Search
Jeffrey Nagler
Captain

Jeffrey Nagler

New York City, United States
25+ reviews
Captain Jeffrey has 40 years of experience fishing and operating vessels of all kinds. He is a fun person who loves connecting with his guests, both returning and new. He operates the charter out of a deep love and passion for fishing and works with a hardworking crew of mates. Captain Jeffrey and his crew will always do their best to make your day on the water a productive and positive experience.

Charter

Rating

4.7
29 reviews
4.5
Boat & Equipment
4.8
Captain & Crew
4.8
Fishing Experience

All reviews (29)

Showing 1 – 5 of 29 reviews
  • Moshe Glick
    Moshe Glick
    Repeat angler
    us
    New York, US
    Member since 2026
    3 trips

    The captain canceled

    Trip was supposed to happen on September 9, 2026
    The charter operation canceled -13 days after the trip date.
  • Ehab Abdeldayem
    Ehab Abdeldayem
    us
    New York, US
    Member since 2026
    5.0
    Verified

    The best boat in Sheepshead Bay

    6 Hour – Shared Fishing Trip • 4 adults • 2 children

    What an incredible experience! The crew was extremely attentive, friendly, and professional from the moment we stepped aboard. My kids, who are 10 years old, were fishing for the very first time. I was honestly worried they might not catch anything, but the crew made sure they had an amazing experience. Personally, the boat ride alone was worth it, but seeing the excitement on my kids’ faces made the trip unforgettable. They each caught more than 10 fish, and we had an absolute blast! Captain Jeff truly made the day special. You could tell he genuinely enjoys what he does. Every time someone caught a fish, he shared in their excitement, and it was obvious he loved seeing everyone having such a great time. I highly recommend Captain Jeff’s fishing charter, especially for families with children. The crew is knowledgeable, patient, attentive, and truly knows how to create a fun and memorable experience for everyone on board. We can’t wait to come back!

    Reported catch:
    Scup (Porgy)
    Black Seabass
  • Bobby Lopez
    Bobby Lopez
    Repeat angler
    us
    New York, US
    Member since 2026
    4 trips
    5.0
    Verified

    Capt. Jeff, Chris & the rest of the crew were great!

    6 Hour – Shared Fishing Trip • 3 adults

    My second time out on the water with these folks and I had yet another great time. The crew was reponsive, making sure to help whenever our lines got caught in the rocks, and made sure to educate each angler on the legal keep limits. This was my nephew's first time on a fishing boat and the veterans were more than willing to lend a hand whenever he had any difficulties. My wife caught the biggest fish on the boat that trip! I'll be seeing these guys again soon for some more fishing adventures. Bobby & Fam

  • Chris Fusaro
    Chris Fusaro
    us
    New York, US
    Member since 2026
    5.0
    Verified
    NEW

    best trip ever

    6 Hour – Shared Fishing Trip • 9 adults

    bunch of chefs one boat great time crew amazing boat super clean and nice caught fish crew and captain were perfect couldn’t ask for more

    Reported catch:
    Black Seabass
    Striped Bass
    Scup (Porgy)
    Bluefish (Tailor)
  • Kenny Lobillo
    Kenny Lobillo
    us
    New York, US
    Member since 2026
    5.0
    Verified

    Amazing!

    7 Hour – Shared Daytime Trip • 8 adults

    first time on a fishing boat and the expirence was amazing and the crew was excellent definitely recommend it and definitely making another trip with jeff a d his crew

Real catches shared by our community

  • Capt. Jeff's Fishing Excursion
    Capt. Jeff's Fishing ExcursionNew York City, NY
    best trip ever
    Chris F.
    Chris F.
  • Capt. Jeff's Fishing Excursion
    Capt. Jeff's Fishing ExcursionNew York City, NY
    The best boat in Sheepshead Bay
    Ehab A.
    Ehab A.
  • Capt. Jeff's Fishing Excursion
    Capt. Jeff's Fishing ExcursionNew York City, NY
    Amazing!
    Kenny L.
    Kenny L.
  • Capt. Jeff's Fishing Excursion
    Capt. Jeff's Fishing ExcursionNew York City, NY
    Catch fish here.
    J P.
    J P.
  • Capt. Jeff's Fishing Excursion
    Capt. Jeff's Fishing ExcursionNew York City, NY
    Amazing first time
    Humberto G.
    Humberto G.
  • Capt. Jeff's Fishing Excursion
    Capt. Jeff's Fishing ExcursionNew York City, NY
    Great way to spend the day!
    Parnell P.
    Parnell P.
  • Capt. Jeff's Fishing Excursion
    Capt. Jeff's Fishing ExcursionNew York City, NY
    Amazing trip!
    Will Y.
    Will Y.
  • Capt. Jeff's Fishing Excursion
    Capt. Jeff's Fishing ExcursionNew York City, NY
    So much fun
    Heather D.
    Heather D.

What's biting with Capt. Jeff's Fishing Excursion in New York City

The NYC Food & Wine Show presents fine dining from across the globe. Meanwhile, we'll be on the water, catching some tasty Tautog for dinner. We've never really understood nouveau cuisine...

Top catches for October

Fishing reports

Anglers actively reeling in fish during a night fishing trip, showcasing a variety of catches including a large Snapper.

Porgies are biting

Jun 22, 2025 • New York City
Our phones are down, but you can still book tickets here and on our website **hidden content**. We are sailing tonight at 7pm and tomorrow morning at 8:30am. Feel free to show up at the boat as a walk on.
Show more
Angler proudly displaying a large Flounder alongside a catch of various fish on a fishing charter in open waters.

Cocktail blues and Fluke

Jun 18, 2025 • New York City
Cocktail blues mixed in with the Fluke. Book your tickets online at midnight **hidden content** or call Captian Jeff himself.
Show more
Angler in bright yellow fishing bibs proudly holding two large flatfish aboard a boat.

Daily Fluke Fishing

Jun 17, 2025 • New York City
We sail Daily from 8:30am-4pm every day for Fluke. At the moment we are intermittently mixing it up with bottom fishing. Book your tickets here, online at midnight **hidden content**, or call Captian Jeff himself.
Show more
A bucket filled with various fish, including some larger specimens, resting on the deck of a fishing boat.

6/15 Night Trip

Jun 16, 2025 • New York City
Pictures speak for themselves. Rain or Shine, we are sailing every night except Wednesday this week. We are currently using our boat the Capt Jeff Express for all our trips. Book your tickets here, online at midnight **hidden content**, or call Captian Jeff himself. Keep on the lookout on our facebook and instagram **hidden content**
Show more