Ithaca Fishing Charters

The best out of 21 charter fishing deals in Ithaca - enter dates to check availability

Ithaca: 21 fishing charters available

Showing 1 - 10

Angler's choice

Listing image

22 ft

Up to 4 people

Red Beard's Fishing – Cayuga Lake

5.0/5 (28 reviews)
Ithaca
Red Beard’s Finger Lakes Charters invites you to experience the stunning waters of Long Point on Cayuga Lake. Having logged many hours on this lake, Captain Stanley can tell you all about the local fishery.

"Captain Stan was friendly, patient, and knowledgeable. We had only modest luck but he worked very hard to get fish on our lines and was clearly committed to delivering a good experience." —⁠ Diane,
Trips from
US $450
Listing image

20 ft

Up to 4 people

Sich's Guide Service – Cayuga Lake

5.0/5 (22 reviews)
Ithaca
Sich’s Guide Service runs fishing charters on Cayuga Lake in a 2021 starcraft fish master 196. One of the most stable and spacious platform in aluminum boats and the latest in technology gives us the edge while fishing in comfort.

"Captain Joe was professional, competent, and friendly. He communicated well ahead of time and most importantly, he got us on the fish." —⁠ T.j.,
Trips from
US $550

Angler's choice

Listing image

16 ft

Up to 2 people

Red Beard's Cayuga Lake Ice Out

5.0/5 (2 reviews)
Ithaca
Hoping to cast a line in Ithaca? Then Red Beard’s Finger Lakes Charters has a trip with your name on it! With Captain Stanley at the helm, you’ll have a knowledgeable and experienced guide.

"Stan was a terrific guide and great conversation on Cayuga. We got a pretty good haul of fish too." —⁠ Ben,
Trips from
US $300
Listing image

18 ft

Up to 3 people

Healy Outdoors – Cayuga Trout Charter

Ithaca
Hoping to cast a line in Ithaca? Healy Outdoors is here to make it happen! Depending on the time of year, you might hook into Atlantic Salmon, Brown Trout, Lake Trout, Rainbow Trout (Steelhead), and anything else that bites.
Trips from
US $400
Listing image

18 ft

Up to 2 people

Jigging Charters With FLX Fish

Ithaca
We offer jigging and casting charters for Lake Trout, Rainbows, Browns and Landlocked Salmon We also offer Perch fishing charters in the spring and fall when the Perch are thick! 2-3 people are allowed, but 2 are recomended due to space and seating.
Trips from
US $400
Listing image

25 ft

Up to 5 people

FLX Fishing

4.9/5 (3 reviews)
Ithaca
Make some memories on Cayuga Lake and go fishing with FLX Fishing. Captain Mike will be your guide, allowing you to benefit from years of Trout fishing experience.

"This weekend we went fishing on this boat with the most positive captain!" —⁠ Alena, NY
Trips from
US $450

Angler's choice

Listing image

24 ft

Up to 4 people

Locked With Lorensen - Cayuga & Otisco Lake

5.0/5 (21 reviews)
Romulus (33 min drive from Ithaca)
Locked with Lorensen is owned and operated by a local family man, Captain Ryan Lorensen, from the Oswego County area. He offers trips for any NYS freshwater species that you would like to target.

"We started out slow, no fish or bites for a few hours, with a..." —⁠ JAMES,
Trips from
US $400
Listing image

18 ft

Up to 3 people

Fish Pimpin Guide Service LLC

5.0/5 (4 reviews)
Romulus (34 min drive from Ithaca)
Looking for a reasonably priced trip for 3 or less people? Then book a date or send me a message to get out on the water. I have over 30 years of fishing experince, look forward to sharing the water and getting ya on some fish.

"My son and I traveled from MD to Cayuga lake near Ithaca to fish before we headed over to Cooperstown for a baseball tournament." —⁠ Tim,
Trips from
US $200
Listing image

33 ft

Up to 6 people

Whiskey Runner Charters – 33'

5.0/5 (5 reviews)
Cayuga (49 min drive from Ithaca)
Captain Dan, owner of Whiskey Runner Charters has over 35 years of experience. He will provide you with an exciting and successful fishing trip! We offer the best in sport fishing on Cayuga Lake.

