Lori Mccoy
Captain

Lori Mccoy

Marathon, United States
50+ reviews
I grew up on the water and have been fishing since I was a little girl. I spent my summers in Destin fishing with family when I was a youngster. I have been fishing and lobstering in Marathon for over 15 years and have made Marathon my home!

Charter

Rating

4.7
89 reviews
4.7
Boat & Equipment
4.7
Captain & Crew
4.6
Fishing Experience

What anglers say

85%
Good experience
95%
Friendly captain
91%
Recommend this charter
92%
Appropriate for children
97%
Satisfied with the boat
89%
Caught fish

Reviews (89)

  • Jad Graves
    Jad Graves
    us
    Florida, US
    Member since 2023
    5.0
    Verified

    Plenty of space for 4 kids and fish

    Half Day Trip (PM) on December 29, 2025 • 6 adults • 2 children

    Kids and I got to learn the finer techniques of yellowtail snapper fishing. 3 peraon limit and took extra time to clean and package the catch for us. Kids had a great time. Stayed anchored up over a chum slick and kept rotating the kids out as they were catching. Recommend for a kid fishing trip.

  • STEVE WOOLUM
    STEVE WOOLUM
    Repeat angler
    us
    Indiana, US
    Member since 2025
    2 trips
    5.0
    Verified

    Great Day Fishing

    Half Day Trip (PM) on February 18, 2026 • 6 adults • 3 children

    we had a great day on the water and caught lots of fish. great experience with the crew, very nice and knowledgeable.

  • JASON SKADSEM
    JASON SKADSEM
    us
    Minnesota, US
    Member since 2024
    5.0
    Verified

    Captain Ricky worked hard and had to re-anchor with changing wind directions caught 40 to 50 fish

    Half Day Trip (AM) on March 20, 2024 • 1 adult

    Good conversation and great fishing

  • Anthony Devoe
    Anthony Devoe
    us
    Florida, US
    Member since 2021
    5.0
    Verified

    Boating trip with Captain Lori and first Mate Ian

    3/4 Day Trip – Mix It Up on July 10, 2021 • 6 adults

    It was an amazing experience!!! The people manning the boat were super kind, supportive, and just fun to be around! They taught us how to do boat fishing, how they chum, and it was a new experience, plus boat fishing is way different from shoreline fishing it turns out. Then the snorkeling was awesome, getting to swim around the nice ocean water was just relaxing as well as fun. Highly recommend going, you’ll have nothing but fun, especially if a fan of fishing, the ocean, and people.

  • Jerry  Onyskiw
    Jerry Onyskiw
    Repeat angler
    us
    Georgia, US
    Member since 2017
    8 trips
    5.0
    Verified

    Mahi time

    3/4 Day Trip – Offshore on July 14, 2021 • 3 adults

    My grandson caught his first mahi-mahi. He caught a total of six mahi of which three were legal size. Kudos to Captain Lori and her first mate Ian for doing a fantastic job before my grandson got nauseous and I asked Lori to take us back. This was my second trip in three days with Captain Lori and I can’t say enough of her friendliness and professionalism. If you need a charter in Marathon call Island Girl Charters. You will not be disappointed

  • Jessi Manthie
    Jessi Manthie
    us
    Minnesota, US
    Member since 2021
    5.0
    Verified

    Awesome half day!

    Half Day Trip (AM) on April 6, 2022 • 6 adults • 2 children

    Thank you Lori and Rick, for making our trip amazing, even with the adjustment for conditions you knew right where bring us to the fish. I also Very happy with your patience in trying to retrain us Minnesotans on how to catch fish island style😁 we will be back!!

  • Jerry Onyskiw
    Jerry Onyskiw
    Repeat angler
    us
    Georgia, US
    Member since 2017
    8 trips
    5.0
    Verified

    Fish on

    3/4 Day Trip – Mix It Up on July 12, 2021 • 3 adults

    The day started with bad weather and Capt Lori waited for storm to hopefully move out. It did and we got going about an hour late. Wonderful fishing on the reef. First time my grandson fished the ocean and caught a nice sized Yellow Jack. We limited out on Yellow And Mangrove snapper. Captain Lori and her first mate Booker were just wonderful. I highly recommend fishing with Captain Lori

  • Troy Grubb
    Troy Grubb
    us
    Florida, US
    Member since 2022
    5.0
    Verified

    Half Day Trip with Captain Lori

    Half Day Trip (AM) on June 6, 2022 • 3 adults • 1 child

    Great trip, highly recommend. Staff was very professional & informative, boat was roomy and comfortable. We are ready to go again!

