Montauk Fishing – Charterboat Oh Brother
See why these East Coast waters are one of a kind aboard “Montauks Oh Brother”! Whether you’re a family looking for a fun activity, a corporate group, or experienced anglers, you’ll enjoy heading out with this crew. Captain Rob Aaronson is a multi-tournament-winning pro who’s worked in nearly every fishery on the East Coast.
Hop aboard his 40’ custom Downeast vessel ideal for up to 6 passengers on day trips. She’s got a spacious interior with a head and a large back deck to fish from. The latest in GPS and Fish Finder technology keeps you on top of your targets and the live well entices their bite.
Head into the deep and explore the offshore waters for Tuna, Marlin, Shark, and Mahi. If you’d prefer to stay closer to shore, it’s all about Striped Bass, Fluke, Black Seabass and more.
At the end of the day, the crew is happy to clean and fillet your catch.
Make sure to pack enough drinks and snacks to keep you going in an iced cooler, and dress for the season.
Customer reviews
Rating summary
Photos & videos by reviewers (23)
+20Angler rating
Anglers claimed
Good experience
100%
Appropriate for children
84%
Friendly captain
100%
Satisfied with the boat
100%
Recommend this charter
100%
Caught fish
100%
Aug 4, 2025
Block Island 5hr trip
Wonderful trip
We had a great day fishing with the crew of “Oh Brother” Capitan Rob knew where all the fish were and we caught big Blue Fish almost immediately. Then we switched up to bottom fishing and we caught so many bass we couldn’t keep count. Capt. Rob caught a Shark, it got away, but it was exciting to watch him reel it in. Overall it was a fantastic first fishing trip for our teenagers. John was very nice and patient with the kids, and he cleaned and prepared the fish for us to take with us, right on the boat. We had an amazing fish dinner when we got back to our hotel and didn’t need to do much. High recommend
We had a great day fishing with the crew of “Oh Brother” Capitan Rob knew where all the fish were and we caught big Blue Fish...
May 3, 2025
Block Island 5hr trip
Great Charter!
Captain Rob and mat Jon were awesome. First trip of the season and each of us were able to get some fish! They were very knowledgeable of the area and gave great recommendations to do to after. Highly recommend!
Captain Rob and mat Jon were awesome. First trip of the season and each of us were able to get some fish! They were very knowledgeable...
Captain replied
Jun 30, 2024
5 Hour Trip – Inshore (AM)
Best captain in Montauk
We have been fishing with Rob for 30 years. He is the best and will make your fishing experience memorable.
We have been fishing with Rob for 30 years. He is the best and will make your fishing experience memorable.
New York, New York
Jul 30, 2021
5 Hour Trip – Inshore (AM)
Half day trip with Capt Rob
Captain and mate do a great job. We left a half hour early at Capt Rob’s suggestion cause the bite was more around sunrise. He was spot on. We caught one exceptional striped bass. Too big to keep so photo and release. We were catching multiple bass on the same rig! Both mate and captain were beyond our expectations. I have been fishing Montauk since the mid 80s and these guys are one of the best!
Captain and mate do a great job. We left a half hour early at Capt Rob’s suggestion cause the bite was more around sunrise. He...
Port Jefferson, New York
Jul 5, 2022
5 Hour Trip – Inshore (PM)
Fishing with Rob
You want to go to Montauk and catch fish? Hire this Captain. This is not a nice little whale watching, dolphin spotting tour. This is a MONTAUK FISHING BOAT. You will surely be exhausted from catching fish all day. We limited out on bass before charter was even over. This boat catches fish, plain and simple.
You want to go to Montauk and catch fish? Hire this Captain. This is not a nice little whale watching, dolphin spotting tour....
Trip availability and prices
| Su | Mo | Tu | We | Th | Fr | Sa | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Customer reviews
Rating summary
Photos & videos by reviewers (23)
+20Angler rating
Anglers claimed
Good experience
100%
Appropriate for children
84%
Friendly captain
100%
Satisfied with the boat
100%
Recommend this charter
100%
Caught fish
100%
Experience:
Boat
Crew
Overall
Wonderful trip
Block Island 5hr trip on August 4, 2025
We had a great day fishing with the crew of “Oh Brother” Capitan Rob knew where all the fish were and we caught big Blue Fish almost immediately. Then we switched up to bottom fishing and we caught so many bass we couldn’t keep count. Capt. Rob caught a Shark, it got away, but it was exciting to watch him reel it in. Overall it was a fantastic first fishing trip for our teenagers. John was very nice and patient with the kids, and he cleaned and prepared the fish for us to take with us, right on the boat. We had an amazing fish dinner when we got back to our hotel and didn’t need to do much. High recommend
We had a great day fishing with the crew of “Oh Brother” Capitan Rob knew where all the fish were and we caught big Blue Fish almost immediately. Then we switched up to bottom fishing and we caught so many bass we couldn’t keep count. Capt. Rob caught a Shark, it got away, but it was exciting to watch him reel it in. Overall it was a fantastic first fishing trip for our teenagers. John was very nice and patient with the kids, and he cleaned and prepared the fish for us to take with us, right...
Experience:
Boat
Crew
Overall
Great Charter!
Block Island 5hr trip on May 3, 2025
Captain Rob and mat Jon were awesome. First trip of the season and each of us were able to get some fish! They were very knowledgeable of the area and gave great recommendations to do to after. Highly recommend!
Captain Rob and mat Jon were awesome. First trip of the season and each of us were able to get some fish! They were very knowledgeable of the area and gave great recommendations to do to after. Highly recommend!
Experience:
Boat
Crew
Overall
Best captain in Montauk
5 Hour Trip – Inshore (AM) on June 30, 2024
We have been fishing with Rob for 30 years. He is the best and will make your fishing experience memorable.
We have been fishing with Rob for 30 years. He is the best and will make your fishing experience memorable.
New York, New York
Experience:
Boat
Crew
Overall
Half day trip with Capt Rob
5 Hour Trip – Inshore (AM) on July 30, 2021
Captain and mate do a great job. We left a half hour early at Capt Rob’s suggestion cause the bite was more around sunrise. He was spot on. We caught one exceptional striped bass. Too big to keep so photo and release. We were catching multiple bass on the same rig! Both mate and captain were beyond our expectations. I have been fishing Montauk since the mid 80s and these guys are one of the best!
Captain and mate do a great job. We left a half hour early at Capt Rob’s suggestion cause the bite was more around sunrise. He was spot on. We caught one exceptional striped bass. Too big to keep so photo and release. We were catching multiple bass on the same rig! Both mate and captain were beyond our expectations. I have been fishing Montauk since the mid 80s and these guys are one of the best!
Port Jefferson, New York
Experience:
Boat
Crew
Overall
Fishing with Rob
5 Hour Trip – Inshore (PM) on July 5, 2022
You want to go to Montauk and catch fish? Hire this Captain. This is not a nice little whale watching, dolphin spotting tour. This is a MONTAUK FISHING BOAT. You will surely be exhausted from catching fish all day. We limited out on bass before charter was even over. This boat catches fish, plain and simple.
You want to go to Montauk and catch fish? Hire this Captain. This is not a nice little whale watching, dolphin spotting tour. This is a MONTAUK FISHING BOAT. You will surely be exhausted from catching fish all day. We limited out on bass before charter was even over. This boat catches fish, plain and simple.
FAQs about Montauk Fishing – Charterboat Oh Brother
The fish you can target
What is the boat like?
