New Church Fishing Charters
The best out of 74 charter fishing deals in New Church - enter dates to check availability
New Church Fishing Charters
Compare 74 captains, read reviews, and book in minutes
Showing 1 - 10
Show on map
36 ft
Up to 6 people
Salt Addict – Angler Management
5.0
/5
(17 reviews)
Chincoteague (26 min drive from New Church)
Salt Addict is all about fishing the stunning waters of Chincoteague. Having logged many hours on these tides, Captain Bruce is prepared to put you on fish.
"Our day was better than we could have imagined. Capt Bruce is accommodating and nice as can be!" — Victoria,
"Our day was better than we could have imagined. Capt Bruce is accommodating and nice as can be!" — Victoria,
trips from
US $600
21 ft
Up to 4 people
Reed and Reel Fishing Company
4.9
/5
(20 reviews)
Chincoteague (8.6 miles from New Church)
If you're ready to start fishing in Chincoteague, book a trip with Reed and Reel Fishing Company. Having logged many hours on these tides, Captain William can tell you all about the local fishery.
"Billy really knows where the fish are! We started in the morning catch catching black drum in an inlet." — John, United States
"Billy really knows where the fish are! We started in the morning catch catching black drum in an inlet." — John, United States
trips from
US $250
Angler's Choice
25 ft
Up to 4 people
Shore Chaos Charters
5.0
/5
(60 reviews)
Chincoteague (19 min drive from New Church)
Book your next trip with Shore Chaos Charters and find out what makes the fishing in Chincoteague so unique. With Captain James at the helm, you're in knowledgeable and experienced hands.
"I had a trip with Shore Chaos on 4/17/26. We wanted to target flounder and the cpt said no problem." — Ron,
"I had a trip with Shore Chaos on 4/17/26. We wanted to target flounder and the cpt said no problem." — Ron,
trips from
US $250
Angler's Choice
28 ft
Up to 6 people
Reel Freedom Charters LLC
5.0
/5
(63 reviews)
Chincoteague (25 min drive from New Church)
Book your next trip with Reel Freedom Charters and find out what you're missing in Chincoteague.
"Captain Rob was superb. Tackle ready, friendly, and made the trip fun for all." — Jeff,
"Captain Rob was superb. Tackle ready, friendly, and made the trip fun for all." — Jeff,
trips from
US $400
24 ft
Up to 6 people
Salt Addict – Bottom Bouncer
5.0
/5
(22 reviews)
Chincoteague (26 min drive from New Church)
If you're in the market for a day to remember, look no further than Salt Addict. Your guide for the day is Captain Bruce, which allows you to benefit from years of sportfishing experience.
"Bruce and the Salt Addict were fantastic! We journeyed out about 3 miles into the Atlantic Ocean and fished on top of these sunken subway cars that had a plethora of fish." — Simon,
"Bruce and the Salt Addict were fantastic! We journeyed out about 3 miles into the Atlantic Ocean and fished on top of these sunken subway cars that had a plethora of fish." — Simon,
trips from
US $300
24 ft
Up to 6 people
Ashlyn Jewel Charters
4.9
/5
(26 reviews)
Chincoteague (25 min drive from New Church)
There's a fish with your name on it in Chincoteague and Ashlyn Jewel Charters will help you catch it! You're likely to fish for Blacktip Shark, Black Seabass, Whiting, Weakfish, Flounder, Skate, Bull Shark, Hammerhead Shark, and more, depending
"I 100% recommend Ashlyn Jewel Charters. Captain Todd was amazing." — Rebecca,
"I 100% recommend Ashlyn Jewel Charters. Captain Todd was amazing." — Rebecca,
trips from
US $300
24 ft
Up to 6 people
Captain Pete's Fish Tales
4.9
/5
(481 reviews)
Chincoteague (26 min drive from New Church)
Sign up with Captain Pete's Fish Tales if you're looking for an unforgettable angling adventure out of Chincoteague Island. Captain Pete Wallace has been fishing here for more than 25 years and knows these waters like the back of his hand.
"Just got back from a fishing trip and it was truly an incredible experience for the whole family!" — Joshua,
"Just got back from a fishing trip and it was truly an incredible experience for the whole family!" — Joshua,
trips from
US $325
22 ft
Up to 3 people
JM Charters
Chincoteague (8.7 miles from New Church)
JM Charters is a light tackle fishing charter that operates in the seaside bays of Virginia. From mid-March through May, we target Flounder and Black Drum in the Wachapreague and Quinby areas of the seaside bays and inlets.
trips from
US $350
21 ft
Up to 4 people
Reel Adventures
4.8
/5
(9 reviews)
Chincoteague (24 min drive from New Church)
Captain Joe Truitt is a fully licensed and insured fishing guide serving the Eastern Shore of Maryland and Virginia. He has been fishing the Eastern Shore for over 40 years. Our boat is trailered so we can move with the fish and the seasons.
"Joe was great! he did everything he could to accommodate us and our fishing efforts we didn’t do as well as we expected." — Steven,
"Joe was great! he did everything he could to accommodate us and our fishing efforts we didn’t do as well as we expected." — Steven,
trips from
US $300
Angler's Choice
22 ft
Up to 6 people
Captain Tim's Chincoteague Bay Adventures
4.9
/5
(458 reviews)
Chincoteague (27 min drive from New Church)
Chincoteague Bay Adventures offers customizable and affordable family fun fishing trips to serve any angler's need.
"If you’re looking for a memorable fishing experience on Chincoteague, look no further than Capt." — Gene,
"If you’re looking for a memorable fishing experience on Chincoteague, look no further than Capt." — Gene,
trips from
US $209