  • Nicholas Rau
    Nicholas Rau
    Repeat angler
    us
    North Carolina, US
    Member since 2021
    2 trips
    5.0
    Verified

    3/4 day reef fishing

    3/4 Day Trip – Mix It Up on June 1, 2021 • 5 adults • 2 children

    Capt Lori and crew got us on the fish fast and the whole family had a great time. Boat was clean and she knows the waters well. 3/4 day was perfect because it allowed us to move around when the bite slowed to keep the fish coming. Highly recommend!

  • Kyle Sheaffer
    Kyle Sheaffer
    us
    Colorado, US
    Member since 2021
    4.7
    Verified

    Great day on the water

    3/4 Day Trip – Mix It Up on May 28, 2021 • 5 adults

    Loved that Lori was flexible with our mix it up day. We ended up shark fishing and we weren’t even thinking about that as an option but it turned out to be a great adventure! We caught good eats and Lori sent us to an amazing local restaurant Castaways and they cooked it to perfection! We caught so many different varieties of fish it was epic!

Real catches shared by our community

  • A couple proudly stands beside a catch of Snapper displayed on a cleaning table, showcasing their successful fishing trip in a tropical setting.
    Fish 1
    Red Snapper
    William M.
    William M.
    A great day on the water with Lori and Rick! They knew exactly where to fish, kept us reeling all morning to a limit. Heading to the grill now with a fresh catch. Thank you!
  • Multiple snapper-like fish arranged on a fillet table aboard a charter boat in a marina, with anglers nearby.
    Fish 1
    Yellowtail Snapper
    Steve W.
    Steve W.
    we had a great day on the water and caught lots of fish. great experience with the crew, very nice and knowledgeable.
  • A family proudly displaying their catch of colorful fish, including Snapper, at a sunny dockside location.
    Fish 1
    Yellowtail Snapper
    Jad G.
    Jad G.
    Kids and I got to learn the finer techniques of yellowtail snapper fishing. 3 peraon limit and took extra time to clean and package the catch for us. Kids had a great time. Stayed anchored up over a chum slick and kept rotating the kids out as they were catching. Recommend for a kid fishing trip.
  • An angler proudly displaying a large Grouper while fishing on a boat in open waters.
    Fish 1
    Fish 2
    Gag Grouper
    Jason S.
    Jason S.
    Good conversation and great fishing
  • Family group with a young angler posing behind a large dockside display of yellowtail snapper in a tropical marina.
    Fish 1
    Yellowtail Snapper
    Troy G.
    Troy G.
    Great trip, highly recommend. Staff was very professional & informative, boat was roomy and comfortable. We are ready to go again!
  • Young angler proudly holding a freshly caught fish aboard a center-console boat offshore.
    Fish 1
    Fish 2
    Bull Shark
    Jessi M.
    Jessi M.
    Thank you Lori and Rick, for making our trip amazing, even with the adjustment for conditions you knew right where bring us to the fish. I also Very happy with your patience in trying to retrain us Minnesotans on how to catch fish island style😁 we will be back!!
  • A group of anglers posing together at a fishing charter location, showcasing a friendly atmosphere under a clear blue sky.
    Scott H.
    Scott H.
  • Adult angler holding a colorful yellowtail snapper aboard a fishing boat in open ocean waters.
    Fish 1
    Yellowtail Snapper
    Ward D.
    Ward D.
    Had a great time. Hammered the yellow fin. Never seen so many fish. They were in their chum line. Kids wanted to catch a shark for fun. With a quick rig he got each kid the fight of their life. Easily over 6 and 8 ft. I would highly recommend.
  • Shark hooked and swimming alongside a boat in clear coastal water during an active fishing trip.
    Fish 1
    Blacktip Shark
    Kirsten B.
    Kirsten B.
    Had a blast! Caught our limit in yellowtail, then went shark fishing, that was fun! Ended the day with a beautiful sunset cruise.
  • Angler holding a colorful mahi-mahi aboard a sportfishing boat in open ocean waters.
    Fish 1
    Dolphin (Mahi Mahi)
    Jerry O.
    Jerry O.
    My grandson caught his first mahi-mahi. He caught a total of six mahi of which three were legal size. Kudos to Captain Lori and her first mate Ian for doing a fantastic job before my grandson got nauseous and I asked Lori to take us back. This was my second trip in three days with Captain Lori and I can’t say enough of her friendliness and professionalism. If you need a charter in Marathon call Island Girl Charters. You will not be disappointed

What's biting with Island Girl Charters Pet Friendly in Marathon

Permit, Pompano, and Speckled Trout all arrive just as the Snook and Tarpon leave (the world's nice like that sometimes). Jacks join the regular crowd of Snapper and Grouper on the reefs, and there are still Tuna offshore.

Top catches for November