400
Listing image
Loading...

30 ft

Up to 4 people

Pulling Meat Fishing Charters

5.0/5 (1 review)
Union Springs (9 min drive from Cayuga)
Pulling Meat Fishing Charters is your ticket to the stunning waters of Cayuga Lake. Your guide for the day is Captain Mike, so you’ll benefit from years of angling experience.

"Captain Mike was awesome. Great with communication, ready to go when I arrived, got me on the fish quickly and would have limited out by 10:30 but I lost a nice Rainbow." —⁠ Richard,
Trips from
US $550
Trips from
US $550

Angler's choice

Listing image
Loading...

22 ft

Up to 4 people

Red Beard's Fishing – Cayuga Lake

5.0/5 (40 reviews)
Ithaca (22 min drive from Cayuga)
Red Beard’s Finger Lakes Charters invites you to experience the stunning waters of Long Point on Cayuga Lake. Having logged many hours on this lake, Captain Stanley can tell you all about the local fishery.

"Our party were four including my six-year-old grandson and his parents and myself." —⁠ Bill,
Trips from
US $450
Trips from
US $450
Listing image
Loading...

19 ft

Up to 2 people

Whiskey Runner 19’ Owasco Lake

Auburn (20 min drive from Cayuga)
If you're ready to enjoy fishing in Moravia, we've got you covered with Whiskey Runner Charters. Having logged many hours on these tides, Captain Daniel knows them forwards and back.
Trips from
US $450
Trips from
US $450
Listing image
Loading...

23 ft

Up to 4 people

Greatest Catch Fishing Charters

5.0/5 (5 reviews)
Auburn (18 min drive from Cayuga)
Make the most of your time in the Finger Lakes and go fishing with the Greatest Catch Fishing Charters. Having logged many hours on these lakes, Captain Captain Corey is prepared to put you on fish.

"Had an amazing time out on the lake with a very knowledgeable and professional Captain." —⁠ Angelica,
Trips from
US $425
Trips from
US $425
Listing image
Loading...

20 ft

Up to 4 people

Sich's Guide Service – Cayuga Lake

5.0/5 (23 reviews)
Ithaca (21 min drive from Cayuga)
Sich’s Guide Service runs fishing charters on Cayuga Lake in a 2021 starcraft fish master 196. One of the most stable and spacious platform in aluminum boats and the latest in technology gives us the edge while fishing in comfort.

"Capt Joe asked a lot of questions before the trip on what we’d like to do so knew what to expect." —⁠ Brian,
Trips from
US $550
Trips from
US $550

Angler's choice

Listing image
Loading...

31 ft

Up to 6 people

Screwy Louie's Fishing Charters

4.9/5 (90 reviews)
Fair Haven (48 min drive from Cayuga)
Screwy Louie’s Fishing Charters is based in Fair Haven, New York just a short ride west of Oswego. Launching out of Little Sodus Bay, the company takes anglers of all ages and skill levels to the beautiful waters of Lake Ontario.

"Took the hubby and two grown kids fishing on Lake Ontario. My goal was to create a great fishing memory." —⁠ Kristine,
Trips from
US $550
Trips from
US $550

Angler's choice

Listing image
Loading...

31 ft

Up to 6 people

LATER ON Charters

4.9/5 (83 reviews)
Oswego (59 min drive from Cayuga)
With calm seas and big fish, LATER ON Charters is an excellent choice for any Great Lake enthusiast. Launching out of Oswego in New York, you will be able to explore the stunning Lake Ontario from the comfort of your own boat.

"Unfortunately Jim was having some engine troubles on his boat." —⁠ Sean,
Trips from
US $700
Trips from
US $700

Top deep sea fishing trips in Cayuga

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...
Loading...
Loading...
Loading...
Loading...
Loading...

Top-rated family fishing trips in Cayuga

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...
Loading...
Loading...
Loading...
Loading...
Loading...

Half-day fishing trips in Cayuga

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...
Loading...
Loading...
Loading...
Loading...
Loading...

Top Targeted Species in Cayuga

Loading...Loading...Loading...Loading...Loading...Loading...

Top Types of Fishing in Cayuga

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...
Loading...
Loading...Loading...Loading...Loading...

Top Fishing Techniques in Cayuga

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...
Loading...
Loading...Loading...Loading...Loading...

Frequently Asked Questions about Fishing Charters in Cayuga

Loading
Loading

Frequently Asked Questions about Fishing Charters in Cayuga

Loading
Loading
Loading
Loading
Loading
Loading
Powered by AI

Fishing in Cayuga

Experience world-class angling on Cayuga Lake, the crown jewel of New York’s Finger Lakes region. This legendary destination boasts some of the most robust lake trout populations in the northeastern United States, with fish averaging 6–10 pounds and thrilling battles guaranteed. Beyond lakers, Cayuga’s diverse waters teem with trophy smallmouth bass fueled by round goby populations, hard-fighting landlocked Atlantic salmon, prolific rainbow trout, and aggressive brown trout.

Seasonal dynamics create year-round opportunities: target lake trout in northern sections during spring, while southern waters heat up with salmon and rainbow action. Summer brings explosive topwater bass strikes and unique fly-fishing challenges for longnose gar. Come fall, tributaries pulse with spawning salmon, and northern bays offer prime ice fishing for panfish and chain pickerel once winter sets in.

Your ideal Cayuga Fishing Charter combines local expertise with access to prime zones. Private charters navigate prime honey holes without crowded launches, leveraging decades of local knowledge. Modern boats equipped with advanced sonar and specialized trolling or jigging gear maximize your catch rates across Cayuga’s 40-mile expanse. From battling 8-pound rainbows to landing bass that anchor professional tournaments, every trip promises sore arms and bragging rights.

After reeling in your limit of trout or salmon, savor Finger Lakes scenery as your crew expertly cleans the day’s bounty. Whether you seek heart-pounding trophy pursuits or family-friendly panfish action, Cayuga Lake delivers unforgettable angling against a backdrop of rolling hills and pristine waters – no other destination matches its consistent world-class fishery.

Cayuga

5/5
Based on 29,545 reviews by FishingBooker anglers

Cayuga Fishing Calendar

Loading

Featured photos from Cayuga

What anglers said about fishing in Cayuga

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...
Loading...
Loading...Loading...Loading...Loading...

How did anglers rate fishing charters in Cayuga?

Loading...Loading...Loading...Loading...

Nearby Fishing Destinations

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...
Loading...