Search
Reel Busy Sport Fishing Inc.
Captain

Reel Busy Sport Fishing Inc.

Montauk, United States
Federal waters
10+ reviews
Capt. Brian Lilienthal is a OUPV Coast Guard Licensed Captain. He grew up on the South Shore of Long Island, New York. Brian spent his childhood on a boat. Growing up, he fished from the Bahamas to Hawaii, working on various types of boats. Captain Brian has had experience of both commercial and recreational fishing. He enjoys showing his friends and guests various fishing techniques and teach them about the fish species. He says 'there is nothing better than watching someone setting the hook on their first trophy fish!' Capt. Brian brings a lifetime of fishing and area knowledge to every trip. Capt. Brian is looking forward to making his clients 'Reel Busy' for a trip that builds memories to share with family and friends for years to come.
Logan H.
Logan H.
First mate
Hunter S.
Hunter S.
First mate
Logan L.
Logan L.
First mate

Charter

Rating

5.0
18 reviews
4.9
Boat & Equipment
5.0
Captain & Crew
5.0
Fishing Experience

All reviews (18)

Showing 1 – 5 of 18 reviews
  • Jennifer Coughlin
    Jennifer Coughlin
    Repeat angler
    us
    New York, US
    •
    Member since 2026
    •
    2 trips
    5.0
    Verified
    NEW

    BEST FAMILY FISHING TRIP!

    Special 5 hours trip for Jennifer Coughlin • 4 adults

    Fantastic experience. Captain Brian was flexible in planning a shorter charter to accommodate children who couldnt hang for the full 5 hours and was incredible in ensuring we caught plenty of fish. We can’t wait to fish with Captain Brian again!

    Response from Captain

    Jennifer, you guys made it easy. The girls were amazing. Thank you for trusting me with you and your family. I’m sure that your “chef” made a great meal out of the fluke. I’m looking forward to seeing the four of you next time.

  • Tore Sveen
    Tore Sveen
    no
    Norway
    •
    Member since 2026
    5.0
    Verified

    Fantastic day at sea

    Half Day Trip (Morning) • 4 adults

    We had a fantastic day at sea with Brian and Logan. They were very pleasant people, and they really worked hard and long to make sure we caught fish. We caught 7 bluefish, which Logan filleted so we could take them to Star Island Restaurant, where they prepared an absolutely fantastic lunch for us. Thank you so much from all of us.
Victor, Leo, Jon and Tore

    Response from Captain

    Tore & Crew, you guys were amazing. Watching you guys sing the Norwegian National Anthem was something that I will not forget any time soon. Thank you for choosing to fish with us and keep us in mind next time you visit NY.

  • Brian Mackay
    Brian Mackay
    us
    New York, US
    •
    Member since 2026
    5.0
    Verified

    5 Star Fishing

    Half Day Trip (Morning) • 5 adults

    Captain Brian and First mate Cort took my family of five out for a great day fishing. We caught many fish and Captain Brian took us to multiple locations ensuring a successful outing. Highly recommend Reel Busy Sports Fishing !

    Reported catch:
    Black Seabass
    Scup (Porgy)
    Flounder
    Response from Captain

    Brian, you have a great family and you guys did great. Thank you for the kind review and i hope to see you guys again in the future.

  • Aidan Murtagh
    Aidan Murtagh
    us
    New York, US
    •
    Member since 2026
    5.0
    Verified

    awesome trip

    Half Day Trip (Morning) • 6 adults

    caught tons of fish, very nice equipment, captain and crew were very knowledgeable and personable. they will get you on the fish no question. we will definitely be back in the future, cant say enough good things about our trip.

  • Jacob Kaufelt
    Jacob Kaufelt
    us
    New York, US
    •
    Member since 2026
    5.0
    Verified

    Super fun trip

    Half Day Trip – Inshore (PM) • 4 adults

    we started with bottom fishing and caught a variety of weird little fish then we did some trolling, and we were successful in having a couple big fights with some bluefish

    Reported catch:
    Bluefish (Tailor)
    Scup (Porgy)
    Flounder
    Black Seabass
    Response from Captain

    Happy Birthday Jacob. You, the boys and your mom dis a great job. You guy made this a great trip for me. With music playing and the fish biting it was really fun.

Real catches shared by our community

  • Reel Busy Sport Fishing Inc.
    Reel Busy Sport Fishing Inc.Montauk, NY
    Amazing day!
    Andrew M.
    Andrew M.
  • Reel Busy Sport Fishing Inc.
    Reel Busy Sport Fishing Inc.Montauk, NY
    Fantastic day at sea
    Tore S.
    Tore S.
  • Reel Busy Sport Fishing Inc.
    Reel Busy Sport Fishing Inc.Montauk, NY
    awesome trip
    Aidan M.
    Aidan M.
  • Reel Busy Sport Fishing Inc.
    Reel Busy Sport Fishing Inc.Montauk, NY
    montauk
    Len S.
    Len S.
  • Reel Busy Sport Fishing Inc.
    Reel Busy Sport Fishing Inc.Montauk, NY
    Terrific experience with Captain Brian and First Mate Logan
    Melanie C.
    Melanie C.
  • Reel Busy Sport Fishing Inc.
    Reel Busy Sport Fishing Inc.Montauk, NY
    First timer
    Robert N.
    Robert N.
  • Reel Busy Sport Fishing Inc.
    Reel Busy Sport Fishing Inc.Montauk, NY
    Spectacular
    Catherine O.
    Catherine O.
  • Reel Busy Sport Fishing Inc.
    Reel Busy Sport Fishing Inc.Montauk, NY
    Super Moon Super twilight trip
    Vincent M.
    Vincent M.
  • Reel Busy Sport Fishing Inc.
    Reel Busy Sport Fishing Inc.Montauk, NY
    Great Night with my boys
    Brian G.
    Brian G.
  • Reel Busy Sport Fishing Inc.
    Reel Busy Sport Fishing Inc.Montauk, NY
    Outstanding
    Albert A.
    Albert A.

What's biting with Reel Busy Sport Fishing Inc. in Montauk

As some of the crowds die down, the action inshore heats up. This is prime time for another of Montauk's specialities: surf fishing for Stripers. Don't miss the Montauk Surf Classic!

Top catches for September