Captain
Michael Sisto

Member since November 2018 Marathon, United States
Background
Growing up with a captain for a father, Captain Michael was always on the water. He began as a first mate and worked his way up to being a full-time captain in 2008. Having spent summers in New Jersey and his winters in the Florida Keys, he relocated permanently to run his business out of Marathon, FL.

Hey, I'm Captain Michael Sisto

Marathon, United States
Background
Growing up with a captain for a father, Captain Michael was always on the water. He began as a first mate and worked his way up to being a full-time captain in 2008. Having spent summers in New Jersey and his winters in the Florida Keys, he relocated permanently to run his business out of Marathon, FL.
Anglers Choice
Verified

My Charter Listing

Jersey Key Charters

17 reviews
Marathon
 Instant Confirmation
trips from $650

Fishing Reports

Salfish showing up

November 01, 2019

Last 3 weeks we started catching some Sailfish. Also been catching Blackfin tuna, few mahi, and lots of snappers on the reef. Read Full Report →


Still caching Mahi!

September 27, 2019

Caught snappers and mahi on a 6 hour afternoon. Read Full Report →


Tuna, tuna, tuna.

September 21, 2019

Blackfin tuna bite was on fire! Read Full Report →


Big MAHI MAHI today

September 08, 2019

Lots of big fish around today! Amazing fishing in Marathon! Read Full Report →


Mahi Slay Day!

September 02, 2019

Just one of those days. Fish were biting!!! Read Full Report →


Mahi, tuna, snapper!!!!

August 27, 2019

Slammer Mahi, jigging tuna, and Mangroves on the reef! As good as it gets!!! Read Full Report →


Limit of Mahi!

August 23, 2019

Excellent fishing. Mahi and snapper!!! Read Full Report →


The mahi bite continues!

August 22, 2019

Caught 1 slammer, few gaffers, and schoolies. A few snappers also. Great day Read Full Report →


Excellent Mahi fishing!

August 10, 2019

All you can handle today!! Read Full Report →


Mahi and big Mangroves

July 30, 2019

Non stop action on 4 hour afternoon! Read Full Report →


Mahi’s and snappers!!!

July 26, 2019

Everything was biting this afternoon!! Read Full Report →


Mahi and yellow

July 05, 2019

Another beutiful day with good action Read Full Report →


Mahi and Tripletail

July 02, 2019

Excellent Fishing all around!! Read Full Report →


Yellowtails on the reef

June 28, 2019

Red hot yellowtail bite! 4 hours of non stop action. Read Full Report →


Non stop mahi fishing

June 26, 2019

Another beutiful day and great fishing. Read Full Report →


Great Mahi Day!

June 24, 2019

All the mahi you could handle today!! Read Full Report →


Big tunas and mahi

June 22, 2019

Great afternoon with blackfin tuna and mahi. Read Full Report →


Mahi mahi

June 22, 2019

4 hours of great weather and great fishing! Read Full Report →


Yellowtails and cero mackeral

June 21, 2019

Fun morning on the reef! Read Full Report →


Mahi on fly rod!

June 13, 2019

Another beutiful day in Marathon. Bunch of mahi offshore and then grouper and snapper inshore. Read Full Report →


Mahi, goliath grouper, and snapper!

June 07, 2019

Great weather, great fishing!!! Father son trip crushed mahi, then caught snapper and grouper on reef! Read Full Report →


Deep drop trip

June 03, 2019

Snowy grouper , tilefish, and a bunch of mahi!! Always fun dropping baits in the deep water! Read Full Report →


Big Mahi and tilefish

May 15, 2019

Caught tile fish deep dropping then caught about 20 mahi including a 40# BULL!! Read Full Report →


Reef Trip

May 13, 2019

Half day on the reef produced a nice Mutton, grouper, yellowtails, and trigger fish Read Full Report →


Permit, Mutton, and sharks

May 11, 2019

Great action all day! Big permit, mutton snapper, sharks, and yellowtails!! Read Full Report →


Snappers!

April 25, 2019

Yellowtail, lane snappers, and sharks! Read Full Report →


Cobias, tuna, king mackeral, sharks, sna

April 23, 2019

Action packed day on the reef. Few cobia, sharks, snappers, and Mackerals. Went deeper looking for a sailfish and caught a tuna. Read Full Report →


Flag yellowtails for Easter

April 15, 2019

All the yellowtail you wanted! Read Full Report →


3 sailfish and released a big black grou

April 14, 2019

Fished a 3/4 anf had 3 sailfish, yellowtails, and released a big black grouper. Read Full Report →


Good Mahi actionand jumped off a sailfis

April 09, 2019

4 hour trip before the weather moved in. Loaded up on ballyhoo and had instant action with the dolphin. Had a sailfish on but pulled the hook on it. Read Full Report →


Mahi, kingsh, and snappers!

