What would you recommend to anglers fishing in St. James City, Florida for the first time?

Answers by verified FishingBooker anglers who went fishing in St. James City

Sort by:
Sort by: Recommended
Showing:
1 - 9 of 9 answers
customer-avatar
Matthew Guinn
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Make A Wake – Matlacha on April 3, 2026
We went out and the wind picked up. If it had been expected he probably would have canceled our trip. He was very upbeat and we caught a lot of different kinds of fish. My son caught a young Bull Shark, and we caught a variety of fish including: snook, lady fish, sea trout, jack, catfish, mackerel, red fish and a shark. We had fun and learned a lot about the area's fishing patterns and waters. We will be back to fish again.

customer-avatar
Tony Lee
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Maxed Out Charters 2 - Homasassa on June 21, 2024
I highly recommend booking with Captain Justin Williams, we caught so much fish and had a blast. Captain Justin asked us what we wanted to catch and took us to the hot spots, showed us fishing techniques and shared stories. He even described the surrounding, it was like we were on a tour and not just fishing. We saw dolpins and manatees. It was so fun, we are definitely booking again.

customer-avatar
Luciano Taffetani
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Unrivaled Charters on March 28, 2026
Enjoy this magnificent place from the scratch. Great work from Kyle, hope to arrange a new trip near soon.

customer-avatar
Amy Martin
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Better Days Charter Service on March 7, 2026
If you want to catch the big grouper, do the longer trips that take you out 60+ miles. Fishing in March is not ideal. Better to fish when the water is warmer.

customer-avatar
Samantha Bryant
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Reel Drag Fishing Charters on December 11, 2025
Lots of shark including smalltooth sawfish (has to be reported to FWC) so shark permit is a must along with shark gear.

customer-avatar
Jack Harred
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Unrivaled Charters on May 25, 2024
Talk to your captain, read the regulations on the fish you are likely to catch, and watch videos on YouTube to know what to expect.

customer-avatar
Kathleen Hoose
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Captain Sandy on April 24, 2024
Just enjoy every part of the experience not just catching fish! Soooo much to soak in and enjoy out there!

customer-avatar
John Conlin
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Captain Sandy on February 17, 2024
Long winter tides make for slow moving water. Capt's can still find the fish, but feeding activity (action) greatly increases with speed of moving water.

customer-avatar
Rich Howard
Highland, IL
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Olde Salty Island Charters on April 1, 2023
SJC is a great location to book a charter. Very short ride to your first fishing spot. You won’t waste time riding in the boat.