Mike McGeehan
Captain

Mike McGeehan

St. Augustine, United States
Angler's choice
25+ reviews
Born into a family of fishermen and surfers, being on the water has been the biggest part of Captain Mike's life for over 25 years. He lives and guides out of St. Augustine, Florida specializing in inshore and coastal waters with experience in offshore fishing as well. Having a strong passion for coastal conservation and wealth of knowledge, Captain Mike will take you on an adventure you won't soon forget. Bring your family for a fun day getting to experience the best part of St. Augustine.

Charter

Rating

5.0
45 reviews
5.0
Boat & Equipment
5.0
Captain & Crew
5.0
Fishing Experience

What anglers say

97%
Good experience
100%
Friendly captain
100%
Recommend this charter
100%
Satisfied with the boat
95%
Caught fish

All reviews (45)

Showing 15 of 45 reviews
  • Daniel Wagner
    Daniel Wagner
    us
    Pennsylvania, US
    Member since 2026
    5.0
    Verified

    Caltain Mike does it right!

    Half Day Trip – Inshore2 adults

    Captiain Mike is an awsome dude, he has great gear, and takes the time to get the right bait. He is a great teacher to newies like me to saltwater. Most importantly he doesn’t get stuck doing the same thing he will change baits and change spots until he finds the fish. The morning started off slow but he kept trying to figure the fish out. We eventually figure the reds out ans absolutely crushed em. Me and my wife had a blast! Thaks Captain Mike!!!!

    Reported catch:
    Jack Crevalle
    Redfish
    Response from Captain

    Thanks Daniel, it was great having you and Desi out on the boat! Had a killer time fishing with you guys!

  • Frank Bowman
    Frank Bowman
    Repeat angler
    us
    Michigan, US
    Member since 2025
    2 trips
    5.0
    Verified

    Great Experience

    Half Day Trip – Nearshore2 adults

    We had a great time fishing with Captain Mike. He knew right where all the hot spots were and when to move to the next one. We caught a mixed bag of fish and broight home enough to enjoy a meal with our whole group. would definitely book with island fishing charters again!

    Reported catch:
    Black Drum
    Redfish
    Flounder
    Response from Captain

    Thanks Frank, great time for sure! Looking forward to the next one!

  • Eric Sheehan
    Eric Sheehan
    Repeat angler
    us
    Florida, US
    Member since 2026
    2 trips
    5.0
    Verified

    Great day

    Half day afternoon trip2 adults

    Excellent day on the water with an excellent guide. Capt. Mike put us on the fish. We caught several different species. 4 hour trip was perfect with not a lot of travel. I highly recommend Capt. Mike if you're in this neck of the woods.

    Reported catch:
    Jack Crevalle
    Redfish
    Speckled Trout
    Flounder
    Response from Captain

    Thanks for the great reveiw!

  • John Hunzeker
    John Hunzeker
    us
    Tennessee, US
    Member since 2026
    5.0
    Verified

    Great Experience

    Half day afternoon trip2 adults1 child

    This was a great experience and we caught two red fish, one flounder and one trout. Captain Mike was excellent with my 12 year old son and helped him out a lot. I would recommend this trip for everyone with a great experience!

    Reported catch:
    Flounder
    Redfish
    Speckled Trout
    Response from Captain

    Thanks John, great meeting you guys. looking forward to the next time!

  • Zach Mcfarlane
    Zach Mcfarlane
    us
    Michigan, US
    Member since 2026
    5.0
    Verified
    NEW

    great captain! great boat! great experience!

    6hr near shore4 adults

    captain did whatever he could to get us on fish

    Reported catch:
    Sheepshead
    Response from Captain

    Thanks for the review Zach, great having you guys on the water!

Real catches shared by our community

  • Island Fishing Charters
    Island Fishing ChartersSt. Augustine, FL
    great captain! great boat! great experience!
    Zach M.
    Zach M.
  • Island Fishing Charters
    Island Fishing ChartersSt. Augustine, FL
    Simply Amazing Great Day on the Water
    Creighton A.
    Creighton A.
  • Island Fishing Charters
    Island Fishing ChartersSt. Augustine, FL
    Great Experience
    Frank B.
    Frank B.
  • Island Fishing Charters
    Island Fishing ChartersSt. Augustine, FL
    Fun Time!
    Farrish S.
    Farrish S.
  • Island Fishing Charters
    Island Fishing ChartersSt. Augustine, FL
    Caltain Mike does it right!
    Daniel W.
    Daniel W.
  • Island Fishing Charters
    Island Fishing ChartersSt. Augustine, FL
    Great day
    Eric S.
    Eric S.
  • Island Fishing Charters
    Island Fishing ChartersSt. Augustine, FL
    Wasn’t the best weather but Captain Mike made it an awesome experience!
    Allan N.
    Allan N.
  • Island Fishing Charters
    Island Fishing ChartersSt. Augustine, FL
    Great Experience
    John H.
    John H.
  • Island Fishing Charters
    Island Fishing ChartersSt. Augustine, FL
    Caught every fish imaginable
    Wayne W.
    Wayne W.
  • Island Fishing Charters
    Island Fishing ChartersSt. Augustine, FL
    Mike was great! Highly recommended!!
    Susan B.
    Susan B.

What's biting with Island Fishing Charters in St. Augustine

Although this is usually the wettest month of the year, it has some big rewards for anglers. Sailfish can be found balling bait just 25 miles offshore and flood tides inshore make for amazing sight fishing.

Top catches for September