Custom Charters 

4.8
(40 reviews)
 
State licensed
 85401 Overseas Highway, Islamorada, FL 33036, United States–

Custom Charters 

Islamorada, FL, United States
–
26 ft
4
4.8
(40 reviews)

Having started fishing, diving, lobstering, and metal detecting the Florida Keys since the mid 1980s, I've acquired many locations for success!

Whether you would like to catch Grouper in the morning and snorkel in the afternoon or go to the sandbar for few hours, we can customize the trip for anyone.

Multi-day trips for you and your family and friends for all your fun on the water with a knowledgeable and experienced Captain. T

hank you for considering me, I assure you I will give you 100%

Having served in the Marine Corps I will honor veterans with 10% discount.

Having started fishing, diving, lobstering, and metal detecting the Florida Keys since the mid 1980s, I've acquired many locations for success!

Whether you would like to catch Grouper in the morning and snorkel in the afternoon or go to the sandbar for few hours, we can customize the trip for anyone.

Multi-day trips for you and your family and friends for all your fun on the water with a knowledgeable and experienced Captain. T

hank you for considering me, I assure you I will give you 100%

Having served in the Marine Corps I will honor veterans with 10% discount.

Jim Butler
Captain
Jim Butler
ID & credentials verified
responds within an hour

Select date to see availability

Trip availability and prices

Trip date:
Group Size:
October 2026
SuMoTuWeThFrSa
Loading...
Group Size
2 adults • 0 children
Change
Almost there...
Half day offshore
FREE Cancellation 3 days notice
4 hour trip starts at 8:00 AM
Dolphin (Mahi Mahi)
Wahoo
Grouper (Black)
Grouper (Red)
+5
US $900
Entire boat: up to 4 people
3/4 Day Trip reef
FREE Cancellation 3 days notice
6 hour trip starts at 8:00 AM
Amberjack
Dolphin (Mahi Mahi)
Wahoo
Grouper (Red)
+5
US $950
Entire boat: up to 4 people
3/4 day offshore
FREE Cancellation 3 days notice
6 hour trip starts at 8:00 AM
Dolphin (Mahi Mahi)
Wahoo
Grouper (Black)
Grouper (Red)
+5
US $1,200
Entire boat: up to 4 people
Full day reef and offshore
FREE Cancellation 3 days notice
8 hour trip starts at 8:00 AM
Dolphin (Mahi Mahi)
Wahoo
Grouper (Black)
Grouper (Red)
+5
US $1,400
Entire boat: up to 4 people
There is 1 person looking at this charter.

Customer reviews

Loading...

Rating

4.8
40 reviews
4.8
Boat & equipment
4.8
Captain & crew
4.7
Fishing Experience

Anglers' gallery (31)

What anglers say

93%
Recommended
88%
Caught fish

Reviews (40)

  • Tim Oquinn
    Tim Oquinn
    us
    Florida, US
    Member since 2026
    5.0
    Verified

    one of the best experiences we have had fishing

    Half Day reef fishing Trip (AM) on May 24, 2026 • 2 adults

    we had a great day fishing with Captain Jim caught eight really nice mango snappers. it was a super windy day and choppy..and we had tried to book a few other charters offshore and they all canceled due to the weather so when we booked this with Jim he had the courtesy to call us and let us know that it was way too windy to go to The reef but if we were willing he had some great places he could take us and put us on some fish!!; so we took the chance and man did it pay off! we caught Big Mangrove snapper like you would normally catch on The reef in his private fishing areas not going to tell you where they are! super great guy went out of his way to make sure that we caught fish and that we had a good time I would recommend this to anyone whether you're a beginner or a seasoned fisherman but I am a beginner my husband is seasoned and we both had a wonderful experience!! boat was super clean has a restroom Jim is just totally amazing person can't wait to eat our fresh catch tonight!!

  • John Roush
    John Roush
    Repeat angler
    us
    Ohio, US
    Member since 2018
    3 trips
    5.0
    Verified

    Great day on the water!

    Full day reef and offshore on March 26, 2026 • 2 adults

    My son Jack and I had a wonderful day fishing with Captain Jim! He was a blessingto work with, great equipment and undying devotion to finding the fish. His experience as well as his attitude were spot on. He is the Captain and first mate all in one and works his tail off while you enjoy the blessings of the waters of Islamorada. I highly recommend him and look forward to fishing with him again! Tight lines and Semper Fi!

  • Damon Pelicano
    Damon Pelicano
    us
    New Jersey, US
    Member since 2026
    5.0
    Verified

    couldn't ask for a better captain

    Half Day reef fishing Trip (AM) on August 18, 2026 • 3 adults • 1 child

    My wife, daughter (9), and myself had a blast with Captain Jim. My daughter caught her 1st fish only because of the Captain's expertise and determination! Great time from beginning to end.

