Captain Pete's Fish Tales

4.9/5 (481 reviews)

Curtis Merritt Harbor Drive, Chincoteague, VA 23336, United States–

Captain Pete's Fish Tales

4.9/5 (481 reviews)

Curtis Merritt Harbor Drive

Chincoteague, VA, United States

Trips & prices Targeted species Boat info What's biting What's included Contact captain

Trips & prices What's included Targeted species Boat info Reviews Contact captain

Sign up with Captain Pete’s Fish Tales if you’re looking for an unforgettable angling adventure out of Chincoteague Island. Captain Pete Wallace has been fishing here for more than 25 years and knows these waters like the back of his hand. He welcomes anglers of all ages and skill levels and will do his best to show you what makes fishing around here so great.

His boat is a 24’ Carolina Skiff that runs on a single 140 HP Suzuki engine and will get you to the fishing grounds in no time. It has a canopy top that will keep you in the shade and a seating area where you can catch your breath and relax. There’s enough room on the boat for up to 6 anglers, so be sure to bring along the rest of the family for the trip.

Fishing for Sharks is Capt. Pete’s specialty, but there are plenty of other species in the sea that you can find. These include Flounder, kingfish, Spanish mackerel, and plenty more. Most of the time you’ll be bottom fishing, and drifting, but you’re welcome to fly fish if you bring your own fly gear.

Conventional fishing gear and live bait caught during your trip are included in the price. Not only that, but your first mate will clean all your catch after the trip so you don’t have to worry about it later. Come on down and create your own tale with Captain Pete’s Fish Tales!

Rating

4.9

481 reviews

440

4.9

Boat & equipment

4.8

Captain & crew

4.9

Fishing Experience

Anglers' gallery (398)

+392

What anglers say

96%

Great experience

98%

Family friendly

99%

Friendly captain

98%

Good boat

98%

Recommended

86%

Caught fish

All reviews (481)

Filter

Sort by: Featured

Featured

Showing 1 – 5 of 481 reviews

David Meffert

4.7

Verified

Super Friendly Captain and Mate

4 Hour Trip – Private (PM) on August 6, 2025 • 4 adults

Often, the people make the experience, and that certainly was the case here. We had less than cooperative weather and conditions, but we still managed to catch some fish. Captain Andrew and Ashley, the mate, were very friendly, and kept us entertained during the slow spots. They were a wealth of local knowledge and turned us on to great restaurants we may have otherwise missed, as well as things to do. The rods were new and in top shape, and we saw lots of dolphins that came around the area we were in. Would recommend this trip, especially if you have smaller kids that want to get out on the water.

Joelann Gilmore

5.0

Verified

Happy 16th Birthday

4 Hour Trip – Private (AM) on July 22, 2025 • 5 adults

This was part of our daughter's 16th birthday and we all had a blast. Everyone caught plenty of fish, a few to keep (which forest mate cleaned), and some amazing memories. Connor was a great captain who made sure we were catching and if we weren't we moved right away. Kevin the first mate was the best. He was on top of getting our fish and bait taken care of. They truly made our day and also made us feel like family. We will be back!

Tanya Helm

5.0

Verified

Best fishing trip ever!

4 Hour Trip – Private (AM) on July 18, 2025 • 2 adults • 3 children

The crew at Fish Tales took my family of 5 out on the Chincoteague inlet this morning and man did we connect with the fish! Constant action and a nice variety of fish. Lots of kingfish and croakers among some others. My kids especially liked reeling in a massive southern sting ray and almost a second. The crew were professional, fun and great with our family. We’ll be booking again next time we’re down. I give Fish Tales my highest recommendation 10/10!

Joshua Landsberger

5.0

Verified

An Absolutely Amazing Fishing Adventure!

Shark Trip – Private on July 9, 2025 • 1 adult • 2 children

Just got back from a fishing trip and it was truly an incredible experience for the whole family! My son and daughter had the time of their lives – they were absolutely thrilled to catch multiple sharks! Seeing their faces light up with each catch was priceless. Beyond the sharks, they also reeled in tons of other cool little fish, keeping them engaged and excited throughout the entire trip. The crew was fantastic, incredibly helpful, and made sure everyone had a blast. We had an amazing time and I highly recommend this charter to anyone looking for a memorable and fun fishing adventure for their family. We'll definitely be back!

Reported catch:

Carlos Savory

5.0

Verified

Wonderful morning on the water in Chincoteague

Eastern Shore Adventure (AM) on July 7, 2025 • 2 adults • 3 children

My family and I had a fantastic morning out on the water! The captain and crew were not only incredibly knowledgeable but also friendly and easy to talk to. My kids were thrilled to catch fish especially my daughter, who has had a tough season and finally landed some catches on this trip! We enjoyed a great variety of fish, explored the island’s ins and outs, spotted wild ponies, and even got a hands-on lesson about crab pots and crabs. We cruised around to different parts of the island and were taken to a beautiful, secluded beach where we spent a relaxing afternoon. This was an unforgettable experience, and I highly recommend it to anyone visiting the area. We’re already looking forward to trying some of the other excursions they offer the next time we visit Chincoteague!

Reported catch:

Trip availability and prices

Trip Date:

Days:

Group Size:

Select date to see availability

January 2026

Su	Mo	Tu	We	Th	Fr	Sa

Number of days

Group Size

2 adults • 0 children

Change

Almost there...

4 Hour Trip – Private (AM)