Search
Secret Cays
Charter operator

Secret Cays

Nassau, Bahamas
25+ reviews
Secret Cays offers sportfishing, private, and group powerboat tours to some of the most beautiful islands in The Bahamas, including to the Famous Swimming Pigs of Exuma and Eleuthera.

Charter

Rating

4.3
31 reviews
4.6
Boat & Equipment
4.4
Captain & Crew
4.1
Fishing Experience

What anglers say

80%
Recommend this charter

All reviews (31)

Showing 1 – 5 of 31 reviews
  • Shawn Crills
    Shawn Crills
    us
    Pennsylvania, US
    Member since 2026
    5.0
    Verified

    top of bukket list fulfilled!

    Half Day Trip (AM) • 2 adults

    Our trip was originally scheduled for Tuesday, but the weather had other plans—too rough to head out. The captain from Secret Cays Charter in Nassau, Bahamas recommended we try again Thursday, and that turned out to be the best decision we could’ve made. My wife and I booked a private trip, and before we even left, he told us the bite had been extremely tough—several boats were out and only one fish had been caught all day. But he didn’t just take us fishing—he went to work. He put in the effort, kept us moving, and never gave up. And because of that, he got us on not one, but TWO incredible Mahi Mahi—a cow and a bull, both around 5 feet long. The cow came in at 40 lbs, and the bull was pushing 50 lbs. In conditions where almost no one else was catching anything, he delivered an unforgettable experience. If you’re booking a fishing trip in Nassau, Bahamas—Secret Cays Charter is hands down the one you want. Hardworking, determined, and knows how to get it done.

    Reported catch:
    Dolphin (Mahi Mahi)
    Response from Charter operator

    thank you. it was a pleasure having you aboard. see you guys next year.

  • Mike Franks
    Mike Franks
    us
    Texas, US
    Member since 2026
    5.0
    Verified

    great boat and crew

    Half Day Trip (PM) • 4 adults • 2 children

    One word. Awesome! Great boat and crew and we had a splendid time. Pet pugs filliwed by snorkle followed by carching 2 barracuda and one tuna. definately going back with captain J!

    Reported catch:
    Great Barracuda
    Blackfin Tuna
    Response from Charter operator

    glad you guys had a great time. see you next year!

  • Michael Korines
    Michael Korines
    us
    New York, US
    Member since 2026
    5.0
    Verified

    Really fun trip great crew

    Half Day Trip (PM) • 2 adults

    Really good trip and crew. Caught a bunch of mahi mahi and then they brought us to a restaurant after to eat. Great experience.

    Response from Charter operator

    it was a great trip with great people. 14 Mahi mahi (4 lost).

  • Grady Lonigan
    Grady Lonigan
    Repeat angler
    us
    Arizona, US
    Member since 2019
    7 trips
    5.0
    Verified

    Winter Wahoo

    Half Day Trip (AM) • 2 adults

    Captain put us on an early winter Wahoo in Jan. easy trolling and relaxed atmosphere. checked all the boxes. thanks!

    Reported catch:
    Wahoo
    Response from Charter operator

    it was a pleasure having you aboard. see you next year.

  • Ryan Veilleux
    Ryan Veilleux
    Repeat angler
    us
    Pennsylvania, US
    Member since 2026
    2 trips
    5.0
    Verified

    Rough day but still put ud on the fish for some bottom fishing

    Half Day Trip (AM) • 3 adults

    great trip,great csptain well worth the morning

    Response from Charter operator

    it was great having you aboard. see you next year.

Real catches shared by our community

  • Secret Cays
    Secret CaysNassau
    Really fun trip great crew
    Michael K.
    Michael K.
  • Secret Cays
    Secret CaysNassau
    great boat and crew
    Mike F.
    Mike F.
  • Secret Cays
    Secret CaysNassau
    top of bukket list fulfilled!
    Shawn C.
    Shawn C.
  • Secret Cays
    Secret CaysNassau
    Rough day but still put ud on the fish for some bottom fishing
    Ryan V.
    Ryan V.
  • Secret Cays
    Secret CaysNassau
    Winter Wahoo
    Grady L.
    Grady L.
  • Secret Cays
    Secret CaysNassau
    Bahama's Fishing Trip
    Jack S.
    Jack S.
  • Secret Cays
    Secret CaysNassau
    Great time
    Steven P.
    Steven P.
  • Secret Cays
    Secret CaysNassau
    Yahooooooo for the Wahoooooo
    James T.
    James T.
  • Secret Cays
    Secret CaysNassau
    Fishing with Javano
    Keith B.
    Keith B.
  • Secret Cays
    Secret CaysNassau
    Fishing with Javano
    Kevin H.
    Kevin H.

What's biting with Secret Cays in Nassau

The heat and the rain finally start coming to a halt in October, and with them, so do a lot of the offshore species. Wahoo are starting to arrive, though, and there are always Bonefish inshore.

Top catches for October

Fishing reports

A collection of Mahi Mahi laid out on the deck of a boat, showcasing a successful fishing trip.

14 Mahi Mahi and 1 Cuda Offshore

Aug 28, 2026 • Nassau
Its a secret! 14 Mahi Mahi + 1 cudda.
Show more
Group of anglers proudly displaying their catch of Wahoo while on a fishing charter in clear blue waters.

Photo needs no title #wahoowarriors.

Feb 25, 2026 • Nassau
Its a secret
Show more
Two large Wahoo stored in a cooler aboard a fishing boat, showcasing a successful offshore fishing trip.

The wahoo were biting

Feb 25, 2026 • Nassau
Its a secret
Show more
Anglers proudly displaying a vibrant Mahi Mahi caught during a deep-sea fishing trip.

Gooday, Good fish, Good people..

Feb 12, 2026 • Nassau
Wahoo and Mahi action
Show more
A large Wahoo is displayed on the deck of a fishing boat, showcasing the catch after a successful fishing trip.

Wahoo vs sharks

Jan 3, 2026 • Nassau
Its a secret.
Show more
Young angler proudly holding a large Wahoo while fishing offshore, showcasing a successful day on the water.

Wahoo action

Jan 2, 2026 • Nassau
Its a secret
Show more