Mayville Fishing Charters
The best out of 65 charter fishing deals in Mayville - enter dates to check availability
Mayville Fishing Charters
Compare 65 captains, read reviews, and book in minutes

Showing 1 - 10
Show on map
28 ft
up to 5
Limit Takers Sportfishing
5.0
/5
(3 reviews)
Westfield (7.7 miles from Mayville)
Ready to cast a line in Westfield? Then, Limit Takers Sportfishing has a trip with your name on it! Your guide for the day is Captain Brayden, bringing years of professional experience aboard.
"Went out at 2pm and had a couple hours of fun before we all limited out." — Lucas, New York
"Went out at 2pm and had a couple hours of fun before we all limited out." — Lucas, New York
trips from
US $500

20 ft
up to 4
Fishing With Dad, LLC
Just listed
Willow Brook (7.3 miles from Mayville)
Welcome to Fishing With Dad your premier choice for Crappie fishing on Chautauqua Lake, tucked away in beautiful western NY.
trips from
US $300

up to 3
Streamside Angling Guide Service
Just added to our fleet
Westfield (7.6 miles from Mayville)
Make that daydream about fishing in Western New York a reality with Streamside Angling! Around here you can fish in local lakes and streams, including a few honeyholes that only the locals can clue you in on.
"Brayden was very knowledgeable and professional and he was wonderful with my 11yr old son." — Laura,
"Brayden was very knowledgeable and professional and he was wonderful with my 11yr old son." — Laura,
trips from
US $325

19 ft
up to 3
Spooled Up Charters
Westfield (7.6 miles from Mayville)
If you're ready to catch fish we've got you covered with Spooled Up Charters. Fishing from a few ports allows us to be on the fish, Westfield, Dunkirk and also Sunset Bay (Hanover launch).
trips from
US $350
Angler's Choice

28 ft
up to 5
Big Bad Wolf Fishing Charter
5.0
/5
(13 reviews)
Erie (30.2 miles from Mayville)
If you're ready to enjoy fishing in Erie, look no further than Big Bad Wolf Fishing Charter.
"Captain Herman delivered a perfect lake Erie walleye trip. Not only did he put us on the fish, he shared the knowledge he has gathered through the years and allowed us to handle his gear as much as we were comfortable with." — Benjamin,
"Captain Herman delivered a perfect lake Erie walleye trip. Not only did he put us on the fish, he shared the knowledge he has gathered through the years and allowed us to handle his gear as much as we were comfortable with." — Benjamin,
trips from
US $450

25 ft
up to 4
Rockin Reels Adventures
4.9
/5
(4 reviews)
North East (14.8 miles from Mayville)
We are a locally owned and operated professional charter service located conveniently in North East Marina. We offer 6 hour or until limits Walleye trips.
"Had a great trip with Aaron. We caught our limit of Walleye!" — Don,
"Had a great trip with Aaron. We caught our limit of Walleye!" — Don,
trips from
US $450

30 ft
up to 6
Westfield Charters, Inc.
5.0
/5
(72 reviews)
Westfield (7.7 miles from Mayville)
Everyone is welcome aboard Westfield Charters Inc. for a fun-filled fishing experience. Discover Lake Erie's thrilling fishing opportunities aboard a boat especially-designed to cater to people with disabilities.
"Captain Rick and his team were easy to work with and friendly throughout." — James,
"Captain Rick and his team were easy to work with and friendly throughout." — James,
trips from
US $450

22 ft
up to 4
Worth The Catch Charters – Chautauqua Lake
5.0
/5
(9 reviews)
Willow Brook (7.3 miles from Mayville)
Jamie Worth invites you to experience the stunning waters of Chautauqua Lake. Captain Jamie, with years of local experience, will be your guide for the day.
"had a great day of fishing with captain Jaime" — Jeff,
"had a great day of fishing with captain Jaime" — Jeff,
trips from
US $450

27 ft
up to 6
Bulldog Fishing Charters
5.0
/5
(5 reviews)
North East (14.8 miles from Mayville)
Bulldog Fishing Charters invites you to experience the stunning waters of North East. Captain Steve will be your guide, which means you'll tap into their local experience.
"Fabulous trip! Lifelong fisherman but i had never even seen a Lake Trout in person." — Dale, PA
"Fabulous trip! Lifelong fisherman but i had never even seen a Lake Trout in person." — Dale, PA
trips from
US $300

22 ft
up to 4
Mark Lorenc Charters LLC
4.9
/5
(29 reviews)
Dunkirk (18.3 miles from Mayville)
Mark Lorenc Charters offers seasonal trips for trophy fish in Lake Erie, departing from Dunkirk, New York. The captain moves his boat so you will be able to catch the most active trophy gamefish on the eastern-end waters of Lake Erie.
"This was an excellent trip in every aspect. 2 out of 3 of us are new ” fishers”." — Cathy, Pennsylvania
"This was an excellent trip in every aspect. 2 out of 3 of us are new ” fishers”." — Cathy, Pennsylvania
trips from
US $400