Geneva Fishing Charters
The best out of 41 charter fishing deals in Geneva - enter dates to check availability
Geneva Fishing Charters
Compare 41 captains, read reviews, and book in minutes
Showing 1 - 10
Show on mapAngler's Choice
24 ft
Up to 4 people
Locked With Lorensen - Cayuga & Otisco Lake
5.0
/5
(25 reviews)
Romulus (24 min drive from Geneva)
Locked with Lorensen is owned and operated by a local family man, Captain Ryan Lorensen, from the Oswego County area. He offers trips for any NYS freshwater species that you would like to target.
"We started out slow, no fish or bites for a few hours, with a..." — JAMES,
"We started out slow, no fish or bites for a few hours, with a..." — JAMES,
trips from
US $400
18 ft
Up to 3 people
Fish Pimpin Guide Service LLC
5.0
/5
(20 reviews)
Romulus (13.9 miles from Geneva)
Looking for a reasonably priced trip for 3 or less people in the finger lakes region? Then book a date or send me a message to get out on the water.
"My wife and I booked a charter on Cayuga Lake with Captain Steve and had an incredible experience." — Wiliam,
"My wife and I booked a charter on Cayuga Lake with Captain Steve and had an incredible experience." — Wiliam,
trips from
US $200
20 ft
Up to 2 people
Ethan Carr Guiding – Cayuga Lake
Union Springs (14.7 miles from Geneva)
LIMITED DATES LEFT Ethan Carr Guiding delivers premier guided fishing experiences on Cayuga Lake, one of New York’s most renowned Largemouth and Smallmouth Bass fisheries.
trips from
US $450
Angler's Choice
21 ft
Up to 4 people
Red Beard's Fishing – Cayuga Lake
4.9
/5
(42 reviews)
Ithaca (17.6 miles from Geneva)
Red Beard's Finger Lakes Charters invites you to experience the stunning waters of Cayuga Lake. Having logged many hours on this lake, Captain Stan can tell you all about the local fishery.
"Our party were four including my six-year-old grandson and his parents and myself." — Bill,
"Our party were four including my six-year-old grandson and his parents and myself." — Bill,
trips from
US $450
21 ft
Up to 4 people
Zack Eggleston Guide Sevice – Cayuga
Union Springs (14.8 miles from Geneva)
Make some memories on Cayuga Lake and go fishing with Zack Eggleston Guide Service. Having logged many hours on New York lakes Captain Zack is prepared to put you on fish.
trips from
US $450
30 ft
Up to 4 people
Pulling Meat Fishing Charters
5.0
/5
(1 review)
Union Springs (39 min drive from Geneva)
Pulling Meat Fishing Charters is your ticket to the stunning waters of Cayuga Lake. Your guide for the day is Captain Mike, so you'll benefit from years of angling experience.
"Captain Mike was awesome. Great with communication, ready to go when I arrived, got me on the fish quickly and would have limited out by 10:30 but I lost a nice Rainbow." — Richard,
"Captain Mike was awesome. Great with communication, ready to go when I arrived, got me on the fish quickly and would have limited out by 10:30 but I lost a nice Rainbow." — Richard,
trips from
US $550
20 ft
Up to 4 people
Sich's Guide Service – Cayuga Lake
5.0
/5
(23 reviews)
Ithaca (51 min drive from Geneva)
Sich's Guide Service runs fishing charters on Cayuga Lake in a 2021 starcraft fish master 196. One of the most stable and spacious platform in aluminum boats and the latest in technology gives us the edge while fishing in comfort.
"Capt Joe asked a lot of questions before the trip on what we’d like to do so knew what to expect." — Brian,
"Capt Joe asked a lot of questions before the trip on what we’d like to do so knew what to expect." — Brian,
trips from
US $550
21 ft
Up to 5 people
Reel Naturalz Charters – Cayuga Lake
5.0
/5
(3 reviews)
Romulus (24 min drive from Geneva)
Spend the day with Reel Naturalz Charters, and let them show you what makes fishing on Cayuga Lake so memorable! With Captain Jason at the helm, you'll have a knowledgeable and experienced guide.
"Jason is an amazing Captain with the knowledge and determination to make sure your trip doesn’t get skunked." — Marco, PA
"Jason is an amazing Captain with the knowledge and determination to make sure your trip doesn’t get skunked." — Marco, PA
trips from
US $625
33 ft
Up to 6 people
Blackjaw Bandit Sportfishing
4.8
/5
(13 reviews)
Wolcott (45 min drive from Geneva)
Cast for rods into Lake Ontario for epic freshwater fishing aboard “Blackjaw Bandit Sportfishing”! Whether you're a novice or a pro, Captain Jim Dennis gets you on top of Brown Trout, Chinook Salmon, Coho Salmon, and Rainbow Trout! Your
"We had an excellent time captain was great and we brought home a lot of fish!" — Harley,
"We had an excellent time captain was great and we brought home a lot of fish!" — Harley,
trips from
US $650
23 ft
Up to 4 people
Dry Creek Charters
5.0
/5
(1 review)
Wolcott (27.3 miles from Geneva)
Spend the day with Dry Creek Charters and find out what fishing Lake Ontario is all about! Depending on the season, you might hook into Chinook Salmon, Atlantic Salmon, Coho Salmon, Brown Trout, Lake Trout, Rainbow Trout (Steelhead), and who knows what el
"5 Stars! Captain Chris was fantastic—extremely knowledgeable, helpful, and an all-around great guy." — Christian,
"5 Stars! Captain Chris was fantastic—extremely knowledgeable, helpful, and an all-around great guy." — Christian,
trips from
US $500