
John Tuttle
Charter
Rating
Anglers' gallery (19)
Reviews (10)
Matt Messier5.0VerifiedRecommend
4 Hour Trip – Striped Bass on August 8, 2026 • 6 adultsIt was a hot and humid bluebird day. We spent the first hour mackerel fishing with nonstop action. Ended up with 100-150 fish between 6 guys and plenty more that didnt make it in the boat, plus a couple of bonus squid. We spent the rest of the morning trying for stripers, but they weren’t biting unfortunately. We saw a handful of boats nearby that all had similar luck. Captain Butch was great - had a cooler of cold water for us and kept us entertained telling stories, then filleted a big bag of mackerel for us to take home. No big fish but still had a great day on the water with beautiful views.
Krystal Gallant5.0Verifiedbeautiful day out on the water!
4 Hour Trip – Striped Bass - 12:00 PM on June 28, 2026 • 6 adults • 3 children captain Butch took great care of us. black dog was a cery nice, clean boat. We were a group of three adults and 3 10year-olds that would fish everyday if they could! they were prepared and ready! Our mission was to land some striped bass. We spent three hours trying to catch mackerel. We caught some, then a little over an hour trying to catch the bass. We were not successful in catching any bass. The kids were pretty letdown as they were very much looking forward to the experience of reeling in one. had to have a heart felt convo on the way home that it doesnt amways work out. but all in all a great day on the water. It was beautiful. We got to see the aisle of Shoals and went home with a few lobsters. 
Samantha Demar5.0VerifiedCaptain Butch was amazing!
4 Hour Trip – Striped Bass - 12:00 PM on August 1, 2026 • 6 adults • 1 childCaptain Butch made this whole trip for us. He was knowledgable, fun, and made it memorable for my almost 16 year old and 12 year old. I cannot thank him enough for everything. I would highly recommend to anyone looking for great quick charter. We also spoke to Jon before departing and he was professional and kind.
Lorna Illerbrunn5.0VerifiedAwesome day on the water
3 Hour Trip – Lobster - 1:00 PM on July 3, 2026 • 4 adults • 2 childrenHad a great time with Butch and John, who were so kind, funny and patient wrangling my friend and I’s two excited 10 year olds that were eager to help. Great memories! Tuck and I will get out for another trip with you guys before school starts!
Justin Manseau5.0VerifiedGreat trip!
4 Hour Trip – Striped Bass on September 12, 2026 • 5 adultsWe will definitely go with this charter again.
Jeremy BambaraRepeat angler5.0VerifiedGreat Trip
3 Hour Trip – Lobster on July 31, 2026 • 5 adults • 1 childWe had a great time, day was beautiful and we hauled in a lot of lobster. Captain and crew were top notch and took time to explain the process. Recommended!
Roger Doyle5.0VerifiedWe would have liked to catch more fish more it was perfect for the kids first fishing triip.
4 Hour Trip – Striped Bass - 12:00 PM on August 15, 2026 • 5 adultsThe experience was great for the first time fishermen. The captain was equally friendly and did his best to keep everyone involved.
Matt Peppler5.0VerifiedGreat trip
4 Hour Trip – Striped Bass on August 15, 2026 • 6 adultsA wonderful trip with family, lucky to catch some fish good enough to eat. The Captain is very capable and engaging
Cynthia Constantino5.0VerifiedGreat trip!!
4 Hour Trip – Striped Bass - 12:00 PM on August 8, 2026 • 6 adultsCaptain was great; knowledgeable and enjoyable to be with. Many fish were caught! Highly recommend!!
Brad Simpkins5.0VerifiedGreat trip
8 Hour Trip – Bottom Fishing on July 24, 2026 • 2 adultsGreat day on the water. Caught fish all day. Highly recommend.
Real catches shared by our community
Black Dog ChartersRye, NH
Black Dog ChartersRye, NH
Black Dog ChartersRye, NH
Black Dog ChartersRye, NH
Black Dog ChartersRye, NH