"I managed to choose a cold rainy day to troll for trout on Cayuga Lake." —⁠ Peter,
Trips from
US $450

Angler's choice

Listing image

20 ft

Up to 4 people

Red Beard's Fishing – Skaneateles Lake

5.0/5 (2 reviews)
Homer (46 min drive from Ithaca)
Make some memories in Homer and go fishing with Red Beard’s Finger Lakes Charters. Captain Stanley will be your guide, bringing aboard years of sportfishing experience.

"We had an amazing day with Captain Redbeard! We caught a slew of perch and bass, and we also enjoyed swimming off the boat." —⁠ Brandy,
Trips from
US $449

Frequently Asked Questions about Fishing Charters in Ithaca

What are the best private fishing charters in Ithaca?

According to customer reviews, some of the most popular fishing charters in Ithaca, New York are:

How much does it cost to go charter fishing in Ithaca?

The average Ithaca fishing trip price for a 4 hour private trip is US $482 based on prices on FishingBooker.com.

Which fishing charters in Ithaca are good for families?

Fishing charters in Ithaca that received great reviews from families are:

What are the top fish species I can catch in Ithaca?

The top 3 fish species targeted on guided fishing trips in Ithaca are:

What are the top fishing techniques in Ithaca?

The top 3 fishing techniques in Ithaca are:

What are the top types of fishing in Ithaca?

The top type of fishing in Ithaca is:

Do Ithaca fishing charters provide rods, reels and tackle?

Many fishing charters in Ithaca provide rods, reels and tackle. Some of the top rated are:

Who are the best rated captains in Ithaca?

According to customer reviews on FishingBooker.com, some of the best rated charter captains in Ithaca are:

Who are the top awarded captains in Ithaca?

Who are the top awarded captains in Ithaca?

What fishing trips are offered by fishing charters in Ithaca?

Some of the fishing trips offered by fishing charters in Ithaca are:

  • 4-hour fishing trips – US $433
  • 5-hour fishing trips – US $489
  • 6-hour fishing trips – US $500
Powered by AI

Fishing in Ithaca

Discover the angling paradise of Ithaca, nestled in the heart of New York's breathtaking Finger Lakes region. Ithaca fishing charters offer unparalleled access to the pristine waters of Cayuga Lake, one of the region's true gems known for its healthy baitfish population and trophy catches.

Cayuga Lake, the centerpiece of Ithaca's fishing scene, delivers exceptional year-round fishing opportunities. Anglers can target a variety of prized species including Lake Trout, Brown Trout, Rainbow Trout, and the coveted Landlocked Atlantic Salmon. The lake's trout typically range from 2-8 pounds, while Lake Trout often average an impressive 6-10 pounds.

Professional guides in Ithaca employ various effective techniques to maximize your success on the water. Trolling with multi-rod spreads using lead-core lines, planer boards, dipsy divers, and downriggers proves consistently productive. For a more active experience, vertical jigging with light tackle spinning outfits offers an exciting way to target Lake Trout.

Morning charters are particularly productive, setting out at sunrise when fish are most active. An average outing yields dozens of bites, often resulting in the satisfying "problem" of sore arms from reeling in so many fish. With experienced captains who've logged countless hours on these waters, you'll benefit from local knowledge that puts you directly on the fish.

Whether you're a seasoned angler seeking trophy catches or a family looking for a memorable day on the water, Ithaca fishing charters deliver exceptional experiences in a stunning natural setting. The combination of abundant fish, knowledgeable guides, and the breathtaking backdrop of the Finger Lakes region makes Ithaca an ideal destination for your next fishing adventure.

