Benson Nicholas
Captain

Benson Nicholas

Nassau, Bahamas
10+ reviews
Benson Nicholas is a local of the area and has over 30 years of experience fishing these waters. Growing up, most of his brothers and uncles were Captains and fishermen, so he grew up on the water and decided to do it himself. He went to the Navigation school in NY. His favorite moments on the water come when he hooks a big fish. He likes to provide customers with a good experience and lifelong memories.

Charter

Rating

4.5
23 reviews
4.5
Boat & Equipment
4.6
Captain & Crew
4.5
Fishing Experience

All reviews (23)

Showing 1 – 5 of 23 reviews
  • Kevin Markwood
    Kevin Markwood
    Repeat angler
    us
    West Virginia, US
    Member since 2023
    2 trips
    5.0
    Verified

    awesome trip

    Half Day Trip (PM) • 10 adults • 3 children

    had a group of 8 on trip my grandsons age 10 and 6 were the main reason for this trip I had told captain Benson all that I cared about was them catching fish and that we did ! this was a scheduled 4 hour trip from 12 ro 4 but we were on a cruise so our schedule needed to be adjusted a little any other charter I've had elsewhere it was 4 hrs from sight of boat to tail lights leaving. we met captain Benson at the pier at 1130 and around 4 pm I had to tell him we needed to go unless he wanted to haul us to Bimini I swear we could have fished all night if we wanted too. so thankful to him and his first mate for an awesome trip. we will return

  • Alec Geist
    Alec Geist
    us
    Nebraska, US
    Member since 2026
    5.0
    Verified

    Very Kid Friendly.

    Half Day Trip (AM) • 7 adults • 3 children

    Captain Benson was fantastic with our group of seven, including the kids. He was patient, kept everyone engaged, and made sure every single person got a chance to reel something in. He clearly knows these waters and put us right on the fish. The boat was clean and comfortable, and he handled all the bait and rigging so the kids could just enjoy the action. A great day on the water. If you’re visiting Nassau with family, book with Sunshine Charters — you won’t regret it.”

    Reported catch:
    Red Grouper
    Mutton Snapper
    Grunt
  • John Collins
    John Collins
    Repeat angler
    us
    Maryland, US
    Member since 2019
    2 trips
    5.0
    Verified

    Fantastic trip with Captain Benson

    Half Day Trip (AM) • 10 adults

    From the time we arrived at the dock until the end of the charter everything was top notch. Captain took us to 3 different spots and was quick to move when the fish stopped hitting. His crew was fantastic helping the younger anglers with less experience. Great day on the water and next time we are in Nassau will be booking with Captain Benson!

    Reported catch:
    Red Grouper
    Mutton Snapper
    Yellowtail Snapper
    Grunt
  • Brian Klippenstein
    Brian Klippenstein
    us
    Washington D.C., US
    Member since 2025
    5.0
    Verified

    Can-do Captain Benson Team

    Half Day Trip (AM) • 7 adults

    Our family had a blast. The scenery is spectacular but Captain and crew even moreso. Despite difficult conditions ok the water, the crew worked tirelessly to find us fish. In particular, we just loved the big fun personalities of rhe Captain and crew. They were not only professional but helpful and delightful. When we return, we will dedinately hope to rejoin them.

    Response from Captain

    Thank you very much Brian greatly Appreciated

  • Chris  Rothlingshofer
    Chris Rothlingshofer
    us
    Maryland, US
    Member since 2020
    5.0
    Verified

    awesome day

    Full Day Trip • 4 adults

    we really enjoyed our day on the water with Captain Benson. Recommend him anytime although we didn’t catch any tune or a Maui Maui like we had hoped they put us on some bottom fish and we still had a great time. 

Real catches shared by our community

  • Adult angler proudly holding a colorful reef fish aboard a fishing boat in coastal waters.
    Fish 1
    Red Grouper
    Chris  .
    Chris .
    we really enjoyed our day on the water with Captain Benson. Recommend him anytime although we didn’t catch any tune or a Maui Maui like we had hoped they put us on some bottom fish and we still had a great time. 
  • A young boy proudly displays a colorful Snapper he caught while fishing with family on a sunny day at sea.
    Fish 1
    Fish 2
    +1
    Mutton Snapper
    Kevin M.
    Kevin M.
    had a group of 8 on trip my grandsons age 10 and 6 were the main reason for this trip I had told captain Benson all that I cared about was them catching fish and that we did ! this was a scheduled 4 hour trip from 12 ro 4 but we were on a cruise so our schedule needed to be adjusted a little any other charter I've had elsewhere it was 4 hrs from sight of boat to tail lights leaving. we met captain Benson at the pier at 1130 and around 4 pm I had to tell him we needed to go unless he wanted to haul us to Bimini I swear we could have fished all night if we wanted too. so thankful to him and his first mate for an awesome trip. we will return
  • A young angler proudly displaying a large fish on a boat, surrounded by a variety of freshly caught fish, showcasing a successful fishing trip.
    Fish 1
    Fish 2
    +2
    Red Snapper
    John C.
    John C.
    From the time we arrived at the dock until the end of the charter everything was top notch. Captain took us to 3 different spots and was quick to move when the fish stopped hitting. His crew was fantastic helping the younger anglers with less experience. Great day on the water and next time we are in Nassau will be booking with Captain Benson!
  • A young angler proudly displaying a colorful Grouper while fishing on a boat in open waters.
    Fish 1
    Fish 2
    Black Grouper
    Al H.
    Al H.
    What a great trip and adventure! fishing, snorkeling, and turtles. Capt put us on the fish real quick!
  • A young angler proudly displaying a freshly caught Snapper while fishing on a boat in open waters.
    Fish 1
    Fish 2
    +2
    Red Grouper
    Jonpaul P.
    Jonpaul P.
    Had an incredible time on the fishing charter! The staff and captains were amazing—super friendly, knowledgeable, and great with the kids. We caught tons of fish and made some unforgettable memories. Highly recommend for a fun family adventure on the water!

What's biting with Sunshine Charters in Nassau

The rain finally leaves as Wahoo fishing picks up. November is also the beginning of the annual Wahoo Smackdown, which is worth checking out. You've also got active reefs and great flats fishing if that's more your scene.

Top catches for November