  • Anthony Ward
    Anthony Ward
    Repeat angler
    us
    Michigan, US
    Member since 2026
    2 trips
    5.0
    Verified

    Great Trip!

    3/4 Day Trip reef on May 29, 2026 • 2 adults

    Great trip with a great captain. Captain Jim is knowledgeable and professional. We caught some good fish, to include Mahi and Tuna. I would certainly recommend this charter!

  • David Williamson
    David Williamson
    us
    Connecticut, US
    Member since 2026
    5.0
    Verified

    Awesome Day

    Half day reef fishing on January 25, 2026 • 2 adults

    cant beat the Captains knowledge of the area and fishing. Catered to different fishing experience levels helping the less experienced and letting the more experienced do their thing. Got some beautiful fish !

  • Audra Donato
    Audra Donato
    Repeat angler
    us
    Pennsylvania, US
    Member since 2025
    2 trips
    4.3
    Verified

    Spring Break Fishing

    3/4 day offshore on March 23, 2026 • 3 adults

    We had a great time fishing with Captain Jim. We caught two, beautiful Dolphin which we had prepared at a hook & cook. Best fish I ever ate! Thanks Captain Jim.

  • Brian Cecil
    Brian Cecil
    Repeat angler
    us
    California, US
    Member since 2023
    2 trips
    5.0
    Verified

    Captain Jim was AWESOME

    3/4 Day Trip reef on June 12, 2025 • 2 adults • 1 child

    We had an unforgettable day on the water! The captain was fantastic—friendly, knowledgeable, and great with my son. He made the whole trip fun and easy, especially for my boy, and really knew how to put us on the fish. We ended up landing a beautiful wahoo and multiple mahi mahi—my son was thrilled! It was non-stop excitement and definitely a trip we’ll remember for a long time. Highly recommend this charter for anyone looking for a great fishing experience with a top-notch guide.

  • Rachael Ramos
    Rachael Ramos
    br
    Bahia, Brazil
    Member since 2025
    5.0
    Verified

    Caught mahi mahi!

    3/4 Day Trip reef on June 30, 2025 • 4 adults

    Captain Jim was great and his boat had everything we needed. We did the 6 hour trip and caught mahi mahi and almost a wahoo! The kids and us parents loved it and on our return to the marina, Jim filleted the fish and bagged it up in ice for us and we're now about to eat it for dinner 😋😄🎣 Would definitely recommend this fishing charter!

  • Ivory Richardson Jr
    Ivory Richardson Jr
    Repeat angler
    us
    North Carolina, US
    Member since 2019
    3 trips
    5.0
    Verified

    Capt Jim is one heck of a fisherman!

    3/4 Day Trip reef on May 28, 2025 • 3 adults

    We went out today fishing for Mahi, a trip ten years in the effort. Capt Jim put us right on the fish! We left at 8 and had Mahi in the boat by 915! A capt that knows how to drive the waters as well as fish them is a gold mine! 10/10 would go again with Capt Jim- he was amazing!! Great stories, great music, and a plethora of experience, Capt Jim made sure we had a blast!

  • Jesse Ibarra
    Jesse Ibarra
    Repeat angler
    us
    Texas, US
    Member since 2021
    3 trips
    5.0
    Verified

    Captain Jim is on fish right away! His experience made fishing easy and a whole lot of fun! If you’re around Islamorada for vacation or the keys, book a trip with Captain Jim and he will put you on some fish!

    Half Day reef fishing Trip (AM) on June 14, 2025 • 2 adults

    Went out today with Captain Jim and had one heck of an experience catching Wahoo, Mahi, and black fin tuna! If you want to get on some fish, go out with Captain Jim! His experience made fishing so easy today! Thanks again for the mementoes today Captain Jim! Andrew and I enjoyed it! We will be back to get on them fish again!!

Rating

4.8
40 reviews
4.8
Boat & equipment
4.8
Captain & crew
4.7
Fishing Experience

Anglers' gallery (31)

What anglers say

93%
Recommended
88%
Caught fish

All reviews (40)

Frequently mentioned
Showing 1 – 5 of 40 reviews
Tim Oquinn
Tim Oquinn
us
Florida, US
Member since 2026
5.0
Verified
one of the best experiences we have had fishing
Half Day reef fishing Trip (AM) on May 24, 2026 • 2 adults

we had a great day fishing with Captain Jim caught eight really nice mango snappers. it was a super windy day and choppy..and we had tried to book a few other charters offshore and they all canceled due to the weather so when we booked this with Jim he had the courtesy to call us and let us know that it was way too windy to go to The reef but if we were willing he had some great places he could take us and put us on some fish!!; so we took the chance and man did it pay off! we caught Big Mangrove snapper like you would normally catch on The reef in his private fishing areas not going to tell you where they are! super great guy went out of his way to make sure that we caught fish and that we had a good time I would recommend this to anyone whether you're a beginner or a seasoned fisherman but I am a beginner my husband is seasoned and we both had a wonderful experience!! boat was super clean has a restroom Jim is just totally amazing person can't wait to eat our fresh catch tonight!!

