We had an excellent time out fishing with Captain Lou. He was really helpful and his boat was great. We were catching fish the whole time… caught enough fluke and porgies to make a delicious dinner! Will definitely book again for a future trip and would recommend highly.

Captains Jack and Ray (father and son) run a great trip. Experienced locals who go out of their way to make you feel welcome. We caught a bunch of fish and had a great time doing it. This is THE boat to charter in Montauk.

Had such a great experience on crunch time sports. Captain TJ and Dave were fun to hang with. They gave my family a great time and we caught so many fish.

Had an phenomenal time with Captain TJ and his First Mate, From experienced Fishers to beginners I can guarantee you will have a great time and an experience you will remember. Definitely learned some new techniques along the way. I will definitely be booking with Crunch Time Again.

This was our 2nd year booking Capt TJ and it was another great experience. The crew is first rate and the boat is well equipped and spacious. TJ was excellent and very patient and helpful with my 11-yr-old nephew, and Capt Dave found all the perfect spots to fish. We’ll see you again next year, thanks for an awesome day!

We did a half day tour with TJ and Dave. The weather conditions weren’t great, but TJ and Dave worked really hard to find fish and we ended up getting a lot - sea bass, blue fish and porgies. We had 3 young boys with us -ages 10 to 13 and TJ and Dave were very patient and kind. A great time was had by all. I highly recommend this charter!

It was a day for the ages! Maybe caught 200+ porgies and sea bass. Incredible day. Crew was fun, funny, and all about making this day the best. Kids had a blast. Caught 20 fish a piece. Captain TJ is the man.

Great day on the water. Captain Dave put us on the fish and first mate Mike took great care of us. Looking forward to getting back out with this crew.

John and Kelly were an absolute pleasure to be fishing with. They communicated weather conditions before the trip and made sure we maximized our options. Plus we learned how to process our fish. We would go out on the ocean with them again without a doubt!

Great day with Mike and Jim. They were patient and knowledgeable and put us on the fish. They were patient with our kids and showed everyone a great time. Thanks again and we’re looking forward to another trip next year!

Been fishing for 50 years. This guy Bert is a very good captain. I highly recommend!!! His mate Joe took care of our group especially the 6 and 8 year old boys!!!

This is truly a motivated and driven Captain who really cares that his clients have a productive and great time. He and his mate are second to none.

Great morning on the water. Captain Pete and 1st mate Brandon made the trip memorable with plenty of fights!

Fishing with Jim McSwigin and his mate Brian was a blast! There were five of us who were older males, a female, and young child. We all had a great experience with Jim McSwigin and would recommend the trip to the experienced and inexperienced angler. Thank you, Jim, for a great day we have already marked our Calendar for July 2024. Do yourself a favor and book a trip with Jim McSwigin I promise you will not be disappointed.

Mike took us up to Block Island. Well worth the distance. once the lines were in the water we were non stop fish on for 3 straight hours. Nice big boat and first mate Jim was such a nice guy. Can't wait til next time. Highly recommended.

This was an excellent experience captain and crew were amazing really made this a memorable time for us. Will always book with them and nobody else.

Just a fantastic trip with these guys, we caught what they told us were going to catch, constant action durring the half day trip. My go to from now on. These guys know their stuff.

Couldn't have scripted a better day. Weather was perfect with calm seas. Captain and mate were accomodating and friendly. Put us on the fish for action all day. The kids came home with smiles and stories. Came home with plenty of meat. We will definitely be back.

Three adults and two boys 11 and 13. Everyone had a ball. They put us on the fish first time. They were super good tempered and made sure everyone knew what they were doing and had a great time.

Great day on the water! Caught lots of fish, many keepers, and even a shark. Captain and mate were both helpful and funny. This was our second year with the Captain and look forward to next year. Thanks, Captain.