Captain
Jeffrey Nagler

Member since March 2017 New York City, United States
Background
Captain Jeffrey has 40 years of fishing experience and operating vessels of all kinds. He is a fun person who loves to connect with his guests, both return and new. He operates the charter out of a great love and passion for fishing and works with a hard-working crew of mates. Captain Jeffrey and his crew will always give their best to making your day on the water a productive and positive experience.

Hey, I'm Captain Jeffrey Nagler

New York City, United States
Background
Captain Jeffrey has 40 years of fishing experience and operating vessels of all kinds. He is a fun person who loves to connect with his guests, both return and new. He operates the charter out of a great love and passion for fishing and works with a hard-working crew of mates. Captain Jeffrey and his crew will always give their best to making your day on the water a productive and positive experience.

My Charter Listings

Excellent
4.6 / 5
(164 reviews)
New York City
 2 bookings in the past week.
 Instant Confirmation
Trips from US $65
Excellent
4.6 / 5
(13 reviews)
New York City
 Last booking: 1 day ago
 Instant Confirmation
Trips from US $74

Fishing Reports

Customer reviews

Rating summary
Excellent
4.6 / 5
out of 5 stars from 177 reviews
Boat
Excellent
4.6 / 5
Crew
Excellent
4.7 / 5
Experience
Excellent
4.6 / 5
Photos & videos by reviewers (120)
Catch fish here.
June fishing trip
Great Fishing Trip
+117
Angler rating
135
23
8
1
4
Anglers claimed
Good experience
89%
Friendly captain
97%
Recommend this charter
89%
Appropriate for children
84%
Satisfied with the boat
94%
Caught fish
79%
Sort by:
Featured  
Showing:
5 of 177 reviews
Ibrahim A. A.

The captain canceled

VERIFIED   NEW  June 21, 2025
The charter operation canceled 2 days after the trip date.
Mark review as helpful
1 person finds this review helpful
You and 1 other person found this review helpful
Mark review as helpful
1 person finds this review helpful
You and 1 other person found this review helpful

Nassir H.
Excellent
4.7 / 5
Experience:
Very good
4.0 / 5
Boat
Excellent
5.0 / 5
Crew
Excellent
5.0 / 5
Overall

Great trip and great crew

VERIFIED   NEW  Full Day Trip โ€“ Shared on July 4, 2025
My familyโ€™s first fishing trip and we loved it.ย  First, the crew was great, all 3 guys, very friendly and fun to talk to.ย ...
Nassir H. recommends Midnight Fleet - Midnight Star
Mark review as helpful
1 person finds this review helpful
You and 1 other person found this review helpful
Nassir H. recommends Midnight Fleet - Midnight Star
Mark review as helpful
1 person finds this review helpful
You and 1 other person found this review helpful

Lorenzo S.
Excellent
5.0 / 5
Experience:
Excellent
5.0 / 5
Boat
Excellent
5.0 / 5
Crew
Excellent
5.0 / 5
Overall

A fun experience

VERIFIED   NEW  Full Day Trip โ€“ Shared on July 6, 2025
Captain Jeff and his team are great! Theyโ€™re very helpful. Whenever I go on Captain Jeffโ€™s boat, itโ€™s always a great...
Lorenzo S. recommends Midnight Fleet - Midnight Star
Mark review as helpful
You found this review helpful
Lorenzo S. recommends Midnight Fleet - Midnight Star
Mark review as helpful
You found this review helpful

Lawrence M.
Excellent
5.0 / 5
Experience:
Excellent
5.0 / 5
Boat
Excellent
5.0 / 5
Crew
Excellent
5.0 / 5
Overall

Great Fishing Trip

VERIFIED   Shared PM trip - Magic Hour Fishing on June 1, 2025
Every year my daughters take me fishing on the Midnight Star with Captain Jeff. He always remembers me and is warm and...
Lawrence M. recommends Midnight Fleet - Midnight Star
Mark review as helpful
You found this review helpful
Lawrence M. recommends Midnight Fleet - Midnight Star
Mark review as helpful
You found this review helpful

Jonathan P.
Excellent
5.0 / 5
Experience:
Excellent
5.0 / 5
Boat
Excellent
5.0 / 5
Crew
Excellent
5.0 / 5
Overall

Catch fish here.

VERIFIED   NEW  7 Hour Trip โ€“ Daytime (AM) on June 29, 2025
Captain moved around to get us where the fish were. The mate was very helpful as well.
Jonathan P. recommends Capt. Jeff's Fishing Excursion
Mark review as helpful
You found this review helpful
Jonathan P. recommends Capt. Jeff's Fishing Excursion
Mark review as helpful
You found this review helpful