Jim Butler
Response from Captain

thank you very much! that was a great trip for improvised bad weather day!

John Roush
John Roush
Repeat angler
us
Ohio, US
Member since 2018
3 trips
5.0
Verified
Great day on the water!
Full day reef and offshore on March 26, 2026 • 2 adults

My son Jack and I had a wonderful day fishing with Captain Jim! He was a blessingto work with, great equipment and undying devotion to finding the fish. His experience as well as his attitude were spot on. He is the Captain and first mate all in one and works his tail off while you enjoy the blessings of the waters of Islamorada. I highly recommend him and look forward to fishing with him again! Tight lines and Semper Fi!

Reported catch:
Mutton Snapper
Yellowtail Snapper
Jim Butler
Response from Captain

Thank you for fishing with me and your review! Hope to see you in the future,.

John O'Hear
John O'Hear
Repeat angler
us
Massachusetts, US
Member since 2025
2 trips
5.0
Verified
We had a great time, plan to book again
Half Day reef fishing Trip (AM) on March 1, 2026 • 2 adults

Jim was great, he was super flexible and allowed us to do what we wanted to do. He also did a great job explaining our fishing strategy and he worked hard to get us on fish. We had a slow day fishing so he even took the time to show us some reefs and reef fish on the way in and gave us extra time out on the water. We are looking forward to booking again with him!

Jim Butler
Response from Captain

Thanks, I really enjoyed having you aboard Custom Charters, looking forward to your return.

Damon Pelicano
Damon Pelicano
us
New Jersey, US
Member since 2026
5.0
Verified
couldn't ask for a better captain
Half Day reef fishing Trip (AM) on August 18, 2026 • 2 adults • 1 child

My wife, daughter (9), and myself had a blast with Captain Jim. My daughter caught her 1st fish only because of the Captain's expertise and determination! Great time from beginning to end.

Reported catch:
Dolphin (Mahi Mahi)
Jim Butler
Response from Captain

Thank you very much! I was determined your sweet daughter was going to catch a Mahi.

Joe Robert
Joe Robert
Repeat angler
us
Pennsylvania, US
Member since 2023
6 trips
5.0
Verified
We caught a sailfish and had lots of fun!
Half Day reef fishing Trip (AM) on July 22, 2026 • 1 adult • 1 child

Captain took care of my son and me, and we had lots of fun. We caught some fish and enjoyed the day together. Captain was great and made the trip special for my birthday.

Jim Butler
Response from Captain

Thank you very much! Great half day fishing

FAQs about Custom Charters

Custom Charters offers the following trips to customers:
  • US $900 per group - Half day offshore (4 hours)
  • US $950 per group - 3/4 Day Trip reef (6 hours)
  • US $1,200 per group - 3/4 day offshore (6 hours)
  • US $1,400 per group - Full day reef and offshore (8 hours)
When you book a trip with Custom Charters, you can expect the following amenities onboard:
  • Toilet Full enclosed bathroom
  • GPS
  • Fishfinder
  • Snorkeling equipment
  • Live bait well
  • Outriggers
  • Spearfishing equipment
  • Ice box
Trips booked with Custom Charters include:
  • Rods, reels & tackle
  • Live bait (We may stop and throw castnet for livebait)
  • Lures
  • Catch cleaning & filleting (I will clean and bag your fish.)
  • First mate (On certain occasions )
  • Fishing license (All fishing licenses are included )
Custom Charters offers the following types of fishing:
  • Nearshore fishing
  • Offshore fishing (Depending on conditions and where the fish are we may go up to 15 or 20 miles offshore)
  • Reef fishing
  • Wreck fishing
Custom Charters offers the following fishing techniques:
  • Light tackle
  • Heavy tackle
  • Bottom fishing
  • Trolling
  • Spearfishing
  • Deep sea fishing
Top targeted fish species with Custom Charters include:
  • Dolphin (Mahi Mahi)
  • Grouper (Black)
  • Grouper (Red)
  • Rainbow Runner
  • Shark (Nurse)
  • Snapper (Mutton)
  • Snapper (Yellowtail)
  • Tuna (Blackfin)
  • Wahoo