Ithaca

4.9/5
Based on 29,146 reviews by FishingBooker anglers

What anglers said about fishing in Ithaca

Conditions are very weather sensitive. Captain changed our meeting location due to northern winds. It paid in spades. Wind has a big affect on water temperature and fish locations
5.0/5
Conditions are very weather sensitive. Captain changed our meeting location due to northern winds. It paid in spades. Wind has a big affect on water temperature and fish locations
Mark R.
Mark R.
I found the lake a little overwhelming to kayak in, Cayuga, at least the first visit, I think taking a charter and getting a little local knowledge is a nice way to get started.
5.0/5
I found the lake a little overwhelming to kayak in, Cayuga, at least the first visit, I think taking a charter and getting a little local knowledge is a nice way to get started.
Alric V. G.
Alric V. G.

How did anglers rate fishing charters in Ithaca?

Red Beard's Fishing – Cayuga Lake
Red Beard's Fishing – Cayuga Lake
Fishing charter in Ithaca
5.0/5
Captain Stan was friendly, patient, and knowledgeable. We had only modest luck but he worked very hard to get fish on our lines and was clearly committed to delivering a good experience. He has equipment for a variety of techniques and was quick and helpful with guidance and tips. Would definitely recommend!
Diane W.
Diane W.
Red Beard's Fishing – Cayuga Lake
Red Beard's Fishing – Cayuga Lake
Fishing charter in Ithaca
5.0/5
Great time ! Tons of fish caught and great captain and equipment! Would definitely book again!
Arlene P.
Arlene P.
Red Beard's Fishing – Cayuga Lake
Red Beard's Fishing – Cayuga Lake
Fishing charter in Ithaca
5.0/5
Captain Stanley knows where and how to catch fishes. He is very friendly and my friends and I had greater time fishing with him. We caught big lake trout and keeper size rainbow trout, we were all so happy with our trip! Highly recommended for anyone interested in a fishing tour around the finger lakes region
Fan X.
Fan X.
Sich's Guide Service – Cayuga Lake
Sich's Guide Service – Cayuga Lake
Fishing charter in Ithaca
5.0/5
Captain Joe was professional, competent, and friendly. He communicated well ahead of time and most importantly, he got us on the fish. I would definitely use him again.
T.j. L.
T.j. L.
Red Beard's Fishing – Cayuga Lake
Red Beard's Fishing – Cayuga Lake
Fishing charter in Ithaca
5.0/5
We had a great time fishing. We had perfect conditions, Stan was very nice and we caught some huge fish. Well worth it, if we come back to the area we will be doing this again!
Brandon W.
Brandon W.
Sich's Guide Service – Cayuga Lake
Sich's Guide Service – Cayuga Lake
Fishing charter in Ithaca
5.0/5
Capt Joe asked a lot of questions before the trip on what we’d like to do so knew what to expect. We had to move around the lake a bit due to some bad weather and changes to fish patterns. We eventually found the fish - as promised! Captain Joe definitely knows how to find the fish. Especially good for experienced fisherman!
Brian O.
Brian O.
Red Beard's Fishing – Cayuga Lake
Red Beard's Fishing – Cayuga Lake
Fishing charter in Ithaca
5.0/5
Capt. Stan knows how to find fish and make fishing fun definitely recommend especially if you normally don’t catch fish!
Laurance M.
Laurance M.
Red Beard's Fishing – Cayuga Lake
Red Beard's Fishing – Cayuga Lake
Fishing charter in Ithaca
5.0/5
Captain Stanley was great. Very attentive to our 14-year-old son who is an angler in the making. He was very professional and courteous. We are definitely booking again when we return to Lake Cayuga!
Tanya M.
Tanya M.
Red Beard's Fishing – Cayuga Lake
Red Beard's Fishing – Cayuga Lake
Fishing charter in Ithaca
5.0/5
AWESOME!! Great trip, Captain Stan was Great!! Caught beautiful lake trout and 1 rainbow trout!!
Debra K.
Debra K.