April 02, 2019

Actuon all day catching a cooler full of mahi, snappers, and a big smoker on 15 pound test. Read Full Report →


Snapper Trip

March 28, 2019

Flag yellowtails and a mutton snapper. Acti all day on reef. Caught a sharks also. Read Full Report →


Released 1 sailsh and loaded cooler

March 25, 2019

1 sailfish release then ran inside and loaded up on mangrove snapper, porgy, and mackeral! Read Full Report →


Reef trip/fullday

March 15, 2019

Had a 30” mutton, mangroves, yellowtails, porgy, and mackeral. We did hook into a ig wahoo on 30# leader, but lost him after a good battle. Read Full Report →


Gaffer Mahi and snapper

March 10, 2019

Caught a few gaffers while Kite fishing. Went on the reef for an hour and caught some Yellotails. Read Full Report →


Night time tarpon trips have started

February 28, 2019

Good action on our first night tarpon trip of the season. Read Full Report →


Mackeral and snappers on the reef.

February 19, 2019

Plenty of action on the reef for this 4 hour trip. Read Full Report →


Blackfin, dolphin, and sailfish

February 15, 2019

Fished an 8 hour day offshore and jigged blackin tuna. Had a sailfish and a mahi while kite fishing. Read Full Report →


Monday 1/14

January 14, 2019

Stayed on the reef and had great action for a alf day trip. Caught a 29”mutton, yellwtail, king mackeral, and released some grouper. Read Full Report →

Customer Reviews

Rating Summary
Photos by reviewers (9)
4.98
out of 5 stars from 17 reviews
Boat
Crew
Experience
6 hour trip
6 hour trip
6 hour trip
+6
Angler Rating
17
0
0
0
0
Anglers Claimed
Good experience
100%
Friendly captain
100%
Recommend this charter
100%
Appropriate for children
88%
Satisfied with the boat
100%
Catch intended fish
100%
Sort By:
Featured  
Showing:
5 of 17 reviews
Kevin O.
Middletown, New Jersey
 5.00
Experience:
Boat
Crew
Overall
I arrived at the harbor 45min early only to be welcomed by Mike and the crew!  I was astonished that he was already at...
Kevin O. recommends Jersey Key Charters
Mark as helpful
1 person finds this review helpful
You and 1 other person found this helpful
Kevin O. recommends Jersey Key Charters
Mark as helpful
1 person finds this review helpful
You and 1 other person found this helpful

Stephen B.
Hallandale, FL
 5.00
Experience:
Boat
Crew
Overall

Captain Mike is Awesome

VERIFIED   NEW  November 9, 2019
Thanks a lot for taking us out Mike! Extremely personable and experienced captain, Mike went out of his way to ensure everyone...
Stephen B. recommends Jersey Key Charters
Mark as helpful
You found this helpful
Stephen B. recommends Jersey Key Charters
Mark as helpful
You found this helpful

Dave M.
IND HBR BCH, FL
 5.00
Experience:
Boat
Crew
Overall

6 hr blue water

VERIFIED   October 26, 2019
Mike did a great job putting us on fish and making sure we were comfortable.  Two of us limited on yellowtail in 1 hour...
Dave M. recommends Jersey Key Charters
Mark as helpful
You found this helpful
Dave M. recommends Jersey Key Charters
Mark as helpful
You found this helpful

Quinn B.
Westfield, New Jersey
 5.00
Experience:
Boat
Crew
Overall

2 trips aboard the Jersey Key

March 3, 2019
I traveled to the keys for a long weekend of fishing. After doing some research I found Capt Mike and after talking to him...
Quinn B. recommends Jersey Key Charters
Mark as helpful
You found this helpful
Quinn B. recommends Jersey Key Charters
Mark as helpful
You found this helpful

Levi B.
San Juan
 5.00
Experience:
Boat
Crew
Overall

Mike is Great!

VERIFIED   October 23, 2019
Mike took 3 of my kids , my brother and I out yesterday. He took us out to a great spot with lots of action, mostly caught...
Levi B. recommends Jersey Key Charters
Mark as helpful
You found this helpful
Levi B. recommends Jersey Key Charters
Mark as helpful
You found this helpful

Weather Protection
Weather Protection
Canceled due to bad weather? We'll help reschedule or refund.
Best Price Guarantee
Best Price Guarantee
Found the same trip for less? We'll refund the difference!
Service You Can Trust
Service You Can Trust
7 day customer support for a hassle-free fishing experience.
Trusted Payments
Trusted Payments
Book via our secure platform and enjoy flexible payment options.