Your captain

Jim Butler
Jim Butler
Islamorada, Florida, United States
4 Fishing Reports
ID & license verified
40 Customer reviews
Typical response within an hour
Member since April 2025
Angler's Choice
The Angler's Choice Award is given to listings that consistently deliver a high-quality service and earn great reviews from customers.
I started fishing as a kid fishing for Smallmouth Bass on mid-west rivers. In the mid 1980's started fishing the Florida Keys and became hooked on the offshore fishing!
Jim Butler
Jim Butler
Fully verified
Angler's Choice
4
reports
40
reviews
2025
member since
~1h
response
I started fishing as a kid fishing for Smallmouth Bass on mid-west rivers. In the mid 1980's started fishing the Florida Keys and became hooked on the offshore fishing!

The fish you can target

Dolphin (Mahi Mahi)
Dolphin (Mahi Mahi)
Black Grouper
Black Grouper
Red Grouper
Red Grouper
Rainbow Runner
Rainbow Runner
Nurse Shark
Nurse Shark
Mutton Snapper
Mutton Snapper
Yellowtail Snapper
Yellowtail Snapper
Blackfin Tuna
Blackfin Tuna
Wahoo
Wahoo
Dolphin (Mahi Mahi)
Dolphin (Mahi Mahi)
Black Grouper
Black Grouper
Red Grouper
Red Grouper
Rainbow Runner
Rainbow Runner
Nurse Shark
Nurse Shark

Real catches by this captain

  • couldn't ask for a better captain
    Damon P.
    Damon P.
  • Great Trip!
    Anthony W.
    Anthony W.
  • one of the best experiences we have had fishing
    Tim O.
    Tim O.
  • Great day on the water!
    John R.
    John R.
  • Spring Break Fishing
    Audra D.
    Audra D.
  • Nice day out on the water with little fish
    Georg T.
    Georg T.
  • Awesome Day
    David W.
    David W.
  • Great Trip with a Friendly, Capable Guide
    Brent W.
    Brent W.
  • August fishing trip
    Kelly T.
    Kelly T.
  • Awesome time with Captain Jim!!!
    Erik C.
    Erik C.

What is the boat like?

Boat image
Boat category
Center console boats
Capacity
4 persons
Boat length
26 ft
Year built
2017
Boat manufacturer
Sea Fox
Boat type
Center console
Engine model
Yamaha
Powered by
2 x 150HP
Max cruising speed
40 knots

What kind of fishing will you do?

Nearshore Fishing
Offshore Fishing
Reef Fishing
Wreck Fishing

Which fishing techniques you can try

Light Tackle
Heavy Tackle
Bottom Fishing
Trolling
Spearfishing
Deep Sea Fishing

Which amenities are available onboard

Toilet
Full enclosed bathroom
GPS
Fishfinder
Snorkeling equipment
Live bait well
Outriggers
Spearfishing equipment
Ice box
What's included in the trip price
Rods, reels & tackle
Live bait
We may stop and throw castnet for livebait
Lures
Catch cleaning & filleting
I will clean and bag your fish.
First mate
On certain occasions
Fishing license
All fishing licenses are included

How cancellations work

Free cancellation up to 3 days prior to trip
You can cancel or modify your booking up to 3 days before the trip date, free of charge. If you cancel or modify your booking later, or fail to show up, you'll forfeit 100% of what you've paid.
More details

What the listing policies are

Pickup not included
Transfer to/from departure site is not included in trip rates.
Child friendly
No age restrictions , I'm a father 3 grandfather of 6.
You keep catch

How you can pay

Book with 10% deposit, pay rest to captain
When the captain confirms your trip, FishingBooker charges your credit card a 10% deposit to guarantee your reservation.
The remaining balance is to be paid directly to the charter operator on or prior to your trip date in one of the following payment methods:
 Cash
 Visa
 Mastercard
 PayPal
 Checks
 Bank transfer
When paying the remaining balance with a credit card, an additional 3% charge will apply.

What’s biting in Islamorada right now

Dolphin (Mahi Mahi)Dolphin (Mahi Mahi)
Grouper (Black)Grouper (Black)
Grouper (Red)Grouper (Red)
Snapper (Mutton)Snapper (Mutton)
Snapper (Yellowtail)Snapper (Yellowtail)
Tuna (Blackfin)Tuna (Blackfin)
WahooWahoo

Compare similar fishing charters

Current
Custom Charters
Custom Charters
State licensed
4.8
(40)
26 ft
Group size 1 - 4
1 - 4
Fish 1
Fish 2
+7
4 hour trip • 4 persons
US $900