Captain

Pete Casale

Montauk, United States

10+ reviews

Capt. Pete has been fishing in Montauk for over 30 years. He first gained much respect among local anglers by working as first mate for some of the town's most demanding captains, and his considerable experience he has landed some of the area's top tournament winners. Pete has been captain of My Mate for the past twelve years, during which time he has perfected his customer service and become a valued member of the Montauk charter boat fleet.

Charters

My Mate Charters
Montauk
Trips from
US $800
My Mate Charters – Shark Fishing
Montauk
Trips from
US $1,500

Rating

4.8

10 reviews

4.8

Boat & Equipment

4.8

Captain & Crew

4.8

Fishing Experience

Anglers' gallery (7)

All reviews (10)

Showing 1 – 5 of 10 reviews

Tera Goldsmith
New York, US
Member since 2026
5.0
Verified
Fishing with Pete
Trip for Tera on June 21, 2026 • 2 adults
We went for sharks but didn't see any. Sometimes that's the way it is. Capt Pete and First Mate Tyler did a great job of trying. We had an awesome day despite missing out on the sharks. Would absolutely try again.
Matt Williams
New York, US
Member since 2026
5.0
Verified
Fishing with Pete
5 Hour Trip – Fluke or Sea Bass on July 12, 2026 • 3 adults
Awesome day with Captain Pete and 1st mate Tyler today
Reported catch:
Robert Plumaker
New York, US
Member since 2020
5.0
Verified
Half Day w Capt Pete
Half Day Bass inshore Am Trip on August 11, 2023 • 4 adults
Great morning on the water. Captain Pete and 1st mate Brandon made the trip memorable with plenty of fights!
Reported catch:
Adam Miura
Repeat angler
New York, US
Member since 2021
6 trips
5.0
Verified
July fishing trip
4 Hour Trip – Kids Fishing on July 25, 2023 • 4 adults • 1 child
Reported catch:
Response from Captain
July 26, 2023
Thx for coming hope to see you in the Fall or next year. Capt Pete
Stan Persky
Colorado, US
Member since 2016
5.0
Verified
half day trip with Capt. Pete on My Mate
Half Day Bass inshore Am Trip on August 9, 2017 • 2 adults
Very pleasant, no-pressure day with Capt. Pete and mate, Steve. Competent, professional. All one could ask for. No one can put fish on your line, no matter what they advertise. The time we spent on the water was totally satisfying.
Reported catch:
Response from Captain
August 25, 2017
Awesome Stan was a pleasure having you guys on the boat

Real catches shared by our community

My Mate ChartersMontauk, NY
Striped Bass
Gary W.10 years ago
Arrived and they we're ready to go fast. Hit the tide and immediately started bagging big striped bass Captain and Mate are experts. Great experience for me and my 3 kiddos 11, 15, 17 All rookies trained to pros. Bottom line: Captain Pete and Mate Steve's expertise ensured we killed it. -Gary.

Our Fishing Locations

What's biting with My Mate Charters in Montauk

By November, the offshore pelagics have generally moved on, with the action now staying steadily closer to home. Make the most of the open season for Blackfish (Tautog) and keep chasing those Stripers!