Search
Tony Nesbitt
Captain

Tony Nesbitt

St. Augustine, United States
Federal waters
50+ reviews
Growing up in eastern North Carolina, I spent most of my time on the water learning to fish from my grandfather. Many years later and now that I am approaching the end of my Navy career, I have decided to help share my love for fishing and boating to you. One thing that brings me a lot of enjoyment is seeing others catch a fish of a lifetime followed by the biggest smiling faces and memories that will last a lifetime. I look forward to helping you make those memories.
Tony N.
Tony N.
Captain
Zach T.
Zach T.
Captain

Charter

Rating

5.0
75 reviews
5.0
Boat & Equipment
5.0
Captain & Crew
5.0
Fishing Experience

What anglers say

100%
Good experience
100%
Friendly captain
100%
Recommend this charter
98%
Appropriate for children
100%
Satisfied with the boat
92%
Caught fish

All reviews (75)

Showing 1 – 5 of 75 reviews
  • Jody Snow
    Jody Snow
    us
    North Carolina, US
    Member since 2026
    5.0
    Verified

    Great trip on a poor fishing fay

    4 Hour Trip - Inshore (afternoon) • 2 adults

    It was a windy, somewhat rainy, day for our inshore trip. Captain Tony took us to spots where the fish should be with no luck. Towards the end of our trip he took us to a spot where we caught several Black Sea Bass and two small sharks. We finished our trip near the Bridge of Lions where we caught a large Sheeps Head. To me there us no bad fishing day when you can fish with you son. Captain Tony was great, and I highly recommend his charter.

    Response from Captain

    We definitely delt with some nasty weather this week. I appreciate y’all’s patiences through some tough fishing conditions. Hope you and the family enjoyed your stay here.

  • Leah Mccusker
    Leah Mccusker
    us
    Massachusetts, US
    Member since 2026
    5.0
    Verified

    Best fishing trip!!

    3 Hour Trip - Inshore • 3 adults

    Took my dad fishing for his 65th bday and we had the BEST time!! Tony is great and got us on some great catches. We caught a stingray, nurse shark, red fish, and a sea bass. 10/10 recommend. Tony even suggested a great lunch spot which we thoroughly enjoyed!

    Reported catch:
    Black Seabass
    Redfish
    Response from Captain

    Happy Birthday!!!!!! What a fun morning that was! cant wait to have yall on board again soon.

  • Erica Bowman
    Erica Bowman
    Repeat angler
    us
    Tennessee, US
    Member since 2025
    2 trips
    5.0
    Verified

    2nd trip with Great Daye

    4 Hour Trip - Offshore (afternoon) • 4 adults • 1 child

    Capt. Tony is great! He is quick to communicate, knowledgeable of the area and all the fish, and works hard to make sure someone catches a fish! I would recommend to anyone wanting to go fishing in St. Augustine.

    Reported catch:
    Jack Crevalle
    Response from Captain

    Beautiful day on the water! thank you guys for another fun trip!

  • Terri Bray
    Terri Bray
    us
    Maine, US
    Member since 2026
    5.0
    Verified

    Fantastic fishing morning!

    3 Hour Trip - Inshore • 4 adults

    We had an excellent morning, everyone caught several fish and even one shark! It was a great first time experience for everyone on board—we will definitely be back for more in future visits.

    Reported catch:
    Redfish
    Response from Captain

    What a fun morning that was! Thank you all for spending the morning with me. Looking forward to seeing yall again.

  • Andrew Z
    Andrew Z
    Repeat angler
    us
    New York, US
    Member since 2022
    3 trips
    5.0
    Verified

    Great trip

    3 Hour Trip - Inshore • 4 adults

    Great morning trip with Tony. He knew all the good spots and set us up really well. Fish werent biting as much as we had hoped. In the end we still caught a few and my son caught a 24 inch red fish that he still wont stop talking about. We will be calling Tony next time we are in town. Highly recommend.

    Response from Captain

    Thank you Andrew. It was a pleasure having yall onboard. I look forward to seeing yall next time your in town.

Real catches shared by our community

  • Great Daye Fishing Charters, LLC
    Great Daye Fishing Charters, LLCSt. Augustine, FL
    Best fishing trip!!
    Leah M.
    Leah M.
  • Great Daye Fishing Charters, LLC
    Great Daye Fishing Charters, LLCSt. Augustine, FL
    2nd trip with Great Daye
    Erica B.
    Erica B.
  • Great Daye Fishing Charters, LLC
    Great Daye Fishing Charters, LLCSt. Augustine, FL
    Fantastic fishing morning!
    Terri B.
    Terri B.
  • Great Daye Fishing Charters, LLC
    Great Daye Fishing Charters, LLCSt. Augustine, FL
    June fishing trip
    Jeffrey L.
    Jeffrey L.
  • Great Daye Fishing Charters, LLC
    Great Daye Fishing Charters, LLCSt. Augustine, FL
    Great trip on a poor fishing fay
    Jody S.
    Jody S.
  • Great Daye Fishing Charters, LLC
    Great Daye Fishing Charters, LLCSt. Augustine, FL
    Great Day On The Water!
    Lilah L.
    Lilah L.
  • Great Daye Fishing Charters, LLC
    Great Daye Fishing Charters, LLCSt. Augustine, FL
    Holy Mackerel!
    Justin K.
    Justin K.
  • Great Daye Fishing Charters, LLC
    Great Daye Fishing Charters, LLCSt. Augustine, FL
    Good family fun
    Erica B.
    Erica B.
  • Great Daye Fishing Charters, LLC
    Great Daye Fishing Charters, LLCSt. Augustine, FL
    Captain Tony was a Legend!
    Kathryn K.
    Kathryn K.
  • Great Daye Fishing Charters, LLC
    Great Daye Fishing Charters, LLCSt. Augustine, FL
    Great Daye of fishing!
    Pablo B.
    Pablo B.

What's biting with Great Daye Fishing Charters, LLC in St. Augustine

As the water temperature cools, big Wahoo start to invade the waters offshore from St Augustine. Troll for them at high speed with heavy lures and catch a monster - they can reach over 50 lbs!

Top catches for November

Fishing reports

An angler proudly displaying a large Redfish while fishing on a boat in a calm waterway.

Redfish in the rain!

Mar 10, 2025 • St. Augustine
Yesterday was yet another fun day on the water here in the First City. It took some time for the fish to wake up and bite but when they did it was on. Lots of redfish and a few really nice trout. Everything was caught on a Blue Water Candy Aftershock jig head and a live shrimp. Water temps are holding steady around 62 degrees. Come get your fishing fix!
Show more
A young angler proudly displaying a large Redfish while sitting on the boat at the marina, enjoying a sunny day on the water.

Inshore in the wind!

Mar 4, 2025 • St. Augustine
It was a beautiful start to the day here in Saint Auguatine. The water temps have crept into the low 60’s and the fishing has been very good with several days of double digit reds this week. A live shrimp on a jig head has been the ticket lately both in the creeks and under the docks. Spring is here and the fishing is hot!
Show more