Red Beard's Fishing – Cayuga Lake
Red Beard's Fishing – Cayuga Lake
Fishing charter in Ithaca
5.0/5
Capt. Stan took my family and I out for sone trout. We were able to land 4 decent size fish. Capt Stan was knowledgeable, friendly and had patience with us amateur anglers.. I will call him for my next trip
Hector C.
Hector C.
Red Beard's Fishing – Cayuga Lake
Red Beard's Fishing – Cayuga Lake
Fishing charter in Ithaca
5.0/5
Had a great experience fishing Lake Cayuga on the afternoon of Aug. 17, catching four keepers (three lake trout and a beautiful rainbow) and smaller rainbows and landlocked salmon. Captain Stanley was great company, very patient guiding us through our first experience with a downrigger and full of useful information about local fishing opportunities. Highly recommended! Eric and Max Schaeffer, Jesse Kenworthy, visiting from Takoma Park, MD.
Eric S.
Eric S.
Red Beard's Fishing – Cayuga Lake
Red Beard's Fishing – Cayuga Lake
Fishing charter in Ithaca
5.0/5
Easy going relaxed atmosphere! Great boat and VERY knowledgeable Capt. Tell him what your looking for and he will bring you there. Want to learn? He's an open book! Price? He's worth A LOT more than what he charges! HAPPY DAYS!
KENNETH L.
KENNETH L.
Red Beard's Fishing – Cayuga Lake
Red Beard's Fishing – Cayuga Lake
Fishing charter in Ithaca
5.0/5
Captain Stan knows the lake very well and more importantly we caught several good size fish! Would recommend 100%!!!
Beata K.
Beata K.
Red Beard's Fishing – Cayuga Lake
Red Beard's Fishing – Cayuga Lake
Fishing charter in Ithaca
5.0/5
We caught over 20 fish including salmon, rainbow trout and lake trout. Captain Stanley was very knowledgeable and experienced, we had a great time and learnt alot from him and his crew!
Chui-Inn L.
Chui-Inn L.
Red Beard's Fishing – Cayuga Lake
Red Beard's Fishing – Cayuga Lake
Fishing charter in Ithaca
4.0/5
We spent five hours on Owasco lake jigging for trout. Captain Stan and his crew were really helpful showing us what to do and when. Although the catch was not great the overall experience was fantastic.
Jakob W.
Jakob W.
Sich's Guide Service – Cayuga Lake
Sich's Guide Service – Cayuga Lake
Fishing charter in Ithaca
5.0/5
Our family of four went out on Cayuga and had a great time. Captain Sich met us promptly at the launch and got us on some fish. We all caught a mix of lake and rainbow trout. We’d definitely recommend his charter.
Randy S.
Randy S.
Red Beard's Fishing – Cayuga Lake
Red Beard's Fishing – Cayuga Lake
Fishing charter in Ithaca
4.7/5
Fish were there and didn’t want to cooperate. Captain Stan tried to get things going. We had multiple fish follow lures on the graph while jigging and not take it. Capt worked hard today and we couldn’t get them going. Good reviews are easy when the fish are biting. We had a great time and will reach out again.
Josh S.
Josh S.
Sich's Guide Service – Cayuga Lake
Sich's Guide Service – Cayuga Lake
Fishing charter in Ithaca
5.0/5
Amazing morning on Cayuga lake. No sooner than captain Joe set the first line and a hit. Lakers galore. Started shooting for rainbows, Got them. Highly recommend Sich's Guide Service for your year round Central New York fishing quests. Great morning!
Mark R.
Mark R.
Sich's Guide Service – Cayuga Lake
Sich's Guide Service – Cayuga Lake
Fishing charter in Ithaca
5.0/5
Captain Joe was awesome. He knew exactly how and where to find what we were fishing for. He was friendly and very knowledgeable.
Chandra H.
Chandra H.
Sich's Guide Service – Cayuga Lake
Sich's Guide Service – Cayuga Lake
Fishing charter in Ithaca
5.0/5
We fished Cayuga for lake trout. Captain Joe put us on tons of great fish and we had an awesome time even with the 90°+ temps! Highly recommend booking with him, and we can’t wait to book again in the future!
Kimberly B.
Kimberly B.